Player X vs Player Y (Part II)

[Pedsy]

Pav or Fyfe?
Can't split them for my final fwd upgrade.

 

[Baxter23]

Pav or Fyfe?
Can't split them for my final fwd upgrade.

Pav, known supercoach performer and has the stats to prove it, having said that, I don't think you could go wrong with either.



Mine is,

Is it risky to trade Zac Smith out for Vardy before Vardy's price goes up while Smith is covering for Sandi?

I have Bailey on my bench also.

 

[SoupAStars]

Pav or Fyfe?
Can't split them for my final fwd upgrade.

You can't but Fyfe can...talking about his shoulder and socket.
Decision made?

 

[Pedsy]

Yes, I think it is!

 

[Spudregus_87]

Shaw & Pavlich

or

Deledio & Kennedy/ROK/Rioli

 

[Moogs]

can you do shaw, franklin, lower?

Nope.. Not enough dollars unless I touched Zac Smith..
I think I might just go for Enright and Lower in the end.. and then either save my trade to Franklin for later (after R17??) since I have Rioli too..

Or go for Brennan who has averaged 107.1 if you discount his first game..


I'm much more happy with Lower D7 and Heppell as D8/M7 than Heppell D7 and Stanley or Puopolo D8..
If you take our Lower's substituted scores, he would average 95.4 which is more than Suckling and Gibbs - who I also have..

This will leave me with:
D7/D8: Lower/Heppell
M6/M7: Hodge/Hibberd
F7/F8: N.Reiwoldt/Brennan
with Jacobs, Puopolo, I.Smith, Prestia and Callinan warming the bench and 6 trades...

 

[Moogs]

Shaw & Pavlich

or

Deledio & Kennedy/ROK/Rioli

Flip a coin..

They are all very similar in terms of averages and probably what they will score to the end of the season, although some more risky and probably with higher rewards (see rioli).. It depends on how many players you have at a bye on at the same time in my opinion..

If you have Goodes/J.Roo/Nahas, Franklin/Roughead, Fyfe/Sylvia/Knights/Mzungu/Callinan/etc..., Adcock - then don't get ROK, Rioli, Pav, Deledio respectively..

Edit: if you are after overall ranking..

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Shaw & Pavlich

or

Deledio & Kennedy/ROK/Rioli

I'd be very tempted to get Rioli in. Unfortunately for me he was injured when I made my forward upgrades.

Lids is in sensational form, but so is Heater, flip on that one (I've got them both). Of the other two definitely between Pav or Cyril. Pav for his consistency and Cyril for his ability to pile on the scores.

He managed 55 DT for 100 SC a few weeks back - Insane!

 

[Ed_Gein]

Shaw & Pavlich

or

Deledio & Kennedy/ROK/Rioli

Deledio + Rioli for me.

I say that because i'm just waiting on Shaw having a forward tag put on him causing his scores to suffer.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

2 of Stevie J, Chapman, Fyfe, Rioli, O'Keefe, Pavlich

 

[RWnBluey]

2 of Stevie J, Chapman, Fyfe, Rioli, O'Keefe, Pavlich

Don't trust chappys groins, Stevie J and Pavlich for mine

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Just a bit worried with Pav in the last few. Seems all over the joint

 

[toxic]

2 of Stevie J, Chapman, Fyfe, Rioli, O'Keefe, Pavlich

Rioli and PAV. - think of finals and cats bye. Hawks have easy run home so Rioli is a lock.

 

[J Squad]

Deledio + Rioli for me.

I say that because i'm just waiting on Shaw having a forward tag put on him causing his scores to suffer.

Oh I hope it happens sooner rather than later

 

[controlKLICK]

Strauss v Simpkin?

Any concerns for job security, or is there a better rookie I may have missed.

 

[skyfia]

Midfielder upgrade, plenty of $ available from the sandi downgrade, currently have Pendlebury, Swan, Selwood, Murphy.

Ablett (566k, resting risk late season, highest upside)
Mundy (486k, cheapish, seems pretty reliable, already have pav and fyfe)
Priddis (503k, not sure about the eagles, seems pretty consistent)
Boyd (509k, high BE, could be another mid upgrade in a couple of weeks)
Dal Santo (471k, saints up and down)
Mitchell (461k, cheap, low BE, a bit more variance in his scores)
Bartel (430k, cheap, already have selwood and chappy, wary of the finals bye)

who do you think?

 

[Daniels]

Midfielder upgrade, plenty of $ available from the sandi downgrade, currently have Pendlebury, Swan, Selwood, Murphy.

Ablett (566k, resting risk late season, highest upside)
Mundy (486k, cheapish, seems pretty reliable, already have pav and fyfe)
Priddis (503k, not sure about the eagles, seems pretty consistent)
Boyd (509k, high BE, could be another mid upgrade in a couple of weeks)
Dal Santo (471k, saints up and down)
Mitchell (461k, cheap, low BE, a bit more variance in his scores)
Bartel (430k, cheap, already have selwood and chappy, wary of the finals bye)

who do you think?

If you still have 2 MID upgrades to do I reckon this week swoop on the best value for money bottomed out premium with a low BE IMO.

I like Priddis, Dal and Mitchell purely on unique-ness, prices and abilities. All 3 look very nice as a M6

 

[Daniels]

2 of Stevie J, Chapman, Fyfe, Rioli, O'Keefe, Pavlich

Stevie J and Pav

 

[we57st]

Who's more likely to play - Hibberd or S.Buckley?

 

[Daniels]

Who's more likely to play - Hibberd or S.Buckley?

Both in same boat. Reckon both will play considering who are named along side them on extended benches

 

[we57st]

Has Buckley come up OK after being injured?

 

[Daniels]

Has Buckley come up OK after being injured?

As far as I know he is ok, maybe check Collingwood boards to see if anything has been mentioned.

 

[reddahaydn]

Hibberd i would think should start.

What would you prefer...

50k, Sandi, Lynch and Matera (darling of on the bench)

107k, Griffen, Krak, Darling (darling on bench)

 

[DamoCFC]

Fyfe in the mid, Franklin in the fwd.

Both carrying injuries

I have mzungu to cover one of these too.

The question is, who needs the cover more? Who is less likely to play?

 

[Daniels]

Fyfe in the mid, Franklin in the fwd.

Both carrying injuries

I have mzungu to cover one of these too.

The question is, who needs the cover more? Who is less likely to play?

Franklin