List Mgmt. Our Trade/FA, Suburban & Country Town Thread

[3rdMan]

The narrative would be 100% different if our name was Geelong Football Club.

To be fair they currently only have 8 players over 30. We have 9. Completely different story!

 

[3rdMan]

He & his media mates would be much happier if we just sat on our hands during the trade period, lost Richards, didn't get Perryman, didn't go after Houston, maybe give Nobes away & went to the draft with our 36, 51, 54 picks.

Now that would be what I'd call really being reckless & falling off the cliff

Fairly sure any commentators (can't call em journos) are happy for us to be active. Drives engagement. Negative comment even more so.

 

[sr36]

He & his media mates would be much happier if we just sat on our hands during the trade period, lost Richards, didn't get Perryman, didn't go after Houston, maybe give Nobes away & went to the draft with our 36, 51, 54 picks.

Now that would be what I'd call really being reckless & falling off the cliff

It's nuts, apparently the safe option when you need to replace old blokes soon is to cross your fingers and take a couple of 2nd round picks to the draft.

 

[loki04]

He’s a loser

The only thing he loves more then Richmond is hating on Collingwood. He's a deadset flog when it involves us.

 

[Apex36]

If Houston wants to go Carlton, they have said that they’ll trade their F1 for GC13. Maybe GC may think that Carlton will finish lower than pies next year. It makes perfect sense if youre GC.

That’s not what they’ve said at all, that’s just a Ralphy fantasy.
The only thing GC have said is that they’ll deal with Collingwood first on 13 because they want Noble.

As for the last sentence? If by perfect sense you mean they like to gamble, then you’re spot on I guess.

 

[JLC]

Real Footy podcast "Folly of Collingwood"

Lol ffs this is our of control

 

[sr36]

I don’t believe a word they are saying. The only thing the suns care about is the best value for pick 13. They don’t care who Houston nominates

If they do care where Houston gets traded, it's good news as it could only be Lukosius related and a 3 way deal with us Port and them.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Fairly sure any commentators (can't call em journos) are happy for us to be active. Drives engagement. Negative comment even more so.

They'd then just be spending their time saying how we aren't doing anything..whilst having such an old list with no ready made replacements & only late picks in the draft.

That sounds pretty dire & negative.

 

[manicpie]

Real Footy podcast "Folly of Collingwood"

Lol ffs this is our of control

They all hate us coz they ain't us

 

[76woodenspooners]

He’s a loser

Gee that’s a crazy ass way of simply saying “Collingwood have five players older than Carlton’s oldest”

And can anybody explain what “positive ranking on AFL relative rankings” means?

 

[stormskye]

If they do care where Houston gets traded, it's good news as it could only be Lukosius related and a 3 way deal with us Port and them.

Yup. Dealing separately with Carlton for pick 13, us for noble, and port for Luko just seems stupid

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

Old Ralphy boys obsession with Collingwood on his Twitter feed is strong. Back to back articles in 10 minutes.

I’m surprised he doesn’t cop more in the replies, anyone remember the time he posted his Home Screen by mistake?

 

[JLC]

Gee that’s a crazy ass way of simply saying “Collingwood have five players older than Carlton’s oldest”

And can anybody explain what “positive ranking on AFL relative rankings means”?

Thank you for translating that - was making my head hurt tbh lol X Definitely needs an edit button - go back and try again Ralphy.

 

[sr36]

Yup. Dealing separately with Carlton for pick 13, us for noble, and port for Luko just seems stupid

Sydney have supposedly offered 19 and 21 for 13 - I think they'd shop for a suitors for those picks and that it will trump the Blues bid anyway.

 

[manicpie]

Gee that’s a crazy ass way of simply saying “Collingwood have five players older than Carlton’s oldest”

And can anybody explain what “positive ranking on AFL relative rankings means”?

Unfortunately for Carlton, one of their oldest is Cripps and they are going to be a hell of a lot worse off than us when they lose him. He is Carlton

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Real Footy podcast "Folly of Collingwood"

Lol ffs this is our of control

Gleeson and Ryan are Collingwood supporters too.

 

[HFF]

Did anyone tell Ralph flags aren’t won with birth certificates?

It anyone is experienced to talk about it is us.
We won a flag with the youngest team in history and a flag with the oldest.
We have done it on both sides of the coin and realised there are no guarantees.

Wait 2-3 years when his beloved Tigers are delisting the bulk of their draft additions that haven’t “kicked on”
Let’s see what he says then

 

[satanshoof101]

Needs to be a bit of posturing. Collingwood give Gold Coast Noble, F1 and 36 and get back from Gold Coast: 13, 23 and 29. Pick 13, 23 or 29 and Richards . Does that leave us enough for McGuane next year? Hopefully we can get a future 2nd or third back somewhere along the lines.

At the moment it's been reported we offered Noble + F1 for pick 13, 23, 29 which is looking like a best case scenario.

It probably ends up being Noble + F1 for pick 13, 23

Maybe if we give Suns pick 36 as well we can get the full allotment 13, 23, 29

Suns will be left with picks 36, 41, 50 which = 1187 points

Lombard will get a bid around 10-12 which is 1250 - 1350 points

Best case scenario Suns take pick 36 give us pick 29 and find points elsewhere and we take 29, 52, 55 to the draft

Edit: I would take Will Graham he looks like a gun, Suns can't hoard endless mids.

 

[manicpie]

Sydney have supposedly offered 19 and 21 for 13 - I think they'd shop for a suitors for those picks and that it will trump the Blues bid anyway.

If we don't get Houston I'd jump all over that. Those 2 picks could get us 2 KPP

 

[PIEWITHSAUCE]

GCS have stated that they want a rebounding defender that's ready to rock'n'roll , so it depends how they value JFN vs a speculative draft pick. I think the answer is obvious and we don't let Noble go unless we're sure our replacement is locked away. It's our deal to get done and I think with good will at both ends it'll happen.

 

[Seedsfan]

He’s a loser

While he makes somewhat of a point. The comparison with Carlton? They have proven they are not good enough. They maybe marginally younger but name any decent young player on their list? They haven’t had a player make the 22 under 22 in the last two years.

 

[sr36]

Gee that’s a crazy ass way of simply saying “Collingwood have five players older than Carlton’s oldest”

And can anybody explain what “positive ranking on AFL relative rankings means”?

Bobby Hill is under 25 and doesn't have a positive relative ranking - Obviously Peter and Josh are positive relatives for Nick, but I would have thought Bobby's cousins made the grade.

 

[Pedro]

At the moment it's been reported we offered Noble + F1 for pick 13, 23, 29 which is looking like a best case scenario.

It probably ends up being Noble + F1 for pick 13, 23

Maybe if we give Suns pick 36 as well we can get the full allotment 13, 23, 29

Suns will be left with picks 36, 41, 50 which = 1187 points

Lombard will get a bid around 10-12 which is 1250 - 1350 points

Best case scenario Suns take pick 36 give us pick 29 and find points elsewhere and we take 29, 52, 55 to the draft

They'll get points when they trade Lukosius wont they? they should have plenty

 

[leon123]

I want him Pablo

All good, but who dont ya want

 

[sr36]

If we don't get Houston I'd jump all over that. Those 2 picks could get us 2 KPP

I agree. But I meant in terms of the Carlton offer probably not being the best one for pick 13 anyway.