Opinion Matthew Nicks: Adelaide's Coach (Part 3) - The Biggest Loser

Is Matthew Nicks the right coach for Adelaide?

  • Firmly yes (I love what I'm seeing)

  • Leaning yes

  • Can't decide either way

  • Leaning no (but don't sack him yet)

  • Firmly no (he should be sacked)


Results are only viewable after voting.

Remove this Banner Ad

Oh that’s right, what was that again? Something about kids and values or was that another time?
That was when he ruled out playing the likes of Dowling 8-9 weeks into the year because he didn't plan on debuting them over the off-season.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I'm just worried that any improvement will be brushed off as '' we said Nicks needed help , we got him help and look we were right ''

Actually I think a few here might have that in their script meetings for next year
 
I'm just worried that any improvement will be brushed off as '' we said Nicks needed help , we got him help and look we were right ''

Actually I think a few here might have that in their script meetings for next year
Yep, we are seriously going down the Ken path without any finals, so we are worse.

When the club identifies they need someone else to be in charge of gameplan, execution, assistants and development, you’d hope they’d acknowledge that Nicks isn’t the man.

But if we don’t make finals next year he has to be gone.
 
He said he had no plans to debut Dowling this year or something like that

It's funny because it's exactly what we were told Pyke said to junior players that were gunning it up in the 2s. He apparently told them they were going really well, but they're not going to get selected unless multiple injuries intervene. The same people just employ the same people, nothing has changed.
 
That was when he ruled out playing the likes of Dowling 8-9 weeks into the year because he didn't plan on debuting them over the off-season.
And said those calling for any of our reserves players to come in probably haven't been watching the SANFL games
 
Thoughts on Stewy Dew coaching again? coaching the Suns when he did was a big ask.... we all know he was sacked cos Dimma was waiting in the wings.
I don't like the idea of Nicks replacement being a untried new coach. Justin leppitch deserves another go and i think he will be better this time around. Would kill for Chris Scott but i think he will coach Tassie.

Dew
Leppitch
Buckley
C Scott
Bevo
L Cameron

who??
 
Thoughts on Stewy Dew coaching again? coaching the Suns when he did was a big ask.... we all know he was sacked cos Dimma was waiting in the wings.
I don't like the idea of Nicks replacement being a untried new coach. Justin leppitch deserves another go and i think he will be better this time around. Would kill for Chris Scott but i think he will coach Tassie.

Dew
Leppitch
Buckley
C Scott
Bevo
L Cameron

who??

Games coached at one club in VFL/AFL history without every making the finals:

Alan Richardson - 126
Stuart Dew - 121
Matty Nicks - 106

Replacing #3 with #2 is just terrible optics.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Games coached at one club in VFL/AFL history without every making the finals:

Alan Richardson - 126
Stuart Dew - 121
Matty Nicks - 106

Replacing #3 with #2 is just terrible optics.
Don't worry, Nicks will be 2nd by the time he's sacked, so replacing him with 3rd is an upgrade!!
 
Don't worry, Nicks will be 2nd by the time he's sacked, so replacing him with 3rd is an upgrade!!
So we cause Dew to drop from 2nd to 3rd so we then appoint Dew so he can become #1...
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Matthew Nicks: Adelaide's Coach (Part 3) - The Biggest Loser

Back
Top