I'd take Taranto over Jackson any day of the week, unfortunately Taranto won't come hereWrong again.
A slow midfielder with below average disposal skills really has little value. Just because he plays for GWS and was a high draft pick (seems to be the factor most posters on this site use to determine value) means very little. Richmond is going to be taken to the cleaners this trade period for two ordinary players.
Jackson is the rarest of commodities, an athletic ruck/forward. Melbourne should be demanding three first round draft picks.
Won a B&F at the Giants in his second year, hugely underrated because he plays in Sydney