Abraham Nuscrack
Team Captain
Not sure Scully will play SANFL next yr anyway from some whispers I've heard
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. List Management 2024-25
- Thread starter Long live PAFC
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I've got no issues with those five guys be delisted or looking for better opportunities.
Abraham Nuscrack
Team Captain
Think L Evans needs to be upgraded? That leaves 5, dare say we will leave a spot free for mid-season draft? So looking at drafting 4 in then?
Scully is very stiff. 200cm+ young tall will naturally take a few years to get up to speed. He was tracking just as you’d expect/hope.
Finlayson or T. Marshall will need to spend some of preseason down back. It might be good for Todd- he can punch some forwards in the back of the head instead of being punched himself.
We’ve lost all our TB reserves- K.Marshall, Clurey, McKenzie. I don’t want Lukosius being chopped and changed between CHF and CHB. Walsh has exceeded expectations but I don’t think he is AFL ready yet.
Finlayson or T. Marshall will need to spend some of preseason down back. It might be good for Todd- he can punch some forwards in the back of the head instead of being punched himself.
We’ve lost all our TB reserves- K.Marshall, Clurey, McKenzie. I don’t want Lukosius being chopped and changed between CHF and CHB. Walsh has exceeded expectations but I don’t think he is AFL ready yet.
There must be something else is going on with Scully.
At the start of his draft year, some people had him number 1 overall.
That's a pretty big fall.
At the start of his draft year, some people had him number 1 overall.
That's a pretty big fall.
- Mar 26, 2007
- 21,150
- 45,678
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- SA Spurs, Anaheim Ducks, White Sox
So only the one surprise in Clurey.
Sounds like they have a confirmation he will go somewhere else which decreases the salary we have to pay him.
Does position us interestingly for the draft though. Gives us a 5th pick which it felt like we desperately needed given how many delist targets we have for next year. We should be able to take a rookie now, probably Rome Burgoyne. We also near certainly will need another key back at the draft too. I also presume Walsh will go back to defence after playing the last part of the year up forward.
Sounds like they have a confirmation he will go somewhere else which decreases the salary we have to pay him.
Does position us interestingly for the draft though. Gives us a 5th pick which it felt like we desperately needed given how many delist targets we have for next year. We should be able to take a rookie now, probably Rome Burgoyne. We also near certainly will need another key back at the draft too. I also presume Walsh will go back to defence after playing the last part of the year up forward.
- Mar 26, 2007
- 21,150
- 45,678
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- SA Spurs, Anaheim Ducks, White Sox
Just found out the players were told Friday.
- Jan 5, 2013
- 13,863
- 25,583
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Scully left for Atkins could come.
Makes sense
Makes sense
Jed still has a year to run on his contract so he gets another year to prove himself.
With Richards on the list, he's officially backup or possibly backup to backup.
With Richards on the list, he's officially backup or possibly backup to backup.
Only if Rataoglea is playing SANFL. If he's still playing in the forward line at AFL level, then he isn't depth for the backline. And we end up robbing our forward line to cover a defensive injury.
And the backline at SANFL level will be inexperienced kids that are late picks in the draft that wouldn't even be playing Seniors if they were at an SANFL side. And we'll blame the SANFL for why our development path is so shit...
Could they move Finny down back?
All three are guaranteed to survive a nuclear apocalypse
- Oct 8, 2004
- 18,474
- 25,289
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
tell us more....
- Aug 21, 2007
- 32,979
- 108,632
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Aston Villa, San Antonio Spurs
Clurey is a much smarter player and worked better with his teammates. Esava is a great size and a great athlete, but he doesn't quite have the skills or nous. I think he'll probably start the season in the SANFL.
Is he a clearly worse player than Esava, even now? I'm not sure that he is. I'd say it's pretty lineball.
Trengove was the victim of some really poor list management and Matthew Lobbe's ability vanishing.
We knew Ryder was going to get banned or at least we knew it was a big chance, and we didn't cover him. We then used Trengove in the ruck in 2016, remodeling the defence without him and deciding that he didn't fit our style anymore. We then play him as a forward in 2017 (where we were short due to another list management stuffup) which he's not suited to and we end up giving him away to the Bulldogs, where his heart isn't in it and his career peters out. I don't think it would have petered out as it did if we simply left him as a KPD the whole time.
Port2Power
Team Captain
I checked Scully's instagram as soon as the club released the delistings and it shows he's following the Carlton football club... a bit strange all of a sudden
Abraham Nuscrack
Team Captain
I just know a local SAAFL club is throwing serious coin at him & have confidence in their ability to have him next yr
Probs was because he's good mates with LemmeyI checked Scully's instagram as soon as the club released the delistings and it shows he's following the Carlton football club... a bit strange all of a sudden
PortPortPort
Sack Hinkley
Bye bye Narkle. Thought he was average at best.
Doctor Feel
Shitposter In Chief
We are gonna sift through the bins again arent we
- Nov 6, 2014
- 63,868
- 80,833
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
But that hair
I bloody hope not. Ratkins is bad enough.
Having just updated the spreadsheet, we look to have need at:
1. KPF
2. KPD
3. Big bodied midfielder
4. Small forward
5. Medium forward
1. KPF
2. KPD
3. Big bodied midfielder
4. Small forward
5. Medium forward
