Incredible how many people just do not understand this.
I think the best way to describe how the actual clubs look at it is to imagine you went back in time say, 10 or 12 years ago and were drafting for your list today, but from the 2013 or 2014 draft, but you knew how good (talented) each player has been in reality since that date.
You wouldn’t pick on needs. You’d just pick the best players one by one and skip over all the guys that turned out to be duds.
All listen managers try to project now, who are going to be those duds.
If Walls thinks there is a 60% chance that Charlie Nicholls makes it but he also thinks the best small forward left has only a 10% chance of making it long term at the level, he’s going to pick the 60% chance every single time. Even if we need a small forward more than a key forward in 2025.
Walls clearly thinks that Nicholl is going to be a superior AFL player than Alger or Boxshall or Clarke, or whoever else was touted on this board at this pick. Thats really all that matters in the end.
Nicholl looks like he would be a great defender… similar draft profile to Alex Pearce!
Freo's Pick 37: Alex Pearce
With our second pick (#37) in the NAB AFL Draft we’ve chosen 18-year-old Alex Pearce from the Devonport Magpies
www.fremantlefc.com.au