List Mgmt. Our Trade/FA, Suburban & Country Town Thread

[GreekLunatic]

GC wants noble so they would have to do a deal.

 

[Run n Spread]

Dees have significant issues with holes everywhere and are facing the real possibility of starting a rebuild, especially if petracca and Oliver leave in the next 2 years.

Have 5 and 9 to kick it off before a cliff
Gawn and May is their issue.
Biggest thing is if cp and co get back to their best for various reasons. Are there for a while yet

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Which basically confirms they’re pretty much exclusively dealing with us for 13

Also, breaking news, Melbourne to trade 5 and 9 for 13

 

[Run n Spread]

You aren’t serious?

Our picks at this point start at 36.
Best we can do is 13 23 and Richards. If suns accept it. Would be great. But if I'm port I'm pulling a dees and saying your staying put.

 

[GreekLunatic]

so are they going to give us 9 then I thought GC don't want first round picks this year

 

[Pistol Night]

Our picks at this point start at 36.
Best we can do is 13 23 and Richards. Would be great. But if I'm port I'm pulling a dees and saying your staying put.

They would of said that from the start then rather than **** everyone around for a week surely

 

[GreekLunatic]

On Facebook now it's down to us and north or him staying

 

[Run n Spread]

GC wants noble so they would have to do a deal.

If the DH trade blows up do we accept say pick 23 or 26 (no futures trading) or keep him?
I'd trade and take the picks.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

On Facebook now it's down to us and north or him staying

Really going out on a limb with that.

 

[3rdMan]

I don’t think too many supporters enjoyed that trade.
Let’s not do it again.

Agreed. No one liked it. Treloar was only here a couple of years though and salary cap relief was needed. Trading out Maynard just so we can get a draft pick? That would be magnitudes worse.

 

[Pistol Night]

Really going out on a limb with that.

I’m checking MySpace for confirmation

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

We want to take some decent picks to do the draft, so we would be wanting to keep (23) and 36.

36 isn't really a "decent" pick though, so if us being pigheaded about giving that up is what costs us Houston it's a mistake.

 

[celestial]

vIf they’re against giving us 13 and 23 for Noble and our F1, why the hell would they change their mind for an extra unfavourable (for them) pick swap?

According to ralphy we have asked for 13,23,29.So I was spot on with what Collingwood had in mind. I only suggest we turn that pick 29 into a pick swap to make the trade more palatable.

Someone has to bite the bullet, and it more likely will be GC because they need senior players to take this list forward .

 

[GreekLunatic]

Port want Lukosious too so who knows what's happening

 

[3rdMan]

Melb/essendon in discussions for dons pick 9
Meaning out of the pick 13 discussions

A second team out of the race for pick 13? It's losing value all the time. Or maybe it was always going to us and the rest of the talk has been posturing.

 

[frizzle]

On Facebook now it's down to us and north or him staying

Here's were you went wrong.

 

[Run n Spread]

They would of said that from the start then rather than **** everyone around for a week surely

They will assess offers. Had all but worked it out with the dees. If north offer the goods port may say us or them.
Any other players we could chuck in the mix to improve the hand if we're desperate.
Schultz or Mcreery are 2 I can think of if desperate.
Otherwise just move on.
See if we can get some young mids.
Peatling or Stone would've been good.
This is my fear we chase unrealistic targets Smith etc when other slip
It's like trying to bid at a toorak auction with 1 million while houses an hour do the road go begging.

 

[3rdMan]

Goes to show how much opposition coaches admire him - even though their fans hate him

Maynard is certainly a player Clarkson would admire. Even more since having to coach the dreck at North.

 

[Antz]

They will assess offers. Had all but worked it out with the dees. If north offer the goods port may say us or them.
Any other players we could chuck in the mix to improve the hand if we're desperate.
Schultz or Mcreery are 2 I can think of if desperate.
Otherwise just move on.
See if we can get some young mids.
Peatling or Stone would've been good.
This is my fear we chase unrealistic targets Smith etc when other slip
It's like trying to bid at a toorak auction with 1 million while houses an hour do the road go begging.

Is that you, Jon Ralph?

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

 

[Pistol Night]

They will assess offers. Had all but worked it out with the dees. If north offer the goods port may say us or them.
Any other players we could chuck in the mix to improve the hand if we're desperate.
Schultz or Mcreery are 2 I can think of if desperate.
Otherwise just move on.
See if we can get some young mids.
Peatling or Stone would've been good.
This is my fear we chase unrealistic targets Smith etc when other slip
It's like trying to bid at a toorak auction with 1 million while houses an hour do the road go begging.

If we somehow gave up Shoota or Beau in the deal I’d leave a flaming shit in a paper bag on Leppa’s doorstep

 

[TradeDraft]

Get the thread prepped TD or someone might beat you to it.

Already Have

 

[jimmy35]

36 isn't really a "decent" pick though, so if us being pigheaded about giving that up is what costs us Houston it's a mistake.

Pretty common sense if it comes down to that Leppa will pull the trigger.

 

[lones37]

I can assure you he is coming to Victoria, and the deal will get done. He has planning the move since May, and the Melbourne deal was done, until the club imploded.

Once it is confirmed, I will outline why he's coming back.

 

[Pistol Night]

Pretty common sense if it comes down to that Leppa will pull the trigger.

And just shoot the campaigner?