Post Your Team Here

[JTRx]

Thanks Quicky. I'll get started tinkering.

 

[cormick]

Backs Goddard, Gilbee, Chad, Birchall, Malceski, Raines, S.Hill
(Emg: Broughton, Suban)

Mids Bartel, S.Burgoyne, Nicky Dal, Young, Skipworth, Rich
(Emg: M.Robinson, Ziebell)

Rucks Cox, Ottens
(Emg: Meesen, A.Graham)

Fwds Pav, Buddy, Richo, Stevie J, Alwyn Davey, Higgins, Yarran
(Emg: J.Grant, Gumbleton)

Ne thoughts/opinions on this team?
Cheers

Pretty good, but don't expect Meesen or Gus to play many games; maybe get someone else in ruck; McEvoy?

 

[Quicky]

Backs: S Fisher, L Gilbee, C Cornes, J Adcock, N Malceski, D Myers, S Hill
(EMG: A Rance, N Suban)

Centers: C Judd, S Pendlebury, J Selwood, R Griffen, P Hasleby, D Rich
(EMG: D Beams, M Robinson)

Rucks: D Cox, H McIntosh
(EMG: J White, D Currie)

Forwards: M Pavlich, B Deledio, J Brown, T Cloke, S Lucas, S Higgins, C Yarren/ J Ziebell
(EMG: S Gumbleton, M Brown)

I've got $37,500 in the bank after my latest adjustments. I need some advice on Myers and Cloke, should I get either of them or are they a no go?

I'd stay away from Cloke if I were you. His form is very hit and miss and he plays better with another big forward in the team. This might not happen as: Rocca is injured and no-one knows how bad except that he's still not in full training, Rusling injury risk/ not really good enough yet to take the pressure off Cloke, Dawes still needs alot of development, Reid looks set to play back this season (although a good SC pick up at 130k ). I'd try to upgrade to S Johnson or B Johnson with the money you have but you'd need to tinker around with your team again to make up the difference.

Essendon supporters seem to have good things to say about Myers except he may not play 22 games. Not sure that matters if he plays the games at the start of the year and you get to upgrade. Probably worth having some good emergency cover which you seem to

 

[RevDog]

I just had second thoughts on both of them, lol. I was thinking R Houlihan from Carlton in the backline, would give me a lot of money for a replacement for Cloke.

 

[gum3]

Hello Everyone just joined up here, some good teams floating around for this early in the season......This is a crack at my first team, some feedback would be appreciated cheers

B: Gilbbe, Malceski Cornes, burchill, Adcock, Ryder, J smith - emerg. Hurley suban

Mids : Burgoyne, S.Thompson, Delidio, Griffin, Higgins, Rich emerg - sidebottom, Davenport

R: Hille, Griffin emerg - Vickory, Bailey

F: Pavlich, Franklin, Lucas, Edwards, Didak, Skipworth Reid, emerg - Gumbleton, T.Walker

Im pretty happy with it, alot of mid range players so banking on them im not a huge fan of goin blue chip early in the season, also not a massive fan of rucks, only seems like 3 in the comp that score high and cox's price will come down by round 10...... thoughts

 

[JLoh]

Hi all,

This is my first time playing SuperCoach and here's my first effort for a team:

Backs: Goddard - Newman - Cornes - McPhee - Wojcinski - Petterd - Hill
(Suban - Rance)

Mids: Bartel - Judd - Black - Griffin - Morton C - Rich
(Swift - Dangerfield)

Rucks: Hille - Ottens
(Currie - Spencer)

Forwards: Harvey - Franklin - Richardson - Porplyzia - Davey Aa - Higgins - Ziebell
(Gumbleton, Schoenmakers)

Any thoughts appreciated.

Hmm..a fair team, few questions marks over the backline with mcphee and wojincski and petterd. Mcphee not impressive in his swingman role so far and probably have to wait and see about petterd who is highlighted for big things by bailey.
Also would probably trade out Black and have him as an option later down the track. (alternatives: pendlebury or teammate luke power both who are cheaper options)
hope this helps a bit

 

[Hurleys Hawkers]

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Cornes Lockyer Mackie Malceski Goddard Raines Pettard (Hill Broadbent)

Judd Reilly Selwood Sewell Kerr Rich (Dangerfield Beams)

Cox McIntosh (Currie Trengrove)

Delidio Richardson Didak Johnson LeCras Higgins Hentchel (Gumbleton Ballantyne)

 

[Baxter23]

Backline, mids and rucks are solid.

Fwds not to bad but having Didak, Johnson (assuming its SJ) LeCras and Hentschel in the one fwd line is a bit risky. They all have the ability to be inconsistent.

 

[robertg22]

Goddard, H Shaw, C Cornes, Myers, Malceski, Urquhart, Raines (S Hill / R Sloane)
Judd, Swan, Kirk, Kerr, Foley, Rich (C Ward / M Robinson)
Cox, McIntosh (Graham / Currie)
Franklin, Deledio, Didak, Lucas, Higgins, Skipworth, Ziebell (Grant / Gumbleton)

 

[torq]

Backs:
- I don't like Enright because he is comming off a stunning year and I can't see improvement. I'd look at downgrading 60K to the Chad.

- Merritt is one of the best spoilers in the competition, that doesn't score in supercoach. Better is Raines, Houlihan or at 70k less Petterd looks promising.

Midfield:
Is ok

Rucks:
You know every team will have cox by then end of season so might as well pick him up now and save the trade.

Forwards:
Good but Ebert?? There's better choices around that price. I'd probably spend a touch more and go Lucas.

Thanks for the feedback Dan. Not a fan of the Chad, but I might flick Enright and Merrett. Pettard looks a good buy too.

 

[Baxter23]

Like your team also robertg22.

If anything maybe a better player sitting on the pine in the mids.

Like the rest of your team

 

[robertg22]

Like your team also robertg22.

If anything maybe a better player sitting on the pine in the mids.

Like the rest of your team

Thanks. I have spent the bit extra on Callan Ward because I think he'll be good this year. Could go with either him or Rich on the bench at any given time but will wait and see there. From what I read Mitch Robinson has had a significant impact so far in the intra club games. Wouldn't mind maybe Dayne Beams but having not seen him play even in the NAB cup yet I'm not sold he'll be in our 22..

 

[nofeet]

Here is my current supercoach team for 2009.
Give me some advise on how I can make my team better.
Made some changes to my team
Black prices are new players
Got $6,400 left
BACK
1. GODDARD, Brendon $555,100
2. NEWMAN, Chris $539,100
3. PRATT, Daniel $531,600
4. GILBEE, Lindsay $526,100
5. MALCESKI, Nick $355,900
6. HILL, Stephen $164,200
7. MCKERNAN, Shaun $94,200
MIDFIELD
8. POWER, Luke $567,700
9. CROSS, Daniel $564,100
10. BURGOYNE, Shaun $555,600
11. MASTEN, Chris $306,900
12. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=252HASLEBY, Paul $358,400
13. RICH, Daniel $144,200
RUCK
14. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=697PETRIE, Drew $515,100
15. FRASER, Josh $433,400
FORWARD
16. HARVEY, Brent $605,400
17. O'KEEFE, Ryan $560,400
18. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=542BROWN, Jonathan $539,100
19. DIDAK, Alan $489,900
20. JOHNSON, Steve $471,800
21. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=458HIGGINS, Shaun $223,400
22. YARRAN, Chris $149,200
INTERCHANGE
23. RANCE, Alex $94,200
24. SUBAN, Nick $94,200
25. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=475ROBINSON, Mitch $94,200
26. BEAMS, Dayne $94,200
27. CURRIE, Daniel $94,200
28. SPENCER, Jake $83,400
29. GUMBLETON, Scott $94,200
30. WALKER, Taylor $94,200​

 

[BangersAndMash]

Ok, 2nd revised edition... 1st time SuperCoaching.

B: S.Fisher, L.Gilbee, C.Cornes, S.Hill
G. Birchall, S.Gilbert, A.Raines
(J.Trengrove, A.Rance)
M: C.Judd, L.Power, D.Rich
D.Cross, J.Selwood, P.Hasleby
(H.Hartlett, T.Swift)
R: D.Cox, M.Kreuzer (D.Currie, J.Meesan)
F: B.Harvey, L.Franklin, B.Delidio, S.Gumbleton
J.Brown, J.Zeibell, S.Sidebottom
(M.Thorp, R.Nahas)

Still have $119,800 left over. Pretty happy although I may have too many kids? Thoughts?

Cheers

 

[hendo8888]

Here is my current supercoach team for 2009.
Give me some advise on how I can make my team better.
Made some changes to my team
Black prices are new players
Got $6,400 left
BACK
1. GODDARD, Brendon $555,100
2. NEWMAN, Chris $539,100
3. PRATT, Daniel $531,600
4. GILBEE, Lindsay $526,100
5. MALCESKI, Nick $355,900
6. HILL, Stephen $164,200
7. MCKERNAN, Shaun $94,200
MIDFIELD
8. POWER, Luke $567,700
9. CROSS, Daniel $564,100
10. BURGOYNE, Shaun $555,600
11. MASTEN, Chris $306,900
12. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=252HASLEBY, Paul $358,400
13. RICH, Daniel $144,200
RUCK
14. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=697PETRIE, Drew $515,100
15. FRASER, Josh $433,400
FORWARD
16. HARVEY, Brent $605,400
17. O'KEEFE, Ryan $560,400
18. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=542BROWN, Jonathan $539,100
19. DIDAK, Alan $489,900
20. JOHNSON, Steve $471,800
21. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=458HIGGINS, Shaun $223,400
22. YARRAN, Chris $149,200
INTERCHANGE
23. RANCE, Alex $94,200
24. SUBAN, Nick $94,200
25. http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=475ROBINSON, Mitch $94,200
26. BEAMS, Dayne $94,200
27. CURRIE, Daniel $94,200
28. SPENCER, Jake $83,400
29. GUMBLETON, Scott $94,200
30. WALKER, Taylor $94,200​

Not sure that I'd want 4 Back rookies this year
Smack won't play much and wouldn't expect any until mid-season
Not sure about Power in there, reckon there's much better options
It's not too bad, but I reckon it could be improved a fair bit

You need Cox imo

 

[whitmore1]

Hey just thought I'd post my team in here and try and get some tips to help me out. I've got $9,400 left over, and am not too sure about any of it at the moment. If you could let me know what you think, thatd be great.

Backs: M. Mattner, C. Cornes, J. Adcock, J. Smith, R. Houlihan, S.Hill, M. Maguire (N. Suban, A. Rance)

Midfield: G. Ablett Jr (C), C. Judd (VC), L. Hayes, B. Dalziell, R. Griffen, D. Rich (H. Hartlett, M. Robinson)

Rucks: D. Cox, H. McIntosh (J. Meesen, L.Keefe)

Forwards: M. Pavlich, B. Deledio, J. Brown, J. Porplizia, M. Williams(?), S. Higgins, J. Ziebell

 

[Baxter23]

Always better to have that safe back up.

 

[BIGANT]

Try 5th time revised - Need advice, first time SC.....

Backs; Newman, Gilbee, Houli, Raines; - Suban/Slattery
Ellis, Malceski, J. Smith

Defence & Mids, whilst happy with & chock full of dollars...If i could down grade to up grade my forward line to make it complete i will...

Midfielders; Ablett, J. McVeigh, S.Hill
J. Selwood, Gibbs, Cousins - Sidebottom/Dangerfeild

Rucks; B. Ottens, Mitch Clark - Meesen/Currie

I can live w my rucks....no concerns, unless suggested differently.

Forwards; Deledio, M. Richardson, S. Johnson, C Yarran
C. Rioli, Lucas, Higgins - Ziebell/Gumbleton

Forward line feels like it's 1/2 full 1/2 empty....worries w Yarran, Ziebell, Gumbleton. Throw Taylor Walker amongst those mentions too...suggestions on whole forward squad.

Look forward to hearing from you all...

 

[captain foley]

Backs: J.Gram, M.Firrito, A.Mcphee, A.Raines, D.Wojcinski, J.Rivers, L.Hansen(R. O'Keefe, A. Rance)

Midfield: M.Murphy, J.Selwood, D.Kerr, B.Cousins, R.Griffin,T.Cotchin (D. Rich, J.Davenport)

Rucks: A.Sandilands, B.Ottens (A.Cordy, J.Trengrove)

Forwards: M. Richardson, B. Deledio, M.Hahn, S. Milne, S.Dew, S. Lucas, S. Edwards (S.Sidebottom S.Gumbleton)

Any suggestions on how i could improve this team ? oh and who should i put as captain ?

 

[gtrain29]

DEFENDERS
L.Gilbee,H.Shaw,C.Cornes,J.Adcock,J.Smith,A.Raines,R.Petterd(S.Hill,N.Suban)

MIDS
C.Judd,J.Bartel,D.Kerr,P.Haselby,T.Lockyer,P.Dangerfield(D.Rich,H.Hartlett)

RUCKS
D.Cox,H.McIntosh(D.Currie,J.Sellers)

FWDS
M.Pavlich,A.Didak,P.Chapman,T.Cloke,S.Lucas,S.Higgens,C.Yarren(J.Ziebell,S.Gumbleton)

will change between now and start of season but not to bad for a first side,going with a bit of youth to raise a bit of cash for the second half of the year.let me know what u think.

 

[sebsport3]

Hey all,
Just wanted some feedback on my team if you dont mind?

B: Enright - Cornes - Adcock - Malceski - Houlihan - Raines - Petterd
(Em: Hill & Rance)
M: Judd - Corey - Black - Cross - Masten - Rich
(Em: Davenport & Beams)
R: Cox - Hille
(Em: Vickery & Trengove)
F: Pavlich - Deledio - Brennan - S. Johnson - Higgins - Yarran - Ziebell
(Em: Gumbleton & Walker)

Just under $100K left in the bank too.

I wasnt sure about the top line midfielders i have, was tossing up between Black, Cross, Thompson, Selwood, Burgoyne. Judd and Black are cemented in atm.

Any suggestions/advice would be greatly appreciated. Thanks

 

[DanA]

Try 5th time revised - Need advice, first time SC.....

Backs; Newman, Gilbee, Houli, Raines; - Suban/Slattery
Ellis, Malceski, J. Smith
Defence & Mids, whilst happy with & chock full of dollars...If i could down grade to up grade my forward line to make it complete i will...

You could downgrade JWS to Petterd and reduce risk without comprimising score to much. I would also consider finding a spot for Hill in the backline rather than midfield.

Midfielders; Ablett, J. McVeigh, S.Hill
J. Selwood, Gibbs, Cousins - Sidebottom/Dangerfeild

I think McVeigh is too injury prone for a premium player.
Rucks; B. Ottens, Mitch Clark - Meesen/Currie

I can live w my rucks....no concerns, unless suggested differently.
I think you will have problems fielding a side in the ruck division and will be forced to take more than one 0.
Forwards; Deledio, M. Richardson, S. Johnson, C Yarran
C. Rioli, Lucas, Higgins - Ziebell/Gumbleton

Forward line feels like it's 1/2 full 1/2 empty....worries w Yarran, Ziebell, Gumbleton. Throw Taylor Walker amongst those mentions too...suggestions on whole forward squad.
I like your forwards but would change Gumbleton to sidebottom and find a new midfield premium (there's always plenty)
Look forward to hearing from you all...

 

[JETTA#07]

backs-L. Hodge, M.Mattner, C.Cornes, N.Malceski, J. Smith, J.Drumond, J.Adcock, A .Kite, T.Zomer

Mids- C.Judd, M.McVeigh, D.kerr, A.Lovett, D.Rich, P.Dangerfield, T.Swift, M.Robinson

Rucks, Hille, Mcintosh, currie, j.tippet

forwards- okeefe, harvey, buddy, alwyn davey, deledio higgins, ziebell , gumby ,ballantyne

thoughts please

 

[Blueboys7]

backs-L. Hodge, M.Mattner, C.Cornes, N.Malceski, J. Smith, J.Drumond, J.Adcock, A .Kite, T.Zomer

Mids- C.Judd, M.McVeigh, D.kerr, A.Lovett, D.Rich, P.Dangerfield, T.Swift, M.Robinson

Rucks, Hille, Mcintosh, currie, j.tippet

forwards- okeefe, harvey, buddy, alwyn davey, deledio higgins, ziebell , gumby ,ballantyne

thoughts please

I think you have stacked your back line mayb downgrade drummond/adcock to someone like petterd (will give you 280k/200k respectively) and upgrade lovett or dangerfield as your midfield is a tad weak with dangerfield and rich not assured of game time.

 

[Blueboys7]

Here is my team:

B: B.Goddard - L.Gilbee - C.Cornes
J.Adock - X.Ellis - N.Malceski - S.Hill

(N.Suban, A.Rance)

M: C.Judd - J.Selwood - B.Gibbs
D.Kerr - N.Foley - D.Rich

(M.Robinson, T.Swift)

R: D.Cox - H.MacIntosh

(J.Seller, D.Currie)

F: M.Pavlich - B.Deledio - P.Chapman
S.Lucas - S.Higgins - H.Skipworth
C.Yarran

(J.Ziebell, S.Gumbleton)

Emergencies are not set in stone, waiting on appearances in the NAB cup. I have 53k left. I feel my fwd line is a little week but hoping to upgrade Lucas and Skipworth.

My main questions are over my midfield. Judd is a no brainer, Selwood i think will excel again and not get much of a tag and Gibbs should explode this year after bulking up and wont recieve a tag. Im not sure about Kerr and Foley any advice on this would be greatly appreciated.