Player X or Player Y

[rjslcM]

SFisher or HShaw or Enright or Thornton?

Ziebell or Sidebottom or Swift or Palmer?

Hurley or Waite?

Deledio or Vince or Gibbs?

Gray or Rioli?

Thankyou.

 

[Borrus]

Presuming he's your sixth fwd, Vez. If your seventh, Walker as there will be moments of greater upside with less consistency

Houli, Masten or A Walker + $83K??

A Walker at the moment watch him in the NAB cup if his shoulders are okay then he is easily the best and he'll make money.
Byrnes Vs. Gray Vs. Knights

 

[StGradey]

Goodwin or Drummond?

 

[Super Hans]

I would go niether. Old vs injury prone but if it had to be one it would be drummond for more upside.

Trengove vs morabito vs cunnington for 5th mid

 

[swansfan51]

Here's a few player comparisons that should offer some real insight into your selections.

Gram destroys Stokes
Bock smashes Bird
Lovett beats Chick, Black and Brown
Fev has trouble with Knights because he cant get past Glass
McVeigh all too often downs Hahn
Kerr has been stung by Ray
Milne and Montagna avoid Bail
Cousins is controlled by Sellar, wants Moore
Didak will let off Rounds
Hogan continually rolls Schulz
Fev will be brough undone by a mad Mundy
Drummond will be carved apart by Surjan
Hall is dangerous if he is playing Cross
Fev cant sink Lower
Heath Shaw will be hurt by Carr, Stack
Franklin is worse than Pratt
Renouf hotter than Savage, Currie
Entire Blues side in trouble with Skipper
Judd, Gawn, Franklin, Dunn. Will miss games

Most players will have trouble with Hooker and Betts

Clunk, that's top shelf

 

[daveymak]

Mclean, Kerr gets a bit punch and is carrying injuries, mcclean if gets a a game will be tag free.

nah he isnt

 

[Hurdley]

Here's a few player comparisons that should offer some real insight into your selections.

Gram destroys Stokes
Bock smashes Bird
Lovett beats Chick, Black and Brown
Fev has trouble with Knights because he cant get past Glass
McVeigh all too often downs Hahn
Kerr has been stung by Ray
Milne and Montagna avoid Bail
Cousins is controlled by Sellar, wants Moore
Didak will let off Rounds
Hogan continually rolls Schulz
Fev will be brough undone by a mad Mundy
Drummond will be carved apart by Surjan
Hall is dangerous if he is playing Cross
Fev cant sink Lower
Heath Shaw will be hurt by Carr, Stack
Franklin is worse than Pratt
Renouf hotter than Savage, Currie
Entire Blues side in trouble with Skipper
Judd, Gawn, Franklin, Dunn. Will miss games

Most players will have trouble with Hooker and Betts

I liked it.

I would go niether. Old vs injury prone but if it had to be one it would be drummond for more upside.

Trengove vs morabito vs cunnington for 5th mid

I'd predict Trengove to manage the highest average of those, but morabito to play the most games. Cunnington looks great, but there's some talk of little injury issues during his preseason? At the moment my pick of those is Trengove, but obviously the NAB cup will tell us alot.

I've got two:
Fisher vs Hurn
Jolly vs HMac vs Clark

 

[rjslcM]

I've got two:
Fisher vs Hurn
Jolly vs HMac vs Clark

Fisher, quite comfortably.
Clark over Hamish and Jolly.

I've got three:
Ziebell or Palmer?
SFisher or HShaw?
LeCras or Gray?

 

[BILC]

Go Palmer for the first one
Fisher more reliable
And Gray is more likely to break out i think


Heres mine i have 229,600 left for a backman who should i get out of
Myers
Raines
X.Clarke
J.Smith
T.Callan
Schoenmakers
Waters
Sheppard
Talia
Moore

 

[Rioli]

Fisher, quite comfortably.
Clark over Hamish and Jolly.

I've got three:
Ziebell or Palmer?
SFisher or HShaw?
LeCras or Gray?

I'm not sure what made you say Fisher comfortably over Hurn. Fisher is aging and will turn 28 this year I believe. Will start to slow down, Hurn is much younger and should be getting even better. Not to mention that Fisher has much more players on his team stealing points from him. Go Hurn. I'd pick Clark over HMac and Jolly though.

For your questions:
Ziebell
Shaw
LeCras

Go Palmer for the first one
Fisher more reliable
And Gray is more likely to break out i think


Heres mine i have 229,600 left for a backman who should i get out of
Myers
Raines
X.Clarke
J.Smith
T.Callan
Schoenmakers
Waters
Sheppard
Talia
Moore

It's out of Sheppard and Schoenmakers.
Schoenmakers should play every game of the season and has gotten MUCH bigger over pre-season. Looking faster as well. I would go with him.

Gibbs VS Deledio VS Vince

 

[StGradey]

I have $352,400 left in the salary cap, who should i get ?

Dangerfield, Ziebell, M. Williams, Polkinghorne, or Murphy if i get $2,000

and who should i get on the bench around $94,000?

 

[Headless]

I have $352,400 left in the salary cap, who should i get ?

Dangerfield, Ziebell, M. Williams, Polkinghorne, or Murphy if i get $2,000

and who should i get on the bench around $94,000?

Ziebell slightly ahead of Dangerfield, I reckon.


Harvey vs. Cooney?

 

[thomas_m18]

I'm not sure what made you say Fisher comfortably over Hurn. Fisher is aging and will turn 28 this year I believe. Will start to slow down, Hurn is much younger and should be getting even better. Not to mention that Fisher has much more players on his team stealing points from him. Go Hurn. I'd pick Clark over HMac and Jolly though.

For your questions:
Ziebell
Shaw
LeCras



It's out of Sheppard and Schoenmakers.
Schoenmakers should play every game of the season and has gotten MUCH bigger over pre-season. Looking faster as well. I would go with him.

Gibbs VS Deledio VS Vince

I have Vince on my team, but compared to the other 2, Gibbs is probably the best choice.


My turn now.

Hayes and Montagna or Ablett and O'Keefe?

 

[Rioli]

I have Vince on my team, but compared to the other 2, Gibbs is probably the best choice.


My turn now.

Hayes and Montagna or Ablett and O'Keefe?

Hayes and Montagna will take points from each other

Hamish McIntosh or Mitch Clark

Jarred Waite & Jordan Lewis or Mark LeCras/Robbie Gray & Daniel Kerr

 

[wheels4]

Beau Waters or Bradley Sheppard

 

[thomas_m18]

Hayes and Montagna will take points from each other

Hamish McIntosh or Mitch Clark

Jarred Waite & Jordan Lewis or Mark LeCras/Robbie Gray & Daniel Kerr

I'd say Clark and the first combo

 

[Antz]

I commented before and no one commented on mine

Scott Pendlebury vs Joel Selwood

 

[roosaints]

Hard to split. Both gun supercoachers. Selwood the better footballer so probably him.

Drummond v Goodwin

 

[wheels4]

Tough one but Drummond, missing out a few games a year and still dominates and goodwins ageing.

Brad Sheppard or Beau Waters?

 

[Borrus]

Joel just, I just love him, last year he was one of my best players I always knew he could perform and I think he plays better in SC as well. I just think he is a gun, he and Gibbs I think will be top 2 for the charlie this year

 

[Rioli]

Vince and Selwood

or

Dal Santo and Kerr/Lewis.

 

[theCATSfromHELL]

Tough one but Drummond, missing out a few games a year and still dominates and goodwins ageing.

Brad Sheppard or Beau Waters?

So that translated into English = Drummond > Goodwin?

 

[wheels4]

So that translated into English = Drummond > Goodwin?

Pretty much mate,
I had Drummond last 2 years and was brilliant except for injuries worth the risk.

 

[FBDonkey]

Vince and Selwood

or

Dal Santo and Kerr/Lewis.

Vince and Selwood. By a fair way

 

[wheels4]

Brad Sheppard or Beau Waters anybody haha