Oppo Camp Non-Eagles Discussion

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I picture Petruccelli using his pace
Cracking Up Lol GIF by HULU
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Berry has decided to appeal the eye gouge
No real surprise there. Not sure he will get off,but the argument that it was careless (I.e. hard to see what you are doing when your head is forced sideways by the other players elbow that is also on your throat) deserves to be made.

Also get them to squirm on what 'unreasonable' contact is, based on the above elbow choke.

On SM-G986B using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Berry has decided to appeal the eye gouge
The penalty is so odd. If it's intentional, then eye gouging is about as low an act as there is and it should be straight to the tribunal and awaiting a Gaff-level suspension.

They should be able to argue down to careless given how reticent the MRO normally is to apply an intentional grading to more calculated acts than this one.
 
The penalty is so odd. If it's intentional, then eye gouging is about as low an act as there is and it should be straight to the tribunal and awaiting a Gaff-level suspension.

They should be able to argue down to careless given how reticent the MRO normally is to apply an intentional grading to more calculated acts than this one.
I think the best thing in Berry's defence is the fact Oliver is all over him and his throat.

No chance they'd even consider a Gaff level suspension for this, and nor should they.
 
I think the best thing in Berry's defence is the fact Oliver is all over him and his throat.

No chance they'd even consider a Gaff level suspension for this, and nor should they.
That's my point, they're not considering a lengthy suspension yet saying it was an intentional eye gouge. I can't reconcile those positions.
 
Claiming involuntary reaction didn't get Masto off his biting charge so it seems unlikely to work here.

I only saw the replay once but tbh it looked about as significant as when Schofield shattered Oliver's jaw.
 
SCG has been a fortress this year for the swans and they ended the pies unbeaten run a month ago with ease .

It will be a good game but swans to win .

Think Geelong game goes either way .

Brisbane have some belief after breaking the MGC hoodoo and Geelong have well known issues coming off a bye .
We beat Sydney in Sydney.

We lost by 10 to Geelong at Geelong, and beat Geelong by 40 odd at home.

Geelong is probably a team we don’t fear.

And we also beat Collingwood as well.
 
I think the best thing in Berry's defence is the fact Oliver is all over him and his throat.

No chance they'd even consider a Gaff level suspension for this, and nor should they.
Also Oliver appears to try to bite his fingers.
 
The penalty is so odd. If it's intentional, then eye gouging is about as low an act as there is and it should be straight to the tribunal and awaiting a Gaff-level suspension.

They should be able to argue down to careless given how reticent the MRO normally is to apply an intentional grading to more calculated acts than this one.

Brayshaw got a week when he was charged with eye gouging Berry


I do agree it should be a heavier penalty, eye gouging is amongst the lowest of the low
 
How many weeks was Judd facing before Campbell Brown lied for him?
 
How many weeks was Judd facing before Campbell Brown lied for him?

Just the 1 game it seems

AFL doesn't rate eye gouging that big a deal surprisingly
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

We beat Sydney in Sydney.

We lost by 10 to Geelong at Geelong, and beat Geelong by 40 odd at home.

Geelong is probably a team we don’t fear.

And we also beat Collingwood as well.

Well it would be nice if you stop telling us about what you've done during the regular season and actually get it done during the finals.

Relying on Sydney to fly the interstate flag doesn't sit well with most Eagles supporters so if Brisbane can stop shitting the bed in finals...

Runningwild GIF by National Geographic Channel
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top