Rate a Scum: Alan Didak.

[davey_magik]

Alright, he is a damn good player when on song.
However he dives, acts, is dirty (i.e Kicking David Johnson in the guts when Johnson went to tackle him) and thinks he is awesome.
Highlight of the QB this yaer aside from Yze kicking 4 in a quarter was Whelan playing all over him.

 

[deck]

Highlight of the QB this yaer aside from Yze kicking 4 in a quarter was Whelan playing all over him.

He kicked 3 goals for the game. I'll take whelan playing all over him like that every time we play you.

 

[Johnson#26]

Only Collingwood fans rate him.

At the moment, Didak>Lovett. Time will tell. He is certainly more than handy. Needs to add consistancy.

 

[rick James]

He kicked 3 goals for the game. I'll take whelan playing all over him like that every time we play you.

when didak was playing as your key forward I'll take it every week too.

face it, we friggin' owned you punks.

 

[:::buddy38:::]

Wells = Meant to be at Carlton

And i bet hes happy he isnt

 

[deck]

when didak was playing as your key forward I'll take it every week too.

face it, we friggin' owned you punks.

He was playing as a FP/HFF and if your happy with a opposition small forward kicking 3 goals every game i'm sure every team will take that.

 

[Lensen]

He's the clearly greatest player in the comp. And I'm the biggest Luke Hodge fan in the world - which means that Hawk fans, or actually anyone, that thinks he's a soft dud thinks even less of Hodge. Which is ridiculous given that Hodge is a superstar. A mega superstar in any non-Didak era. So you're all blatantly wrong.

Didak > anyone.

 

[Jeremias]

didak is another draft mistake by the pies...will they ever learn? he has some talent, mainly as a forward pocket. cannot play midfield, yet the pies still seem to think he can.

 

[Lensen]

didak is another draft mistake by the pies...will they ever learn? he has some talent, mainly as a forward pocket. cannot play midfield, yet the pies still seem to think he can.

Didak > Andrew Walker

 

[Jeremias]

Didak > Andrew Walker

BORING.....i think that one has been used a couple of times....but then again im glad collingwood supporters can think of only one such player....

 

[DynamoUltra]

One of the biggest thugs in the game. Should've got a combined total of 9 weeks suspension during the year. Thinks he is big when he is not. Outside player of the highest order who sooks and whinges all day long. Hate him. As scum, I rate him highly, as a player, I don't rate him at all.

 

[Lensen]

BORING.....i think that one has been used a couple of times....but then again im glad collingwood supporters can think of only one such player....

Your other high draft picks being?

 

[Lensen]

Given that Luke Hodge is rated slightly below, if not equal to the same person taht went two spots below him in the 2001 draft, that perosn being Chris judd. I think it's reasonable that given I've seen no good reason why Hodge > Didak, then it's reasonable at the very least to consider Mr Didak on the same level in terms of ability and application as Mr Judd.

Didak > Hodge > Judd, IMO.

Regards
Lenny.

 

[AVA-182]

does anyone know if that was after goal number FOUR or FIVE for the night? i cant work it out

 

[Lensen]

does anyone know if that was after goal number FOUR or FIVE for the night? i cant work it out

More than Hodge kicked, I'll bet.

 

[DynamoUltra]

Cherry picker.

 

[deck]

does anyone know if that was after goal number FOUR or FIVE for the night? i cant work it out

I think it might have been goal number 3 but then again it might have been number 5

 

[DynamoUltra]

=

 

[AVA-182]

Hmm.

nice work moron.

 

[cogs24]

nice work moron.

Go to the Music Board, i asked you a question

 

[DynamoUltra]

nice work moron.

Is it not fixed? Der...

 

[JLC]

Once again another classic big footy thread.

I'd rather Didak be a thug than a coward......seem to recall a certain ******** charging one of our players on Anzac Day. Trying to show his toughness wont mention any names though.

Given a relatively good run with injuries i expect Didak to establish himself as a more than handy midfielder/half forward. Especially when our full compliment of tall forwards are up and running.

I grant that on occassions he does play for free kicks but i doubt he gets a better run with the umpires than say Lloyd or Gary Ablett Junior. GAJ seems to get a dream run with the umpires.

IMO the king sniper of the game is Camporeale (he is the king of the cheap shots).

jlc

 

[AVA-182]

Go to the Music Board, i asked you a question

done.

 

[DynamoUltra]

I'd rather Didak be a thug than a coward......

Ok, here goes. Didak is a cowardly thug. He hits people when they're not looking, elbows people who are virtually sitting behind him etc. A ********er of the highest order.

References;
Didak elbows Chick sitting behind him after being tackled.
Didak elbows Port Player when Port player was not looking.
Didak elbows Osborne when Didak was lying on top of Osborne after being tackled.
Didak elbows a Sydney player who was running from behind Didak.

The above is from 2006. Didak is a disgrace.

 

[AVA-182]

Ok, here goes. Didak is a cowardly thug. He hits people when they're not looking, elbows people who are virtually sitting behind him etc. A ********er of the highest order.

References;
Didak elbows Chick sitting behind him after being tackled.
Didak elbows Port Player when Port player was not looking.
Didak elbows Osborne when Didak was lying on top of Osborne after being tackled.
Didak elbows a Sydney player who was running from behind Didak.

The above is from 2006. Didak is a disgrace.

go sit in the bitter corner with all the geelong tools.