Player X vs Y

[JPod_31]

You're kidding yourself

Hey, everyone says that they have finished their team but in a couple days time, they change it again.
Am I right?

 

[kananooks]

McVeigh 100 /Murphy 100 vs

Hurn 85 /Rockliff 120

hurn and rockliff just. toss of a coin really

 

[Big Fozza]

Great summery krk. Now i'm going to pounce on Webster even though i said 5 days ago that i will leave my team as it is.

I just gotta stop tinkering till teams are announced

Sent from my GT-I9507 using Tapatalk

 

[Big Fozza]

- 2x 90's from NAB 1&2 (inc. one from only ~12 poss. IIRC)
- great disposal & DE
- Saints early games have looked to get ball in his hands
- ball likely to be in Saints backline a fair bit in '14
- 240k & def rookie availability issues otherwise
- early Richo favourite (?)

Also; I'm not very confident of playing laidler on field. For extra 80k webster is worth considering as a stepping stone to fallen premium

Sent from my GT-I9507 using Tapatalk

 

[Kadog]

Rockliff, KSimpson, Laidler, Caddy vs
Pendles, McVeigh, Webster, McDonough (f6)

 

[kangaroos3]

Rockliff, KSimpson, Laidler, Caddy vs
Pendles, McVeigh, Webster, McDonough (f6)

That's a tough one, but I'd go for the 2nd option.

 

[kangaroos3]

K. Simpson D3 & R. Shaw D5

or

A. Walker D2 & J. Webster D5

 

[Fiasco]

Is go option 1, don't think Walkers going to be as good this year. Go Simpson & Webster and use the cash elsewhere.

 

[Kadog]

Is go option 1, don't think Walkers going to be as good this year. Go Simpson & Webster and use the cash elsewhere.

I agree.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I think theres a bit of bartel with walker he could be used else where.I'm going one highprice backman and get one/two as they drop on price.

 

[karaoke]

Wheres chips (fisher) and Roberton?

Not sure with Fisher, hasn't played yet,

Roberton played one rd of NAB, should be right to go rd 1 v Dees,

 

[Jiska]

Rockliff, KSimpson, Laidler, Caddy vs
Pendles, McVeigh, Webster, McDonough (f6)

2nd option by a long way

 

[Jiska]

K. Simpson D3 & R. Shaw D5

or

A. Walker D2 & J. Webster D5

Go Simpson & Webster and use the cash elsewhere.

Agreed

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

Not quite an X vs Y question but, if you had to pick two of Fyfe, Libba and Cotchin, which two would you pick? Why?

Also, does anyone think any of the three will outscore Barlow this year? Why?

 

[Jiska]

Not quite an X vs Y question but, if you had to pick two of Fyfe, Libba and Cotchin, which two would you pick? Why?

Also, does anyone think any of the three will outscore Barlow this year? Why?

Libba and Cotchin (Assuming you've got Rocky).

Fyfe has horrible disposal and is #1 in the league for Clangers. Until he can fix that....

I see all three out scoring Barlow, natural improvement. Barlow IMO is at his max output.

 

[Fiasco]

Libba and Cotchin (Assuming you've got Rocky).

Fyfe has horrible disposal and is #1 in the league for Clangers. Until he can fix that....

I see all three out scoring Barlow, natural improvement. Barlow IMO is at his max output.

Agreed, I'm going for all three of Libba, Cotchin and Rocky. Just think there all set for massive improvement and have room to increase there avg.

 

[Boris the Contradiction]

Libba and Cotchin (Assuming you've got Rocky).

Fyfe has horrible disposal and is #1 in the league for Clangers. Until he can fix that....

I see all three out scoring Barlow, natural improvement. Barlow IMO is at his max output.

Thanks, that's really useful.

 

[Judd_Magic]

- 2x 90's from NAB 1&2 (inc. one from only ~12 poss. IIRC)
- great disposal & DE
- Saints early games have looked to get ball in his hands
- ball likely to be in Saints backline a fair bit in '14
- 240k & def rookie availability issues otherwise
- early Richo favourite (?)

Edit - mainly due to structure, not in my team ATM

Webster and Griffiths both locked in at D5 and D6.

No Suckling and McDonald for me.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Caddyshack will prob runout of steam in the 2nd half of the year.He will be upgraded before bundy and mots get back Or around that time.

True.

I plan to upgrade Caddy to NRoo or another fallen forward premium by round 8.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Which ruck out of Ryder, Lobbe, Pyke and Jacobs?

 

[Fiasco]

Which ruck out of Ryder, Lobbe, Pyke and Jacobs?

I'm interested in Jacobs if he can get back to the 101 ave. of 2012 he'd be a bargain, I know I paid a lot more for him at the start of last year.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Which ruck out of Ryder, Lobbe, Pyke and Jacobs?

I have the same 3 (gtfo jacobs ) I'm tossing up. Lobbe was in and locked months ago but he's just been so ****ing pathetic all pre season. Ryder worries me because I saw Bellchambers is back in 5-6 and with both of them playing I think you would have to upgrade Ryder later in the year. I only like Pyke because he's a lone ruck and mumfords gone. The concern with him is that he didn't hit those really high peaks like Ryder did even when Mumford wasn't there.

In closing, I have NFI...

 

[joydivision22]

Beames in injured. Does that help

yes, yes it does.. haha

 

[TheOz]

Webster and Griffiths both locked in at D5 and D6.

No Suckling and McDonald for me.

What is it about Griffiths exactly that makes him a viable selection?

 

[kangaroos3]

Re-jigged my team around to try get an extra midfield premium. Not sure whether to keep it though..

Hurn D4, Michie M6, Pyke R1

or

R. Shaw D4, Watson M3, Hickey R1

The first option IMO feels like my team is more balanced..
Thoughts?