Player X or Player Y

[Sunday Red]

Considering how oftern the ball goes into melbourne's defence you'd assume that Macdonalds numbers would significantly improve.

Symes will be solid and not alot of people have him, so you could go him for the unique option.

Personally i'd go with Jmac..!

Need help.

Goddard and Sylvia OR Chapman and Fisher

The former. Easily.

I'm staying well clear of Paul Chapman.

Patrick Dangerfield 332
vs
Jack Ziebell 320
vs
Mark Williams 303k

 

[stretcharmstrong]

The former. Easily.

I'm staying well clear of Paul Chapman.

Patrick Dangerfield 332
vs
Jack Ziebell 320
vs
Mark Williams 303k

Can't decide between the top two myself (would like to find a way to include both...) and not really considering Williams so will leave this for someone else.

What about: G. Johncock v J. Macdonald

Fair price difference, currently have Johncock as 3rd prem. def., would love to free up a little cash...

 

[Unknown Identity]

Can't decide between the top two myself (would like to find a way to include both...) and not really considering Williams so will leave this for someone else.

What about: G. Johncock v J. Macdonald

Fair price difference, currently have Johncock as 3rd prem. def., would love to free up a little cash...

JMac's number's will improve due to being in melbourne's young backline, will rack up numbers and should see him average between 85-95 this season. Don't really see Johncock improving on last years average. Free up the cash is say.

Another one for you guys.. Midfield dilemma

Kerr and Dangerfield OR Vince and Trengove

 

[cooney_cougs]

Another one for you guys.. Midfield dilemma

Kerr and Dangerfield OR Vince and Trengove

i'd go with vince/trengove ... don't mess with kerr!

a complex one for someone to help me with.

h.shaw (back) + trengove

OR

dangerfield (forward) + masten

i'll use jarrad waite as a for whichever position is left to fill.

 

[marky53]

i'd go with vince/trengove ... don't mess with kerr!

a complex one for someone to help me with.

h.shaw (back) + trengove

OR

dangerfield (forward) + masten

i'll use jarrad waite as a for whichever position is left to fill.

i'd go shaw and trengove as he will be a cash cow.... keep dangerfield forward but I would stay away from masten........ also be weary of waite coming back from knee.....

schoenmakers or ladson or hunt - all are well priced but who will play regularly and score?

 

[PIES_09]

i'd go shaw and trengove as he will be a cash cow.... keep dangerfield forward but I would stay away from masten........ also be weary of waite coming back from knee.....

schoenmakers or ladson or hunt - all are well priced but who will play regularly and score?

id have to go with Josh Hunt only because he will fit back into a Geelong Backline really well after a year off to reasses his game, Shoenmakers not teh best SC scorer and Ladson i dnt no about he could be a good option if u really have no cash left but Hunt for me..

Anthony Morabito or
Dustin Martin

 

[stkildathunda]

yea hayes is under a injury cloud stress fractures in his foot id stay well clear of him..

hahaha stay clear of him if you want to believe media rubbish. He came out and said he didnt have ANY stress fractures or any injuries. Has been training and running since christmas. He had off-season surgery on the elbow but thats it.

http://www.saints.com.au/season2009/news/newsarticle/tabid/5315/newsid/89175/default.aspx

 

[stretcharmstrong]

hahaha stay clear of him if you want to believe media rubbish. He came out and said he didnt have ANY stress fractures or any injuries. Has been training and running since christmas. He had off-season surgery on the elbow but thats it.

http://www.saints.com.au/season2009/news/newsarticle/tabid/5315/newsid/89175/default.aspx

Thanks for the heads-up. Although the article didn't say no to injury worries, just that he's been running since Christmas... goddammiiiit, who the hell are we to trust!?

 

[stkildathunda]

Thanks for the heads-up. Although the article didn't say no to injury worries, just that he's been running since Christmas... goddammiiiit, who the hell are we to trust!?

We have our intra-club this friday so that'll give everyone better idea at hows he's tracking. But going from what ive seen of him at the 2 training sessions ive been too, id pick him with 100% confidence.

 

[year of the cat]

Vezpremi or L.Jetta? - similarly priced forwardline options.

 

[thomas_m18]

Vezpremi or L.Jetta? - similarly priced forwardline options.

Dunno enough about either to really make a good decision.

My question: Jarrad Waite or Macdonald?

 

[PIES_09]

Kennelly or Malceski - ive heard Malceski, has been training teh house down and i dunno but he has been a good SC scorer in previous years prior to 2009

 

[russea]

L.Jetta is the better player but im not sure how often he will play for the bombers

 

[russea]

Kennelys in really good shape if uv got the cash go 4 him

 

[russea]

Dunno enough about either to really make a good decision.

My question: Jarrad Waite or Macdonald?

Macdonald only cause waites coming of injury

 

[The Sultan]

Vezpremi or L.Jetta? - similarly priced forwardline options.

skip both and look at Taylor Walker (adl) $239,400 may be his breakout year.

 

[PIES_09]

Good thourght on Taylor Walker heard his been bulking up and smashing em

 

[thomas_m18]

Alright. One more question.

Ryan Hargrave or Paul Duffield? Haven't heard much about Hargrave (or Duffield really), but thoughts on the subject are nice.

Oh, and is Kane Lucas a good mid reserve, considering the Carlton midfield?

 

[PIES_09]

Bit of a dilema..
Need to pick a player but have so many to choose from thourghts on what use would pick..
Hayes
Dal Santo
Chappy
Murphy
Goodes
Sewell
Judd
Bartell
or
Mitchell or ROK

 

[Borrus]

Hayes Will be hungrier this year I think he will be so close to Ablett in SC at the end of this year
Dal Santo Even after last year I till hate the fact that a decent tag can easily shut him out of the game, I just thin that would be very frustrating.
Chappy Too injury prone, will never get him when he's 600k nd is guaranteed to miss games.
Murphy I heard he has had a bit of an injury scare wouldn't go there could cop more of a tag this year
Goodes Slow starter, look at him as an upgrade option
Sewell A good player and a diferent pick as well a good choice
Judd Will miss the first three games, again maybe an upgrade option
Bartel Good player again. Cheaper than last year and a etter option, the second there's a drop of rain he'll be top scorer
or
Mitchell or ROK Both good choices Mitchell is coping better with the tag and could average 110+ ROK is good to a gun will not lt you down.
I wold go for Hayes or Sewell. Hayes might get a few more points but less people will have sewell and he'd be a good point of diference, depends what you're looking for.
Mine is Pav & Sylvia Vs. Pav & Gilbee

 

[thomas_m18]

Hayes Will be hungrier this year I think he will be so close to Ablett in SC at the end of this year
Dal Santo Even after last year I till hate the fact that a decent tag can easily shut him out of the game, I just thin that would be very frustrating.
Chappy Too injury prone, will never get him when he's 600k nd is guaranteed to miss games.
Murphy I heard he has had a bit of an injury scare wouldn't go there could cop more of a tag this year
Goodes Slow starter, look at him as an upgrade option
Sewell A good player and a diferent pick as well a good choice
Judd Will miss the first three games, again maybe an upgrade option
Bartel Good player again. Cheaper than last year and a etter option, the second there's a drop of rain he'll be top scorer
or
Mitchell or ROK Both good choices Mitchell is coping better with the tag and could average 110+ ROK is good to a gun will not lt you down.
I wold go for Hayes or Sewell. Hayes might get a few more points but less people will have sewell and he'd be a good point of diference, depends what you're looking for.
Mine is Pav & Sylvia Vs. Pav & Gilbee

Wait, so Pav is virtually guaranteed in the squad? Good choice.

Uhhh, I would take Sylvia, because Gilbee frustrated me a little last year at times, and I dunno about Sylvia, but he seems like an alright choice. Although, if you want money, Gilbee is a good choice, considering he can be used in an upgrade.

My question - Duffield or Hargrave, incase you missed it.

 

[russea]

Mabye duffield he wont get points taken by his team mates

 

[russea]

Got a bit of a problem
Mumford or White
Mumford i think will play number 1 ruckman for swans but then white should play forward???

 

[thomas_m18]

Got a bit of a problem
Mumford or White
Mumford i think will play number 1 ruckman for swans but then white should play forward???

Well, how many points do you think Mumford will make away from ruck contests? Will he make conisistant points during normal play? I'd take White, but I'm not entirely sure.

My Question:

Ziebell or Murphy? (probably been asked before, but I'm scratching my head now)

 

[stretcharmstrong]

We have our intra-club this friday so that'll give everyone better idea at hows he's tracking. But going from what ive seen of him at the 2 training sessions ive been too, id pick him with 100% confidence.

Sweet as, thanks again.