Pick 1 2023 Trade value - What would it take?

[Psicosis]

and both pick 8 &12 ended up with rising stars nominations plus Culley who was msd last year ended up with one as well.
we ended up with three and so did your mob.So if we are rabble so must your mob be.

It was a good deal for all parties. I know your “mob” like to Dodoro this, but reality is a deal of early pick swaps will be done to help both clubs get the outcome they want. Last year was an excellent example.

 

[amazingjoshy]

Yeah I do not buy this bs one bit. There was no clear talent at 2 that wanted to go to WA.

The trade worked out well for all parties & contradicts the WC poster notion that your club are going to bleed ours dry in a pick swap.

Most WC posters have said it would take 2&3 (or some variation) to get it done but don't actually think it would be offered

 

[Eastern Rangers]

Most WC posters have said it would take 2&3 (or some variation) to get it done but don't actually think it would be offered

Unless North changes their draft hand now and between draft night a deal is unlikely.

 

[HairyO]

Most WC posters have said it would take 2&3 (or some variation) to get it done but don't actually think it would be offered

I think this has been the case all along. Unless its picks which guarantee Curtin and McKercher/Duursma/etc. then they wouldnt want to trade, and anyone who could get those players wouldnt want to give them up for Reid.

Or shouldnt anyway. 2 potentially brilliant players is better than one potentially insane player.

 

[RanaNaved]

I reckon a trade will get done for pick number 1 (hey that rhymes).
Eagles fans everywhere start getting your heads around the idea!!

 

[bh90210fan]

I reckon a trade will get done for pick number 1 (hey that rhymes).
Eagles fans everywhere start getting your heads around the idea!!

If it does North won’t be holding two of the first three picks in this years draft that’s for sure

 

[The Nostradamus]

If it does North won’t be holding two of the first three picks in this years draft that’s for sure

We’ve already said we will 100% be holding 2 top 3 picks

Question is will it be 1 and 3 or 2 and 3 as it is now

 

[bh90210fan]

We’ve already said we will 100% be holding 2 top 3 picks

Question is will it be 1 and 3 or 2 and 3 as it is now

Well it won’t be 1 & 3 will it

 

[the big lebowski]

Using JHF as an example of why WC shouldn't take Reid makes no sense, I'm not sure why it keeps getting brought up.

That's the worst case scenario, the guy sooks it up after one year (which I'm pretty sure Reid wont).....and it's still very arguable if North is worse or better off than if they had just taken the pre draft trade from the Crows

If anything it's the perfect example of why WC should take the (so-called) "risk"

I’m convinced JHF got exactly what was planned all along.

He wanted to get to port, he said all the things north wanted to hear so we wouldn’t trade the pick to the crows. He panned to see out his initial contract and then leave but used the Clarko bombshell to get out of dodge early.

As you said, reid is nothing like that, and actually called out his decision.

Reid will spend the first half of his career at west coast if you draft him.

 

[Barrybran]

I’m convinced JHF got exactly what was planned all along.

He wanted to get to port, he said all the things north wanted to hear so we wouldn’t trade the pick to the crows. He panned to see out his initial contract and then leave but used the Clarko bombshell to get out of dodge early.

As you said, reid is nothing like that, and actually called out his decision.

Reid will spend the first half of his career at west coast if you draft him.

I'm sure Geelong already have him on their board for 2030

 

[The Nostradamus]

Well it won’t be 1 & 3 will it

Yeah fair we might have 1 and 2

We did essentially give up 3 and 15 for pick 1 last year (With JHF going for pick 2)

So probably do the same again

 

[bh90210fan]

Yeah fair we might have 1 and 2

We did essentially give up 3 and 15 for pick 1 last year

I don’t know why North supporters seem to think offering a whole heap of junk buys them Harley Reid.

 

[The Nostradamus]

I don’t know why North supporters seem to think offering a whole heap of junk buys them Harley Reid.

A bunch of junk?

You mean what we got for pick 1 last year

 

[bh90210fan]

A bunch of junk?

You mean what we got for pick 1 last year

Pick 3 and a couple of picks that’ll end up in the 20’s is a bunch of junk, yes.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Pick 3 and a couple of picks that’ll end up in the 20’s is a bunch of junk, yes.

lol you still get the 15th best player available despite if it goes back a few picks due to bids

People trying to diminish picks back due to academy kids that they weren’t able to pick is laughable

The going rate for pick 1 was set last year

Expect something similar at best

 

[bh90210fan]

lol you still get the 15th best player available

People trying to push picks back due to academy kids that they weren’t able to pick is laughable

The going rate for pick 1 was set last year

Expect something similar at best

We’re not giving up Aaron Cadman here. You might want to see if you can split that pick 3 of yours and offer something inside the top 10 along with pick 2 if you want to be serious. Your junk picks won’t cut it.

 

[The Nostradamus]

We’re not giving up Aaron Cadman here. You might want to see if you can split that pick 3 of yours and offer something inside the top 10 along with pick 2 if you want to be serious. Your junk picks won’t cut it.

We’d be happy taking 2 and 3 to the draft if it doesn’t cut it

Either way we are having 2 top 3 picks

 

[bh90210fan]

We’d be happy taking 2 and 3 to the draft if it doesn’t cut it

Either way we are having 2 top 3 picks

Would you give up Reid for pick 3 and a pick in the 20’s?

 

[Jeremias]

The going rate for pick 1 was set last year

You don't really believe that do you?

Surely you recognize there are a heap of factors that would change the value of pick 1 every year?

 

[The Nostradamus]

Would you give up Reid for pick 3 and a pick in the 20’s?

No cos he’s Victorian and won’t do a JHF

But I would if I were you

 

[bh90210fan]

No cos he’s Victorian and won’t do a JHF

But I would if I were you

Luckily it’s not a concern for us then.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Luckily it’s not a concern for us

I’ve got useless things to sell you if you really believe that

 

[bh90210fan]

I’ve got useless things to sell you if you really believe that

West Coast have a knack of helping players settle in and feel right at home real quick. I’m sure Reid and his family won’t be any different.

 

[bzparkes]

I’ve got useless things to sell you if you really believe that

Not every club is useless at settling in top end draft talent.

 

[Obeanie1]

Again, Sheezel is a jewish kid from Elsternwick who played at Ajax and went to Mt Scopus (I don't know if you are familiar with the Caulfield and Elsternwick areas of Melbourne)

32% of these suburbs are Jewish and are the largest Jewish communities in Australia.

I don't see it any different to an aboriginal kid not wanting to move away from their community in SA or WA.


It sucks for some teams, but other clubs have been on the receiving end plenty of times also.


It's clearly a unique situation given the amount of Jewish footballers to play AFL football.


It will happen more and more with the Sudanese draft prospects over the next decade(s) also imo.

I cannot believe you are using the indigenous example to defend entitled rich
kids at private schools not wanting to move interstate.

Rich entitled private school boys versus disadvantaged first nations kids with extremely close family ties and ties to home and country.

And the way you are peddling this BS it it's like only WA indigenous players don't like relocating. Well firstly plenty do move. Some even choose to be traded but not back home. And secondly this issue affects every club in every state.

Just seems to be a recent pandemic for Vic Metro kids pushing back on moving interstate.