NAB 3 vs Collingwood Sat 12th March, 1.10pm Etihad Stadium

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

I'd be surprised if players are selected for all 3 games. Seems an unnecessary risk, however were going in full strength, so all those who've played one game, you'd think, will be playing.

Who are the ones that have played both so far out of the above? Daniel, Wallis, Adams, Campbell...is that it?

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Who are the ones that have played both so far out of the above? Daniel, Wallis, Adams, Campbell...is that it?

I think so, I'm trying to remember. I'd like to see Adams play but would they play him 3 times, albeit the first game had limited game time?

Edit Wallis didn't play on Sunday I don't think.

 

[Testekill]

I think so, I'm trying to remember. I'd like to see Adams play but would they play him 3 times, albeit the first game had limited game time?

Edit Wallis didn't play on Sunday I don't think.

Correct, Wallis didn't play

 

[Wizard17]

After roughly looking at the team lists from both weeks these are the SENIOR list players who have played only one game so far:

Tom Liberatore
Marcus Bontempelli
Dale Morris
Jake Stringer
Lin Jong
Fletcher Roberts
Joel Hamling
Zaine Cordy
Easton Wood
Mitch Wallis
Jackson Macrae
Josh Dunkley
Koby Stevens
Matthew Suckling
Tory Dickson
Jason Johannisen
Luke Dahlhaus
Shane Biggs
Robert Murphy
Liam Picken
Bailey Dale
Josh Prudden
Mitch Honeychurch
Declan Hamilton
Tom Boyd
Jack Redpath

and.....

Matthew Boyd hasn't played any.

 

[Wizard17]

With the exception of Campbell this team has the best team I could make with players with one game or less over the preseason.

FB - MBoyd - Roberts - Hamling
HB - Murphy - Wood - JJ
C - Suckling - Bont - Biggs
HF - Hunter - Redpath - Dahl
FF - Dickson - T.Boyd - Stringer
OB - Campbell* - Libba - Wallis

Int - Macrae - Jong - Stevens - Picken - Morris - Dunkley

 

[darthbards]

I think so, I'm trying to remember. I'd like to see Adams play but would they play him 3 times, albeit the first game had limited game time?

Edit Wallis didn't play on Sunday I don't think.

I'd like to see Adams play again also. He seems like he could play round one but not definite and I'd like to see him in a fast paced dress rehearsal under the roof.

 

[bontshow]

Who are the ones that have played both so far out of the above? Daniel, Wallis, Adams, Campbell...is that it?

Collins, Roughead, Hrovat, Minson, McLean, Adams, Campbell, Daniel

 

[JEDi 44]

I'd like to see Adams play again also. He seems like he could play round one but not definite and I'd like to see him in a fast paced dress rehearsal under the roof.

I'm not sure yet about Adams. It seems to me that a lot of pundits jumped onto Adams because Johnno liked him.

 

[ScragCity]

Who are the ones that have played both so far out of the above? Daniel, Wallis, Adams, Campbell...is that it?

Collins, Roughy, Minson...Mclean I think... there should be about 7 or 8 all up since we only had 15 changes from NAB 1 and NAB 2

 

[ScragCity]

Pretty sure Hrovat played both.

 

[darthbards]

I'm not sure yet about Adams. It seems to me that a lot of pundits jumped onto Adams because Johnno liked him.

Haven't heard Johnno on Adams,I thought he might have jumped on another bloke lol. I just want to have another look at Adams and think another game as a mature recruit might help to get a better gauge.

 

[fargy]

I'm not sure yet about Adams. It seems to me that a lot of pundits jumped onto Adams because Johnno liked him.

More so he took a few good contested marks and his kicking wasn't noticeably bad on the weekend.

 

[Dogs_R_Us]

After roughly looking at the team lists from both weeks these are the SENIOR list players who have played only one game so far:
and.....

Matthew Boyd hasn't played any.

As a senior cit Matty doesn't have to. Cotton wool for him this season. He'll be right

 

[JEDi 44]

Haven't heard Johnno on Adams,I thought he might have jumped on another bloke lol. I just want to have another look at Adams and think another game as a mature recruit might help to get a better gauge.

agreed

 

[archibald23]

More so he took a few good contested marks and his kicking wasn't noticeably bad on the weekend.

Was at the game, his marks were excellent, won the ball back for us. His kicking improved, but did see him fluff one during a switch from one wing to another. He seems to have improved in general play, but not so much on the switching.

 

[stefoid]

Lets play adams v freo just to piss off lyon

 

[King Bont]

Was at the game, his marks were excellent, won the ball back for us. His kicking improved, but did see him fluff one during a switch from one wing to another. He seems to have improved in general play, but not so much on the switching.

He reminds me of a Lake/Gipson hybrid. Reads the play really well.

 

[archibald23]

He reminds me of a Lake/Gipson hybrid. Reads the play really well.

Agreed on the gibson call, marks a little differently to Lake, but just as effective.

If we can keep on building up his disposal.... will add massive value to our side.

 

[fronkalicious]

If Adams is to play round 1, why not give him another taste of it in a game that will be higher intensity than either of the 2 he's played previously.

If he runs out of gas later in the year and needs a rest, so be it. But if he's in for round 1 (and he's not in mine), then let's prepare him for what's to come as best as possible.

 

[Yojimbo]

They played all of the KPD's in NAB2 as well as all the rucks
i am starting to think they are as confused as we are.

 

[fargy]

3-5 to come out of this squad.
Players named that have already played two:
Hrovat
Campbell
McLean
Roughead
Collins
Adams
Daniel.

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

Not playing: Cordy, Smith, Roberts, Webb, Dunkley, Honeychurch, Hamilton, Minson, Prudden, Dickson, Dale, Williams, Lynch, Smith, Goetz, Adcock

Hopefully Dickson's injury isn't anything too bad...

 

[Mofra]

I guess that puts the Minson vs Campbell competition to rest.

25 squad - I guess that's pretty much round 1 + emergencies sorted

 

[doggies ftw]

Fantastic, looks like the club sees it pretty similarly to the way I do concerning the ruck/key defenders/key forwards situation. Although id be going one tall shorter in the real stuff and atm thatd be Roughy (but that could change very quickly)

 

[timtamWB]

Collins and Adams both in, that's very nice. And I know it's still just a practice match, but I wish Dunkley had gotten another go.