Player X v Y v Z

[DV2000]

Ed Philips vs Dylan Clarke?

Cumming Vs Heron Vs Ridley?

I'm mainly looking for the player with the better job security.

 

[Andrew Birch]

I liked the part where you admonished yourself

I see no point in just typing a player name I think he should trade in. Means nothing to me without a why? Unless you're that lazy type of coach who looks at it as 3 votes for player X vs 1 vote for player Y and decides their trade on that.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Ed Philips vs Dylan Clarke?

Cumming Vs Heron Vs Ridley?

I'm mainly looking for the player with the better job security.

Phillips
Cumming.

Gotta go with known quantities

 

[Feerits Elf]

Ed Phillips vs Dylan Clarke?

Phillips I reckon. Endurance beast and will be a shining light for us

Bombers mids a bit of a revolving door at the moment

 

[Feerits Elf]

Three onfield of:

Guelfi v Geelong (MCG)
Ronke v Freo (SCG)
Fritsch v Carlton (MCG)
Spargo v Carlton (MCG)
Waterman v Richmond (Perth)
Higgins v West Coast (Perth)

 

[Me Myself and I]

Three onfield of:

Guelfi v Geelong (MCG)
Ronke v Freo (SCG)
Fritsch v Carlton (MCG)
Spargo v Carlton (MCG)
Waterman v Richmond (Perth)
Higgins v West Coast (Perth)

Top three listed.

 

[swindle]

Need to field one of these;

Guelfi
ZGL
Phillips
Spargo
Brayshaw
Holman

Which one?

 

[balmainforever]

Mirra v Murphy on field?

I'm in the same boat. I went Mirra vs lions at gabba over murphy vs dogs at adel oval

 

[Hai_Newman]

I'm in the same boat. I went Mirra vs lions at gabba over murphy vs dogs at adel oval

+1

 

[Pedro]

I have to field one of Coffield, L.Murphy & Ed Richards. No loophole options. Who's the best bet? (I know the real answer is none of them probably)

 

[ohh_v]

Field one out of Coffield, Spargo or Holman?

 

[JuddgementDay]

Field two zgl guelfi henry
Yeah pretty weak fwd line

 

[evo]

Need some help campaigners. I foolishly put the E on Spud Murphy in my backline. Duman is my only loop option, apart from Barry if I VC Cogs
If I want to take say Dangers VC I will have to eat Murphys score.
I have Finlayson playing up next, but have a switch option with Coffield.
I suspect Finlayson can go over 51 which Murphy scored but maybe Coffield can too. But if Finlayson looks like going really big by half time and I have him on midfielod bench could take Zerret out.
Currently have it set like this.

thoughts?

 

[Blueforce]

Field one out of Coffield, Spargo or Holman?

Spargo - dees forward line could have a big day tomorrow

Cole or finlayson?

 

[SC fish]

Field one out of Coffield, Spargo or Holman?

Spargo

 

[SC fish]

Need some help campaigners. I foolishly put the E on Spud Murphy in my backline. Duman is my only loop option, apart from Barry if I VC Cogs
If I want to take say Dangers VC I will have to eat Murphys score.
I have Finlayson playing up next, but have a switch option with Coffield.
I suspect Finlayson can go over 51 which Murphy scored but maybe Coffield can too. But if Finlayson looks like going really big by half time and I have him on midfielod bench could take Zerret out.
Currently have it set like this.

thoughts?

View attachment 499337

I'd stick with what you've got and you'll have to factor in Murphys score when deciding whether or not to take Dangers score as VC.

And yep if Finlayson is going large (i.e heading for a ton) by the time the Port game starts switch Barry with Kelly or Merrett.

 

[Squiba]

Just a quickie.

Spargo vs Ronke

ATM fielding Ronke

 

[SC fish]

Just a quickie.

Spargo vs Ronke

ATM fielding Ronke

Have to go Ronke after last week?

 

[Meksss]

Need some help campaigners. I foolishly put the E on Spud Murphy in my backline. Duman is my only loop option, apart from Barry if I VC Cogs
If I want to take say Dangers VC I will have to eat Murphys score.
I have Finlayson playing up next, but have a switch option with Coffield.
I suspect Finlayson can go over 51 which Murphy scored but maybe Coffield can too. But if Finlayson looks like going really big by half time and I have him on midfielod bench could take Zerret out.
Currently have it set like this.

thoughts?

View attachment 499337

wtf is coffield doing up back when goatlayson is on the mid bench?!!

 

[JDavey]

Spargo v Guelfi v Holman?

Currently on Spargo just because of opposition

 

[JJ14AU]

Spargo v Guelfi v Holman?

Currently on Spargo just because of opposition

Same but thinking last minute switch to Guelfi over Spargo

 

[SC fish]

Play Fritsch or Mason Cox on the field? 33 minutes to decide no pressure

Or take Henry's loopholed score?

 

[evo]

Fritsch on the wing looked good.

 

[Moustachio]

Take Guelfi 61 or back SPargo in for a big one against Carlton?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Take Guelfi 61 or back SPargo in for a big one against Carlton?

Back Spargo.

At worst you will lose about 11 points...