Of course, but coaches aren't judged based on a single year.
Where would you rate him amongst the single flag winners in the afl era?
I feel we keep ignoring the controversy that surrounds Goodwin, and how that impacts people's willingness to be generous towards any underperformance.
And also how little that matters
He'd be the most criticised of this group by a trillion percent
Usually there’s a reason for criticism, same with whipping boys.
Using similar logic we wouldn't have appointed Blight. Couldn't get across the line with an exceptional team
It would have been a red flag for sure.
As I said before, something is rotten in the state of Denmark.
It does seem like the COVID year was more of an outlier than all the years of finals losses.
Some clubs have more than just a premiership capable list. They have elite foundations to set up a period of sustained success.
Maybe he's less annoying to the casual viewer? If you heard him once or twice a year he probably sounds quite good, as a play by play he's actually very good and knowledgeable. It's just once you hear him for the 10th time you realise that every single call of his is the same with the exact same cliches. He's like a demo version of Dennis Commetti that no one ever paid to unlock the rest of.
They aren't going to let Roo dictate proceedings as he's walking out the door.
