Rate my Super Coach Team III

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Backs are good but pretty much what everyone else has.

Mids are interesting with Wells. personally I think he's crap but he's a unique pick.

Not going to bother with a ruck division? You're not a former StKilda coach are you???

Fwds are pretty handy too. But I did hear somewhere Gray is injured??

As for Ablett. I'm betting he will drop (Though not by much) but I still have in my team. Bottom line, he is the best scorer in the comp and most teams will have him as captain. If you don't start with him, you're giving up at least 50 pts a game to your opponent. Besides, you'll trade him in eventually so why waste a trade?

Haha thanks, i forgot my ruck division whoops :p

Jolly,Hille, Warnock, Skipper :p
And i think Wells will do well this year giving our midfield and he will rack up, and yeah i agree with you on ablett.
Thanks for looking at mine (Y)
 
hey guys what u rekon of my team

goddard drummond goodwin bock enright newman duffield

ablett montagna selwood bartel pendlebury dal santo

cox sandliands

chapman goodes riewoldt okeefe didak pav

bench
silvagne webbery
barlow trengorve
prato lobbe
rockliffe hitchock

any suggestions wld b great
 
hey guys what u rekon of my team

goddard drummond goodwin bock enright newman duffield

ablett montagna selwood bartel pendlebury dal santo

cox sandliands

chapman goodes riewoldt okeefe didak pav

bench
silvagne webbery
barlow trengorve
prato lobbe
rockliffe hitchock

any suggestions wld b great

Are you serious. Dont wast our time. Pretty funny though. haha :)
 

Log in to remove this ad.

It mite have been both seasons cause Corrazzo averaged i think 103ish in 07 ah had him as captain for a few games. But he is a risk, with his hot and cold form.

Gram is olso on my radar, has been in and out of my team and surprisingly had a form slump last season compared 2 his previous 2 or 3 seasons were he was around the 90 point mark. He is under priced for what he is able of producing.

I belive its round 3 the prices change, you may have mixed it up with the round 4 when the SC season starts. Must be an SC noob. Haha just taking the piss :D

Harry O'Brien is a spud. Quick and thats it.

yeah this is my first year of supercoach, and i'm handing out advice like lollipops..! I'm secretly sabotaging everybody to increase my overall ranking by as many people as i can influence. Genius!

With Fisher out for the first 4-6 rounds, i'd expect Gram and Gilbert to step up.

Did i say round 4, clearly a typo..! or maybe i don't know as much as i think..! :)

Oh ye of little faith.

I suppose you would have said that Nick Maxwell was a spud in 08..? averaged around the 75 mark, before averaging 92 last season.

O'Brien's average will increase, especially if Heath Shaw is rotated through the midfield as O'Brien will take over his role while he is in the middle.

Really wish they would release the SC stats for the entire NAB series..
I'm getting restless..!
 
hey guys what u rekon of my team

goddard drummond goodwin bock enright newman duffield

ablett montagna selwood bartel pendlebury dal santo

cox sandliands

chapman goodes riewoldt okeefe didak pav

bench
silvagne webbery
barlow trengorve
prato lobbe
rockliffe hitchock

any suggestions wld b great

LOL u get a loan from NAB
 
hey guys what u rekon of my team

goddard drummond goodwin bock enright newman duffield

ablett montagna selwood bartel pendlebury dal santo

cox sandliands

chapman goodes riewoldt okeefe didak pav

bench
silvagne webbery
barlow trengorve
prato lobbe
rockliffe hitchock

any suggestions wld b great

don't think silvagni will be elevated at this stage so you should swap him for someone else on your bench

other than that, the best side i've seen on here so far - will done :D
 
hey guys what u rekon of my team

goddard drummond goodwin bock enright newman duffield

ablett montagna selwood bartel pendlebury dal santo

cox sandliands

chapman goodes riewoldt okeefe didak pav

bench
silvagne webbery
barlow trengorve
prato lobbe
rockliffe hitchock

any suggestions wld b great

Have you been taking advice from John Elliot regarding player payments..???? :D
 
hey guys what u rekon of my team

goddard drummond goodwin bock enright newman duffield

ablett montagna selwood bartel pendlebury dal santo

cox sandliands

chapman goodes riewoldt okeefe didak pav

bench
silvagne webbery
barlow trengorve
prato lobbe
rockliffe hitchock

any suggestions wld b great

Your also missing a forward..???? not that you'd need him, you could probably still win it with 21 players.. ;)
 
yeah this is my first year of supercoach, and i'm handing out advice like lollipops..! I'm secretly sabotaging everybody to increase my overall ranking by as many people as i can influence. Genius!

With Fisher out for the first 4-6 rounds, i'd expect Gram and Gilbert to step up.

Did i say round 4, clearly a typo..! or maybe i don't know as much as i think..! :)

Oh ye of little faith.

I suppose you would have said that Nick Maxwell was a spud in 08..? averaged around the 75 mark, before averaging 92 last season.

O'Brien's average will increase, especially if Heath Shaw is rotated through the midfield as O'Brien will take over his role while he is in the middle.

Really wish they would release the SC stats for the entire NAB series..
I'm getting restless..!

Lol you are sabotaging everyones teams.

Yeah stats would be nice, but it cost a bit to do tha stats there are about 6 people in a room that count the stats, NAB Challenge games can be misleading aswell, because there are kids against the 'big boys'. So although they are helpful they can be very misleading. If you want stats you can go on fanfooty.com.au they have some of the NAB stats.

Have you read my 'Are club captains worth a good look?' thread? Maxwell is mentioned in there 'Becoming club captain has transformed this guy in to a SC point scoring machine'.

Harry O, I am harsh on because he broke Newmans leg, and that is the only reason i dislike him :p
 
Backs:Goddard,Enright,Shaw,Hodge, Malceski, Hunt, Greenwood. (Maguire,Davis)
Midfield: Ablett,Pendles,Mitchell,Wells,Martin,Barlow.(Batinac,Shuey)
Forward: Roo,Jonno Brown, Harvey, Gray, Hall, Ziebell, Rohan (Podis,rockcliff)

Help please.
I dont know about ablett, will he drop?

A few others aswell..

Thoughts? :) Thanks!

Backs are fairly strong maybe upgrade one of Malceski, Hunt or Greenwood to a proven scorer.

Mids look ok with the exeption of wells surely theres better options there!!! (Cotchin, Burgoyne, Masten etc) U MUST HAE ABLETT ur a fool not to, consistantly gets u big scores week by week.

Rucks- you obviously dont need them :p
FWD- Like the fwds the only one to question is Robbie Gray, myself not seeing him play that much cant comment but will he be a big enough scorer for his price tag?


MY TEAM!

Backs: Goodwin Enright Shaw Hodge Gram Shoenmakers Farmer
(Maguire Nason)

Mids: Ablett Mitchell Gibbs Watson Martin Barlow
(Jetta Banner)

Rucks: Tippett Natainui
( Skipper Mcauley)

Forwards: Reiwoldt Pav Harvey Franklin hall Dangerfield Rocklif
(Hitchcock Roberts)

Rate it!


http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=360

http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=522



http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=539



http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=533

http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=234



http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=465

http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=42





http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=72
http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=researchmini&pid=666



http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=6



http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=87



http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/?p=player_select&sell=true&sellid=547
 
MY TEAM!

Backs: Goodwin Enright Shaw Hodge Gram Shoenmakers Farmer
(Maguire Nason)

Mids: Ablett Mitchell Gibbs Watson Martin Barlow
(Jetta Banner)

Rucks: Tippett Natainui
( Skipper Mcauley)

Forwards: Reiwoldt Pav Harvey Franklin hall Dangerfield Rocklif
(Hitchcock Roberts)

Rate it!

Farmer going to play???? I think you have loaded up too much in the backs at the expense of your rucks. There's a number of really good 4250k options out there. take at least one of them. I have 3.

Will Gibbs Squib??? I think so. Watson could be a winner. COULD be.

As has been said, a bit under done here.

Fwds pretty good. Roberts?? Who is he???
 
Super Coach enthusiasts, care to wave your wand over my team

Backs: Goodwin, Enright, Shaw, Hodge, Kennelly, Everitt, Ladson
Emg: Maguire, Silvagni

Mids: Murphy, Bartel, Harvey, Ball, Trengove, Martin
Emg: Barlow, Moles

Ruck: Tippett, Hille
Emg: Charman, Roughead

Fwds: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Hall, Zieball, Rockliff
Emg: Hitchcock, Gumbleton

Have $140k left.

Thoughts? Is there any major oversights, any first year gems I can get in there. What about Hille? Is he playing?
 
Farmer going to play???? I think you have loaded up too much in the backs at the expense of your rucks. There's a number of really good 4250k options out there. take at least one of them. I have 3.

Will Gibbs Squib??? I think so. Watson could be a winner. COULD be.

As has been said, a bit under done here.

Fwds pretty good. Roberts?? Who is he???

Farmer will play been impressive.
I see your point with the backs but i dont agree. The problem with selecting player at that range of 425k is that most dont improve there price and often fall im guessing youv probablly gone for a Joel Mcdonald, Mackie or a harbrow. i just cant see those guys improving from last year.

Gibbs is a risk but hopefully it will pay off with no Judd hes gonna be the leader of the blues midfield.

Relton Roberts just got promoted of the richmond rookie list, has kicked a goal in every game and has said to impress, obviously things will change with the naming of rd 1 teams.

Thanks mate really appreciate it :thumbsu:
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Super Coach enthusiasts, care to wave your wand over my team

Backs: Goodwin, Enright, Shaw, Hodge, Kennelly, Everitt, Ladson
Emg: Maguire, Silvagni

Mids: Murphy, Bartel, Harvey, Ball, Trengove, Martin
Emg: Barlow, Moles

Ruck: Tippett, Hille
Emg: Charman, Roughead

Fwds: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Hall, Zieball, Rockliff
Emg: Hitchcock, Gumbleton

Have $140k left.

Thoughts? Is there any major oversights, any first year gems I can get in there. What about Hille? Is he playing?

Backs: Kennely and everitt very risky have one not both
Mids: its missing ablett enough said
Rucks: Solid enough ( Think Charman is injured though)
Fwds: very strong

That 140k left use to downgrade Kennely to a Shoenmakers and get Ablett in your team
 
Super Coach enthusiasts, care to wave your wand over my team

Backs: Goodwin, Enright, Shaw, Hodge, Kennelly, Everitt, Ladson
Emg: Maguire, Silvagni

Mids: Murphy, Bartel, Harvey, Ball, Trengove, Martin
Emg: Barlow, Moles

Ruck: Tippett, Hille
Emg: Charman, Roughead

Fwds: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Higgins, Franklin, Hall, Zieball, Rockliff
Emg: Hitchcock, Gumbleton

Have $140k left.

Thoughts? Is there any major oversights, any first year gems I can get in there. What about Hille? Is he playing?
Uprade Bartel to Ablett with that extra cash. Money in the bank wont earn you SC points.

Not sure about Everitt in defence maybe hunt is a better option? Goodwin will be 33 this year and risks soft tissue injury, he has a history of injury, missed 3 games last year. Newman a much better option. Other than that i like it.
 
Lol you are sabotaging everyones teams.

Yeah stats would be nice, but it cost a bit to do tha stats there are about 6 people in a room that count the stats, NAB Challenge games can be misleading aswell, because there are kids against the 'big boys'. So although they are helpful they can be very misleading. If you want stats you can go on fanfooty.com.au they have some of the NAB stats.

Have you read my 'Are club captains worth a good look?' thread? Maxwell is mentioned in there 'Becoming club captain has transformed this guy in to a SC point scoring machine'.

Harry O, I am harsh on because he broke Newmans leg, and that is the only reason i dislike him :p

yeah i suppose they could be a little misleading, but i wouldn't have taken much notice of Liam Anthony had he not averaged over 100 in the NAB series last year, hence i hung on to him even though he had stress fractures, a move which paid off very well.

I have read that thread. O'Brien has just been promoted to the leadership group, so maybe his scores will improve only half as much as what Maxwell's did..? :)

I was at that game, it looked horrible..
I still don't really like Michael Voss when he ran through Alan Richardson at the gabba about 10 or so years ago.. Although it was an awesome hit..!
 
Uprade Bartel to Ablett with that extra cash. Money in the bank wont earn you SC points.

Not sure about Everitt in defence maybe hunt is a better option? Goodwin will be 33 this year and risks soft tissue injury, he has a history of injury, missed 3 games last year. Newman a much better option. Other than that i like it.

Ablett $744K
Bartel $578K

$140K in the bank.

I may not know when the prices changed, but your math is terrible! :D
 
Farmer will play been impressive.
I see your point with the backs but i dont agree. The problem with selecting player at that range of 425k is that most dont improve there price and often fall im guessing youv probablly gone for a Joel Mcdonald, Mackie or a harbrow. i just cant see those guys improving from last year.

Gibbs is a risk but hopefully it will pay off with no Judd hes gonna be the leader of the blues midfield.

Relton Roberts just got promoted of the richmond rookie list, has kicked a goal in every game and has said to impress, obviously things will change with the naming of rd 1 teams.

Thanks mate really appreciate it :thumbsu:


My bad. I meant $250k. Not $425k. I'm talking Ladson, Hunt, Malceski, Evrritt, etc.

Not with you on Gibbs but best of luck!! :thumbsu:
 
yeah i suppose they could be a little misleading, but i wouldn't have taken much notice of Liam Anthony had he not averaged over 100 in the NAB series last year, hence i hung on to him even though he had stress fractures, a move which paid off very well.

I have read that thread. O'Brien has just been promoted to the leadership group, so maybe his scores will improve only half as much as what Maxwell's did..? :)

I was at that game, it looked horrible..
I still don't really like Michael Voss when he ran through Alan Richardson at the gabba about 10 or so years ago.. Although it was an awesome hit..!
Yeah and I think we will see the some thing (hopefully) this season woth Rockliff. Could pay of Handsomly.

Im guessing You have Harry O in your team? Look the bloke seems ok, now that ive looked at so stats) but the last time I payed any attention to him was when he was always in and out of the teams a few of years ago.

Dont bring up the Richo incident i was just getting over it. :p

This is my team now:
Backline

Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Corrazzo, Malceski, Ladson, Waters.
Maguire, Davies.
Midfield
Ablett, Dal Santo, Cooney, Ball, Trengrove, Martin.
Barlow, Shuey.
Rucks
Jolly, Hille.
Warnock, Skipper.
Forward line
Riewoldt, Harvey, Franklin, Tippett, Hall, Medhurst, Rockliff.
Gumbleton, Podsiadly.
A strong team I think, nobody i really wanna get rid of but i still have over 180k, I might just upgrade some rookies?
 
Ablett $744K
Bartel $578K

$140K in the bank.

I may not know when the prices changed, but your math is terrible! :D

No, but I said to get rid of a few other blokes also, that will make up for the extra. Goodwin for newman saves 30k so haha looks like your wrong mate. he would have 4 k left over.
 
Uprade Bartel to Ablett with that extra cash. Money in the bank wont earn you SC points.

Not sure about Everitt in defence maybe hunt is a better option? Goodwin will be 33 this year and risks soft tissue injury, he has a history of injury, missed 3 games last year. Newman a much better option. Other than that i like it.

I don't see where you mention anything about downgrading other players to get Ablett..???

Just use the money in the bank to get Ablett instead of Bartel..??

If you had of said that after the mentioning of Everitt to Hunt and Goodwin to Newman, then that infers that you meant what you thought you meant..!

:D :thumbsu:
 
I don't see where you mention anything about downgrading other players to get Ablett..???

Just use the money in the bank to get Ablett instead of Bartel..??
:D :thumbsu:

Well I ment in conjunction haha. Stop being a smartass. So what u think i should do with the spare 180k?
 
This is my team now:
Backline

Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Corrazzo, Malceski, Ladson, Waters.
Maguire, Davies.
Midfield
Ablett, Dal Santo, Cooney, Ball, Trengrove, Martin.
Barlow, Shuey.
Rucks
Jolly, Hille.
Warnock, Skipper.
Forward line
Riewoldt, Harvey, Franklin, Tippett, Hall, Medhurst, Rockliff.
Gumbleton, Podsiadly.
A strong team I think, nobody i really wanna get rid of but i still have over 180k, I might just upgrade some rookies?

Backs look reasonably strong, only major thing to watch for is Malceski, who is apparently right on the edge of the Swans 22. I'd keep an eye on the Round 1 teams in regards to him.

Midfield is solid enough. I have my question marks over Ball, and I think there's better value rookies then Trengove, but you could argue either way. Worth noting that downgrading Trengove would free up 70k though.

Rucks is obviously your choice of around a 500k and 300k player - not the combo I'd pick, but not a bad combo by any stretch.

Forward line is decent, but is probably the weakest part of your squad. I'd look at using your spare cash to upgrade Harvey to someone in the high 500k/low 600k range, or scraping a rookie and getting a Mayne/Ballantyne sort in with enough job security to be getting games week in, week out.

Hopefully that helps!

My team

Backs - Enright, *Duffield*, Shaw, Hodge, Kennelly, *Greenwood*, Waters (Maguire, Silvagni)

Midfielders - Dal Santo, Pendlebury, Watson, Cooney, Martin, Barlow (*Banner*, Shuey)

Rucks - Clark, Nic Nat (Warnock, Roughead)

Forwards - Riewoldt, ROK, Brown, *Gray*, *Hall*, Medhurst, *Walker* (Rockliff, Hitchcock)

Main queries are the highlighted players, and are as followed

- Duffield or Newman? Newman is rumoured to be pushing into the midfield, but I've heard that's going to result in more accountable football from him, and a higher likelihood of skill errors. Yet again, he could explode. Duffield is one you wouldn't expect a big improvement from, but his pre-season has been elite. Thoughts?

- Is Greenwood going to get less run with jobs in 2010, or will he be mostly a lock-down man again? I've heard conflicting reports.

- In regards to Banner, will Moles get a run in the Bulldogs best 22 if he gets elevated? Or am I better off sticking with Banner?

- Gray or LeCras? And is the Gray injured rumour got any credit behind it?

- Hall or Murphy?

- Is Walker a lock in the best 22 this season? Word of him running through the midfield is very exciting at that price!

Thanks to any and all that help :)
 
Yeah and I think we will see the some thing (hopefully) this season woth Rockliff. Could pay of Handsomly.

Im guessing You have Harry O in your team? Look the bloke seems ok, now that ive looked at so stats) but the last time I payed any attention to him was when he was always in and out of the teams a few of years ago.

Dont bring up the Richo incident i was just getting over it. :p

This is my team now:
Backline

Goddard, Enright, Hodge, Corrazzo, Malceski, Ladson, Waters.
Maguire, Davies.
Midfield
Ablett, Dal Santo, Cooney, Ball, Trengrove, Martin.
Barlow, Shuey.
Rucks
Jolly, Hille.
Warnock, Skipper.
Forward line
Riewoldt, Harvey, Franklin, Tippett, Hall, Medhurst, Rockliff.
Gumbleton, Podsiadly.
A strong team I think, nobody i really wanna get rid of but i still have over 180k, I might just upgrade some rookies?

There are obviously numerous ways your could spend your cash..

You could upgrade Carrazzo to Newman and then upgrade Cooney to Mitchell/Bartel.

Franklin to Chapman/Goodes.

Hill To McIntosh..?

I like your rookies, so i'm not sure..?

personally i don't like Cooney..? not sure why everyone is so keen on him..?
Even in his brownlow year, averaged just over 100..? So he is only going to improve by 8-9 points per game if he gets back to his 08 form..?

I would use the money on getting a better midfielder..

Oh and P.S, i don't have Harry O'Brien in my team ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top