Most Overated Player on BigFooty?

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Originally Posted by DCFCFAN84
I know I am gonna get flamed for this but IMO J.Brown is overrated it's like people think he is the next Carey or something.
If he stays fit and is able to have a full pre-season next year watch out, will tear a hole in the competition.
 
Dear oh dear Jonesy you're just digging yourself in deeper. Egan has regularly stood the best backman every week. Every defender in the league has his team mates dropping back to help him out. Cripes, Tomcat missed a lot of early season games back then. Egan is top shelf and I'd rate him as the number one KP backman as he generally stood on the Gorillas. We lost quite a bit when he went down against the Lions in the last match. We especially missed Egan against the Pies.

regards,

REB


REB agree to disagree just think he is overrated personally opinion not fact
 
True Murphy may become a gun but he's not one yet. You'd think he was the way he gets pumped up by your mob.
Deledio too had trouble shaking the tag this season and like Murphy has yet to take the next step.
I just think that Thomas is already is indicating genuine star qualities where as Murphy and Deledio aren't at the same point yet.

Still early days for all of them and likely they'll all be very good players.


Sure its a lot harder to break into a good side when its winning but its also easier to get a touch as well with better players around you as well.

Dont worry Murph and Deledio will come out better players having to work hard early in their career for a kick.
 
DALE THOMAS [the 15 game superstar] is the most overated player in a very long time.

he's forever writing cheques he can't cash running along theboundry wagging his finger like a F**king wiggle

Rodney :eek:ades the most overated coach on Big footy [ain't that the truth]
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Notice those who say Thomas are either Carlton or unlisted
Hmmmmmmmm:confused:

haha gibbs :rolleyes:


seriously though, only around 5 people rate him and no one says his a superstar, yet he is overrated, must be all the carlton supporters, they are used to their players being crap that anything better than crap is overrated, think about it
 
Dale Thomas
Buddy Franklin
Jordan Bannister

probably true because he rated on his potential but Buddy has had more scoring shots than anyone in the afl in 07 at the age of 20. after a bit of experience he might live up to his reputation..
 
probably true because he rated on his potential but Buddy has had more scoring shots than anyone in the afl in 07 at the age of 20. after a bit of experience he might live up to his reputation..

you don't get it at all

buddy is overrated because some people seem to think he is god, he is nowhere near that right now, just look at his last game.
 
After reading all the draft threads the most overrated player for each team is anybody whose name is thrown up for trade.

Player A gets carved up by supporters all year yet when his name comes up as a possible trade option all of a sudden he becomes a gun.

I have even read Bulldogs supporters say we would want a 2nd round pick for Sam Power as an example of this.

For the other 51 weeks of the year its Buddy - he gets 5 threads a day
 
Adcock, he's a good player but some people talk about him as if he is the new Michael Voss

:eek: dont think he can be the 'most overated' as he is not that highly rated by most people.

He will be a gun, but he is a different type than Voss.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Most Overated Player on BigFooty?

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top