Player X vs Y

[domskiezzzzzz]

Neither sorry

Yeah nah that works out well for me anyway

 

[hoddo]

Wright vs Caddy?

Steering clear of both. I reckon they could be this year's versions of Watts and Karnezis.

 

[Heaps of fun]

Tom Mitchell or Luke Parker?

 

[LiverpoolRed]

Tom Mitchell or Luke Parker?

That's a tough one! I dunno if Mitchell will go through the dreaded 'second year blues' or not, but he is probably the more talented player with a higher ceiling. However, Luke Parker is no slouch, he's more seasoned/experienced and probably less of a risk.

Jarred Roughead vs. Nick Dal Santo?

 

[Strahany]

Jarred Roughead vs. Nick Dal Santo?

I think they're much of a muchness, as I don't think either will have a form drop off from last year, however Dal Santo has a greater chance of making a considerable improvement (especially since he's surrounded by two very taggable players in Harvey and Wells, as well as dangerous up and coming mids like Ziebell).

 

[CJApples87]

Steering clear of both. I reckon they could be this year's versions of Watts and Karnezis.

I think Caddy's a bit better than Karnezis. Clearance gun, highly regarded and a decent user of the ball. He gets forward and kicks goals as well. Karnezis could run a bit, not much else.

Wright is hard to read because of his role. If he's unleashed then he'll be one of hte bargains of the season. But I fear with van Berlo out, he may have to tag more often than not.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Buddy v Zorko?

 

[Turly]

Tom Mitchell or Luke Parker?

Mitchell.

Hanley v Hibberd v Enright v Adcock v Hurn

 

[CJApples87]

Enright > Hibberd (if fit) > Hurn > Hanley > Adcock.

 

[Test Tickle]

Mitchell.

Hanley v Hibberd v Enright v Adcock v Hurn

I like Hanley, can go massive when let loose.

 

[Derogue]

Watson, Cotchin, Laidler, Lobbe (can go up to Mumford)
v
Pendlebury, Thomas, Webster, Leuenberger

got Ablett, Libba and Beams in mids in both options

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Buddy v Zorko?

I'd go Buddy even though I don't like both.
Reason being Buddy is as cheap as can be and has a better history of averaging higher.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

If you only had one rookie spot left, would you go Michie or Ellis?
Cash and byes not a factor...

 

[toxic]

If you only had one rookie spot left, would you go Michie or Ellis?
Cash and byes not a factor...

Ellis

 

[kananooks]

Swallow and Laidler, I don't trust Suckling at all.

why so? was scoring 80 90s before he got injured and had shown no signs in preseason thats about to change

 

[Stinger7W]

HELPPPPPPPPP

Brent Harvey or Chad Wingard????!!!!

 

[toxic]

HELPPPPPPPPP

Brent Harvey or Chad Wingard????!!!!

Booooooomer

 

[Mkcaptain]

Watson, Cotchin, Laidler, Lobbe (can go up to Mumford)
v
Pendlebury, Thomas, Webster, Leuenberger

got Ablett, Libba and Beams in mids in both options

I like Watson, Cotchin, Laidler, Lobbe. I'd be wary of Lobbe though given his preseason form.

Rockliff vs Cotchin

 

[Judd_Magic]

I like Watson, Cotchin, Laidler, Lobbe. I'd be wary of Lobbe though given his preseason form.

Rockliff vs Cotchin

Rockcliff it you already have Pendles and Beams otherwise Cotchin.

 

[Judd_Magic]

S.Mitchell, McVeigh, Swallow

or

Hanley, Simpson, Enright



This is for D1-D3

 

[domskiezzzzzz]

S.Mitchell, McVeigh, Swallow

or

Hanley, Simpson, Enright



This is for D1-D3

Haha I'm in the same boat. Have Hibberd in the mix as well, he'll be fit to go come round 1 for the bombers. I currently have the first option as you know what your getting but yeah I need some help as well.

 

[Kozivan]

Mitchell, Mcveigh, Swallow. Fo sure.


Walters or Parker.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Mitchell, Mcveigh, Swallow. Fo sure.


Walters or Parker.

I'd go Parker.

 

[karaoke]

S.Mitchell, McVeigh, Swallow

or

Hanley, Simpson, Enright



This is for D1-D3

 

[Jiska]

d.Swallow/Laidler v Suckling/Webster

both starters.

Sutcliffe or Shaw and Webster

Michie or Aish?