Player X vs Y

[Lachy Jamison]

Which is the better ruck/fwd setup. Appreciate feedback.
A.
View attachment 46769
or

B.
View attachment 46774

Franklin, Pavlich and Cox vs Ryder, T.Mitchell and Wingard
Trust vs Potential in my eyes, although im not a fan of Pav.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Pavlich or Caddy?

Caddy.

Similar output I reckon but Caddy way cheaper.

 

[Kadog]

Watson, Wingard, Roughead

Or

Libba, NRoo and which one of Wingard or Roughead?

 

[GOAUS!]

Clurey or Langdon?

 

[Judd_Magic]

What makes you go for Watson, Wingard, Roughead combo Kadog?

 

[GOAUS!]

Franklin, Pavlich and Cox vs Ryder, T.Mitchell and Wingard
Trust vs Potential in my eyes, although im not a fan of Pav.

Franklin, Pavlich and Cox for me.

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Franklin, Pavlich and Cox for me.

Kadog <--- not my question

 

[Spanish Sahara]

T Mitchell vs L Parker

I have had Parker from the start but I am starting to second guess my choice. Parker named on the bench and Mitchell in the guts. Both will have to really battle to get midfield minutes in the Swans side.

 

[GOAUS!]

T Mitchell vs L Parker

I have had Parker from the start but I am starting to second guess my choice. Parker named on the bench and Mitchell in the guts. Both will have to really battle to get midfield minutes in the Swans side.

Starting position doesn't really matter these days (maybe a bit for the rookies but that's about it).

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Starting position doesn't really matter these days (maybe a bit for the rookies but that's about it).

True. Still seeing Mitchell it a much higher % of teams compared to Parker. Was wondering what that was based on.

I havent played supercoach for about 2-3 years, so a fair bit out of the loops in terms of who are likley to score well

 

[GOAUS!]

True. Still seeing Mitchell it a much higher % of teams compared to Parker. Was wondering what that was based on.

I havent played supercoach for about 2-3 years, so a fair bit out of the loops in terms of who are likley to score well

I've got Parker over Mitchell, just a feeling really.

 

[shaun1800]

Jacobs v Lobey

I like lobey but I'm a little worried he will stay the lone ruckman. Jacobs seems safer.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Jacobs v Lobey

I like lobey but I'm a little worried he will stay the lone ruckman. Jacobs seems safer.

Jacobs for sure now that Renouf has been upgraded to the senior list and in the mix for round 1.

 

[Spanish Sahara]

I've got Parker over Mitchell, just a feeling really.

Yeah I just noticed your team in the other thread. Almost identical.

Same midfield, Impey instead of Rohan, Ryder instead of Luey, Enright and Mcveigh over Hurn and Simpson, Langford over Cameron

 

[paul barnard]

dom tyson v michie

money no issue. just whos gona get it done

 

[Lachy Jamison]

dom tyson v michie

money no issue. just whos gona get it done

Tyson, 3rd year in the system. The didnt trade big for the bloke for no reason.

 

[SnappyHappy]

M.Pyke & B.Harvey OR W.Minson & M.Pavlich/L.Parker/T.Mitchell

Thoughts?

 

[Lachy Jamison]

Pendlebury, Laidler D6, Rohan F7 vs Watson, Webster D5, Rohan F7 vs Pendlebury, Webster, Forward rookie (eg Impey)

 

[Kadog]

What makes you go for Watson, Wingard, Roughead combo Kadog?

Sorry bud I'm confused by your question. I don't have Roughy.

 

[Lachy Jamison]

M.Pyke & B.Harvey OR W.Minson & M.Pavlich/L.Parker/T.Mitchell

Thoughts?

Pyke 80-90 Boomer 100-110 vs Minson 110 Parker/Mitchell 95-105

 

[Judd_Magic]

Sorry bud I'm confused by your question. I don't have Roughy.

LOL!

Was trying to say why you picked that combo in relation to my question over Libba, NRoo Roughead combo.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Pyke 80-90 Boomer 100-110 vs Minson 110 Parker/Mitchell 95-105

I'm thinking the same but with Pyke the sole Ruckman I'm thinking he may average closer to 100.

 

[Grimmjow]

Watson, Wingard, Roughead
Or
Libba, NRoo and which one of Wingard or Roughead?

1st option looks to put up more points.

Nroo has served me well in the past, but I think he'll decline from now. Risky picking starting high priced veteran premiums (incl Boomer). Pavlich is viewed differently due to his starting price.


Hodge Deledio vs Birchall Cotchin ?

I've wanted Hodge Cotchin, but I'm annoyingly $500 short..

 

[SnappyHappy]

1st option looks to put up more points.

Nroo has served me well in the past, but I think he'll decline from now. Risky picking starting high priced veteran premiums (incl Boomer). Pavlich is viewed differently due to his starting price.


Hodge Deledio vs Birchall Cotchin ?

I've wanted Hodge Cotchin, but I'm annoyingly $500 short..

Tough one, Hodge ageing and unreliable injury-wise and Birchall has never reach any great heights SC wise...,I'd probably go Birchall & Cotchin, the addition of a fit Suckling may free Birchall up a bit more from taggers.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Okay, Minson & J.Macrae OR Pyke & M.Murphy