NormaJeanHawk
Team Captain
- Aug 28, 2011
- 342
- 304
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Player X vs Y
- Thread starter Super Hans
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Kadog
Brownlow Kentallist
- Feb 16, 2013
- 18,233
- 44,366
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool Detroit Lions
Ahh gotcha.
Watson > Libba. I feel Watson will get back to that 115-120 avg.
Roughy > NRoo. Roughy is the feature @ the Hawks now and will score consistently.
Wingard is a jet who I feel will breakout this year.
There are probably no right or wrong answers here, it all really comes down to personal choice and gut feel above all else.
On Monday we'll all be experts
Ahh gotcha.
Watson > Libba. I feel Watson will get back to that 115-120 avg.
Roughy > NRoo. Roughy is the feature @ the Hawks now and will score consistently.
Wingard is a jet who I feel will breakout this year.
There are probably no right or wrong answers here, it all really comes down to personal choice and gut feel above all else.
On Monday we'll all be experts
Hah!
Yeah everyone's an expert around here till Monday I guess when we will either have eggs on our faces or end up looking like geniuses.
Tend to agree with your choices, just needed someone to see if they agreed with me.
The forward line is definitely the hardest part of my team that I have had to put together.
Kadog
Brownlow Kentallist
- Feb 16, 2013
- 18,233
- 44,366
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool Detroit Lions
I think I'm set now.Hah!
Yeah everyone's an expert around here till Monday I guess when we will either have eggs on our faces or end up looking like geniuses.
Tend to agree with your choices, just needed someone to see if they agreed with me.
The forward line is definitely the hardest part of my team that I have had to put together.
Dangerfield, Harvey, DMartin, Wingard, Pavlich, Higgins (JKH, impey?)
I don't want to concern myself with fwd rookies headaches.
I'm dealing with this dilemma at the moment also, plus add in D.Thomas, Savage and a few others.
Personally I'm liking Macrae. Mature player for his age, could have a break out year.
Tom Mitchell or Luke Parker ???
Luke Parker is around the right age/games played for a breakout season. 55 games now and finished last year strongly with a good finals series.
Mitchell a bit riskier having only played a dozen games, but has the makings of a great player. I'm leaning towards Parker.
Thanks for the insight and yeah it's a tough one as I want one of them.. but I'll bet the one I don't choose will be better lol fml
Kadog
Brownlow Kentallist
- Feb 16, 2013
- 18,233
- 44,366
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool Detroit Lions
I'll play devils advocate and say tmitchell
Tmitchell, solid player who knows how to get the pill. Named on the ball in Sydney's game v GWS.
Last edited:
Kadog
Brownlow Kentallist
- Feb 16, 2013
- 18,233
- 44,366
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool Detroit Lions
Currently have Pavlich but I'm looking to switch Pav > Buddy.
Couple of options...KSimpson > Hurn or Griffiths > Laidler
Question is: better to roll with Hurn/Griffiths combo or KSimpson/Laidler to get this deal done?
Couple of options...KSimpson > Hurn or Griffiths > Laidler
Question is: better to roll with Hurn/Griffiths combo or KSimpson/Laidler to get this deal done?
Last edited:
I'll play devils advocate and say tmitchell
Tmitchell, solid player who knows how to get the pill. Named on the ball in Sydney's game v GWS.
I've gone Mitchell
How bout Matthew wright or Josh Caddy ???
Kadog
Brownlow Kentallist
- Feb 16, 2013
- 18,233
- 44,366
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool Detroit Lions
Caddy
Hmmm just suddenly felt the need to tinker with my forward line structure,
How would you rate in order?
N.Riewoldt, D.Martin, J.Roughead, T.Mitchell?
Really got an uneasy feeling about Martin (have been burnt by him pulling random s*** scores at shocking times in the past and the burn is still there!)
I have a feeling that Mitchell is capable of just as big a number as Martin and will pull me back 90k approximately to play with.
Riewoldt does have a question mark about what numbers he can put up given his side potential struggles, however he isn't a stay at home forward, he gets involved and comes right up the ground, don't think he will hit the scoreboard as much but his disposal numbers in turn will more than likely improve.
Roughead has always been a pretty good option, he should be very consistent and that's what I like.
How would you rate in order?
N.Riewoldt, D.Martin, J.Roughead, T.Mitchell?
Really got an uneasy feeling about Martin (have been burnt by him pulling random s*** scores at shocking times in the past and the burn is still there!)
I have a feeling that Mitchell is capable of just as big a number as Martin and will pull me back 90k approximately to play with.
Riewoldt does have a question mark about what numbers he can put up given his side potential struggles, however he isn't a stay at home forward, he gets involved and comes right up the ground, don't think he will hit the scoreboard as much but his disposal numbers in turn will more than likely improve.
Roughead has always been a pretty good option, he should be very consistent and that's what I like.
Caddy comfortably for me i think!
Hmmm tough one leaning just towards Simpson & Pav for consistency. Only a matter of a couple of points in that one though IMO.
Gunston
I'm leaning towards Mitchell, think his ball winning ability just shades Parker's, have a feeling he will really blossom after a decent taste last year!
Kadog
Brownlow Kentallist
- Feb 16, 2013
- 18,233
- 44,366
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool Detroit Lions
Hard one to put in order but I can say..
Martin>tmitchell & Roughead>NRoo just.
Sorry, should of been a bit clearer, I have 3 spots available, what would you go with out of these guys? Or would you take someone outside this group?
Kadog
Brownlow Kentallist
- Feb 16, 2013
- 18,233
- 44,366
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool Detroit Lions
Martin, Roughy & Nroo as a nice POD in that group. Outside of that I like Harvey, Wingard, Rioli
Kadog
Brownlow Kentallist
- Feb 16, 2013
- 18,233
- 44,366
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Liverpool Detroit Lions
Currently have Pavlich but I'm looking to switch Pav > Buddy.
Couple of options...KSimpson > Hurn or Griffiths > Laidler
Question is: better to roll with Hurn/Griffiths combo or KSimpson/Laidler to get this deal done?
Couple of options...KSimpson > Hurn or Griffiths > Laidler
Question is: better to roll with Hurn/Griffiths combo or KSimpson/Laidler to get this deal done?
Personally would be pushing for Simpson/Griffiths if I could, but if you need to stick to this then Hurn/Griffiths gets the nod in my books.
I personally think that Pav will be close to Buddys scores (at least to start with) so not sure if this trade will be necessary.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
