Player X vs Y vs Z - 2016

[DraftPunk]

Shiel v Rocky

 

[King_Steele]

Shiel v Rocky

Rocky.

 

[DraftPunk]

Rocky.

Yeah thinking Rocky, despite his injury risk his ceiling is huge. Shiel just about my favourite player to watch from another club though. Absolute star.

 

[RWnBluey]

Bringing in a mid this week.

Current mids: Danger, Pendles, Selwood, GAJ, Libba, Parker, Smith, Hopper

Can afford anyone. Should I go:

Neale
Hannebery (+$14k) or
Gray (+$105k)

Think Gray is great value or do I go one of the other two?

 

[The Lemon]

Bringing in a mid this week.

Current mids: Danger, Pendles, Selwood, GAJ, Libba, Parker, Smith, Hopper

Can afford anyone. Should I go:

Neale
Hannebery (+$14k) or
Gray (+$105k)

Think Gray is great value or do I go one of the other two?

Neale is a beast.
Hannebery is a filthy little pig. Just hunts the ball.
Gray is a soft**** campaigner.

i'd go Neale

 

[RWnBluey]

Neale is a beast.
Hannebery is a filthy little pig. Just hunts the ball.
Gray is a soft**** campaigner.

i'd go Neale

ok, now the objective opinion?

Neale obviously the best hence the price, but you don't think Gray represents great value?

 

[The Lemon]

ok, now the objective opinion?

Neale obviously the best hence the price, but you don't think Gray represents great value?

Not consistent value. Travel away and Gray goes to shit.

Neale and Hanna will pig out wherever they go.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Not consistent value. Travel away and Gray goes to shit.

Neale and Hanna will pig out wherever they go.

Not a gray fan?

Neale and hanners are dirty sc pigs I prob look at getting one thou the bye weeks I need a SP gun mid.

 

[The Lemon]

Not a gray fan?

Neale and hanners are dirty sc pigs I prob look at getting one thou the bye weeks I need a SP gun mid.

I got gray, but he is gonna have down weeks.

Those others will rarely spud it

 

[mac17]

Gray vs Selwood

 

[JDC!]

Gray vs Selwood

Selwood!

 

[JDC!]

Weird sort of question but interested to hear some thoughts on which trade would be best.

J Smith --> T Rockliff
T Liberatore --> P Dangerfield
M Dea --> Rance

Current team looks like this:

B: Shaw, Simpson, Laird, Adams, Byrne-Jones, Dea (McTippa, Brown)
M: Pendlebury, Ablett, Parker, Ward, Selwood, Libba, Petracca, Hopper, (Smith, Gresham, Jansen)
R: Goldstein, Gawn, (Grimley)
F: Martin, Merrett, Wells, Franklin, Montagna, Kerridge, (Ben Ken, McCarthy).

 

[toxic]

Weird sort of question but interested to hear some thoughts on which trade would be best.

J Smith --> T Rockliff
T Liberatore --> P Dangerfield
M Dea --> Rance

Current team looks like this:

B: Shaw, Simpson, Laird, Adams, Byrne-Jones, Dea (McTippa, Brown)
M: Pendlebury, Ablett, Parker, Ward, Selwood, Libba, Petracca, Hopper, (Smith, Gresham, Jansen)
R: Goldstein, Gawn, (Grimley)
F: Martin, Merrett, Wells, Franklin, Montagna, Kerridge, (Ben Ken, McCarthy).

rocky

 

[Gene Simmons]

I'm going HALL --> WINGARD or ROCKLIFF

I'm leaning towards The Chad because of his DPP status.... But I don't know!!!

 

[stevebbb]

I'm going HALL --> WINGARD or ROCKLIFF

I'm leaning towards The Chad because of his DPP status.... But I don't know!!!

Chad is a forward only this year mate

Does that make your decision easier?

 

[Gene Simmons]

Chad is a forward only this year mate

Does that make your decision easier?

LoL...Oops

Thanks for that

So what do you think... Rockliff v Wingard ? (to replace Hall)

 

[stevebbb]

LoL...Oops

Thanks for that

So what do you think... Rockliff v Wingard ? (to replace Hall)

I'd go Chad, only because I hate despise don't trust Rocky

 

[Gene Simmons]

Here's another for you SC experts..

WELLS V THE CHAD

 

[Judd_Magic]

Here's another for you SC experts..

WELLS V THE CHAD

Doesn't every team already have Wells .ie. started with him?

 

[Deliverance]

Doesn't every team already have Wells .ie. started with him?

Some bad people traded him out.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Some bad people traded him out.

I kept Wells during carnage week and got rid of Barlow when he didn't get selected to avoid a donut.

In reality I should have got rid of Hall instead with his bung shoulder at the time.

Got to love hindsight.

PS.

Hall got traded out for Merrett this week.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Doesn't every team already have Wells .ie. started with him?

I was 1 of those teams but then I got sucked into the whole "his achilles is shot" story

I traded him for Zorko.... Even though not disappointed with him, time will say it was a sideways trade

 

[Blueforce]

Pendles or Neale?

 

[astro_toby]

Hey everyone

Need to get a ruckman from FA in my Draft league & below are my choices. This is a 1 week proposition, so who of the below is the most likely to have a big week?

Zac Smith
Matthew Kruezer
Rhys Stanley
Tom Nichols
Daniel Gorringe
Jon Griffin
Rory Lobb

 

[Determinant]

Hey everyone

Need to get a ruckman from FA in my Draft league & below are my choices. This is a 1 week proposition, so who of the below is the most likely to have a big week?

Zac Smith
Matthew Kruezer
Rhys Stanley
Tom Nichols
Daniel Gorringe
Jon Griffin
Rory Lobb

smith