Clearly collingwood supporters have identified its not that travel factor.
so what is it? Im now intrigued too.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Traded Ollie Henry - Traded to Geelong as part of a reported 3-way deal (details tbc)
- Thread starter Elmer_Hauser
- Start date
- Tagged users None
so what is it? Im now intrigued too.
Lol. it takes 4 hours to fill out the paperwork.
His mums milk.
- Feb 21, 2016
- 2,195
- 2,907
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
It's more like 70 than 1 though
Geez Collingwood fans memories suck. They laughed at StKilda for not trading for Luke Ball. Luke Ball than goes to the draft and puts $1million on his head and gets taken at P30.
Saints get nothing and proceed to get a draw in the Grand Final, lose the next week.
1 simple trade probably cost them a flag but hey at least they stood firm right? Lol
Geelong hold all the cards here, surely Collingwood after being involved in such an important trade stand off are not this dumb? Surely they take P25 or anything?
Geelong will get him eventually.
It’s not too late to not make another massive mistake Pies.
Bruhn was a pick 12, GWS now accept pick 18.
Clark was a pick 15, we took P22 off Freo.
How come the narrative is Collingwood getting ripped off so much? It’s the norm here to slide this far when OOC.
Krueger is ahead of Henry when I saw your selections. What did we get for Krueger?
Saints get nothing and proceed to get a draw in the Grand Final, lose the next week.
1 simple trade probably cost them a flag but hey at least they stood firm right? Lol
Geelong hold all the cards here, surely Collingwood after being involved in such an important trade stand off are not this dumb? Surely they take P25 or anything?
Geelong will get him eventually.
It’s not too late to not make another massive mistake Pies.
Bruhn was a pick 12, GWS now accept pick 18.
Clark was a pick 15, we took P22 off Freo.
How come the narrative is Collingwood getting ripped off so much? It’s the norm here to slide this far when OOC.
Krueger is ahead of Henry when I saw your selections. What did we get for Krueger?
It is more like Pick 70.
We have picks 16 and 27.
We are using 2 draft picks plus upgrading Noble.
Therefore Pick 25 is a 2 pick upgrade on Pick 27 or the equivalent of Pick 69.
Because Pick 25 is a 2 spot upgrade on Pick 27.Geez Collingwood fans memories suck. They laughed at StKilda for not trading for Luke Ball. Luke Ball than goes to the draft and puts $1million on his head and gets taken at P30.
Saints get nothing and proceed to get a draw in the Grand Final, lose the next week.
1 simple trade probably cost them a flag but hey at least they stood firm right? Lol
Geelong hold all the cards here, surely Collingwood after being involved in such an important trade stand off are not this dumb? Surely they take P25 or anything?
Geelong will get him eventually.
It’s not too late to not make another massive mistake Pies.
Bruhn was a pick 12, GWS now accept pick 18.
Clark was a pick 15, we took P22 off Freo.
How come the narrative is Collingwood getting ripped off so much? It’s the norm here to slide this far when OOC.
Krueger is ahead of Henry when I saw your selections. What did we get for Krueger?
We won't be using 3 draft picks
16, Next pick and then Noble upgrade.
- Dec 20, 2021
- 6,747
- 18,236
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Arsenal
- Sep 25, 2013
- 16,122
- 31,138
Obviously Henry has seen how little the Pies value great clubman who sign long term, and has decided he doesn’t want to be a part of that toxicity.
The kid has his head screwed on.
You know what Hawthorn want do you.
We wanted top 25 for Grundy.
We want a first rounder for Henry.
Seems it's ok for everyone to get what they want exept Collingwood.
I think it's mainly because we're reigning Premiers and have received a draft bounty of Bowes and P7 for a future 3rd round pick. That's "not fair" to the observer because they didn't also get it so it's only "fair" that we pay what they want for the OOC player. You see it with little kids all the time, they both get an ice cream but one complains that their ice cream is smaller.
sr36
TheBrownDog
Geez Collingwood fans memories suck. They laughed at StKilda for not trading for Luke Ball. Luke Ball than goes to the draft and puts $1million on his head and gets taken at P30.
Saints get nothing and proceed to get a draw in the Grand Final, lose the next week.
1 simple trade probably cost them a flag but hey at least they stood firm right? Lol
Geelong hold all the cards here, surely Collingwood after being involved in such an important trade stand off are not this dumb? Surely they take P25 or anything?
Geelong will get him eventually.
It’s not too late to not make another massive mistake Pies.
Bruhn was a pick 12, GWS now accept pick 18.
Clark was a pick 15, we took P22 off Freo.
How come the narrative is Collingwood getting ripped off so much? It’s the norm here to slide this far when OOC.
Krueger is ahead of Henry when I saw your selections. What did we get for Krueger?
Could you walk me through how doing the trade and getting pick 30 would have resulted in St Kilda probably winning the flag?
- Apr 18, 2015
- 21,055
- 25,580
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- PAOK of SALONIKA LIVERPOOL
Just heard on SEN.
Ollie deal will be done soon.
Ollie deal will be done soon.
Bear Nectar
Debutant
- Sep 20, 2019
- 61
- 51
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
My bad - read it wrong
see below
An embargo is in place until 3pm AEDT, meaning no deals can be done until then. Clubs will then have until the trade deadline at 7:30pm AEDT to process their remaining trades.
We will draft another player in we get another solid pick. We will have to delist more players though. If we take 25 we will use it or upgrade it because that means that we rate that pick higher then one of our listed out of contract players. The point is that we don't need it because we can just use pick 16 and upgrade 2 rookies if needed and hold our currently listed players. Is 25 better then Poulter? WHE? Kelly? Because it will come down to a choice.
- Oct 29, 2017
- 21,550
- 41,901
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Because pick 25 is unders for a guy taken late mid-late teens and threatening to walk to the draft is obviously even worse (let alone an appalling thing to do).
Is it really that hard to understand?
After 3pm at least
Bear Nectar
Debutant
- Sep 20, 2019
- 61
- 51
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I also find it amusing that Catters are still triggered over the Krueger trade.
- Oct 29, 2017
- 21,550
- 41,901
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Did they offer 18? When?
Its another one guys. Yawn. Swear I have read this before.Geez Collingwood fans memories suck. They laughed at StKilda for not trading for Luke Ball. Luke Ball than goes to the draft and puts $1million on his head and gets taken at P30.
Saints get nothing and proceed to get a draw in the Grand Final, lose the next week.
1 simple trade probably cost them a flag but hey at least they stood firm right? Lol
Geelong hold all the cards here, surely Collingwood after being involved in such an important trade stand off are not this dumb? Surely they take P25 or anything?
Geelong will get him eventually.
It’s not too late to not make another massive mistake Pies.
Bruhn was a pick 12, GWS now accept pick 18.
Clark was a pick 15, we took P22 off Freo.
How come the narrative is Collingwood getting ripped off so much? It’s the norm here to slide this far when OOC.
Krueger is ahead of Henry when I saw your selections. What did we get for Krueger?
I do know how averages work, and that's not it.
It's 44.7 ruck contests per game at 39.5% (17.6), not 44.7% of rucks, for Cameron, and 36.2 ruck contests per game for Cox at 48.6% hitout win rate(17.6).
Combined they average (17.6 +17.6)/(44.7+36.2)=43.5% hit out win rate
Grundy was 66.3 per game, with a 46% hit out rate.
Like I said, both of them together aren't worth one Grundy.
- Dec 20, 2021
- 6,747
- 18,236
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Arsenal
Here comes Captain Hindsight
Similar threads
