Competition Rate the Opposition MVP - Season 36 Edition - Winner Announced

[Kilroy]

…and as I said, thank you for proving my point.

I’m saying that you shouldn’t & that when AnUltimateRessie uses activity data it ruins the entire purpose of his concept.

Is it “Rate the opposition” or Sweet’s “Spammiest Spammersl?

Better than nothing?

If you wanna complain about a good idea gone wrong, ask Cadsky what happened to the Sweet FA Pass Mark thread

 

[Robertio]

…and as I said, thank you for proving my point.

I’m saying that you shouldn’t & that when AnUltimateRessie uses activity data it ruins the entire purpose of his concept.

Is it “Rate the opposition” or Sweet’s “Spammiest Spammersl?

Doesn't matter mate you're not getting a mention either way.

 

[Senor M]

Doesn't matter mate you're not getting a mention either way.

Some of us are capable of thinking beyond ourselves Robertio.

I would’ve have thought someone who cares so much about this award (as you brag about coming top 5 a few seasons back at every opportunity) would want this award to mean something rather than be a convoluted mess.

 

[Robertio]

Some of us are capable of thinking beyond ourselves Robertio.

I would’ve have thought someone who cares so much about this award (as you brag about coming top 5 a few seasons back at every opportunity) would want this award to mean something rather than be a convoluted mess.

I came top 5 twice mate.

 

[Senor M]

Better than nothing?

If you wanna complain about a good idea gone wrong, ask Cadsky what happened to the Sweet FA Pass Mark thread

Just because Cadsky has a bad idea, doesn’t mean that the voting process for this award is inconsistent & makes no sense.

I feel like I’m back in the Season 30 rookie thread trying to explain to you that it’s ok if people aren’t around to post on a Friday night

 

[Senor M]

I came top 5 twice mate.

Congratulations.

Wouldn’t the award mean more if the votes came from the same place each week so we were able to know if you were Top 5 for being popular or if it was just because you were spammy?

 

[Robertio]

Congratulations.

Wouldn’t the award mean more if the votes came from the same place each week so we were able to know if you were Top 5 for being popular or if it was just because you were spammy?

Probably a bit of both i would say.

 

[Cadsky]

Better than nothing?

If you wanna complain about a good idea gone wrong, ask Cadsky what happened to the Sweet FA Pass Mark thread

Firing back up again shortly

 

[Kilroy]

Just because Cadsky has a bad idea, doesn’t mean that the voting process for this award is inconsistent & makes no sense.

This award has always had a mix of voting criteria. It mostly got derailed by teams not submitting votes.

The difference here is the “penalty” for not doing so is that “legitimate“ qualitative votes get replaced by post counts.

Post counts were often the go to anyway if you struggled with identifying who said what.

 

[Gralin]

I think it's rather clear that when i got a clear lead people realised I couldn't be beaten fairly and gave up, even AnUltimateRessie didn't update at the end of round 5

Competition - Rate the Opposition MVP - Season 36 Edition - Winner Announced

I'd like to give them all 3 votes! I'll give them all 0 instead. Cheers

www.bigfooty.com

Pretty clear this is the top 3

Rank	Player	Team	Total Votes
1	Gralin	Demons	12
2	TedDougChris	Roys	11
3	Cadsky	Royals	10

 

[serial_thrilla]

Pretty clear this is the top 3

Rank	Player	Team	Total Votes
1	Gralin	Demons	12
2	TedDougChris	Roys	11
3	Cadsky	Royals	10

As if this competition didn't lack enough credibility already...

 

[Gralin]

As if this competition didn't lack enough credibility already...

I'm not worried about credibility, just badges.

I assume the winner gets a badge?

If not I no longer care about rigging the result

 

[King Tenz]

If you’re going to allocate posts to the spammiest players then it moves away from the entire purpose of “Rate the Opposition”.

It now just becomes a second tier posting award with no consistency in the way points are accumulated.

See AnUltimateRessie? Salt.

 

[King Tenz]

I didn’t base my choices on numbers, Senor.

I do. Lol.

Sue me.

I'm gonna reward guys who are more active. But, I will give votes to someone who isn't as active but never the 3.

 

[AnUltimateRessie]

If you’re going to allocate posts to the spammiest players then it moves away from the entire purpose of “Rate the Opposition”.

It now just becomes a second tier posting award with no consistency in the way points are accumulated.

Appreciate your passion about this concept. I feel like it's less about the final award and more about showing appreciation to quality.

Usually those that are top three posters in the thread are the ones that get the votes anyway.

 

[Sun Ra]

Round 7 vs Bad News Bears

3 - JoshWoodenSpoon
2 - Millky95
0.125 - Senor M, guero, Dingster, Tandy, tony, Cap, MWPP & RonnieRaven.

Also acknowledge DemurePrincess for the disruptive "research".

Thread = 3.3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333 / 5.0

 

[Robertio]

3. AnUltimateRessie engaging all week
2. HARPSichord always fun
1. damicky always good

Thread 4/5 always enjoyable with the Wonders

 

[Senor M]

Appreciate your passion about this concept. I feel like it's less about the final award and more about showing appreciation to quality.

Usually those that are top three posters in the thread are the ones that get the votes anyway.

Quality & quantity are not the same thing.

If you can’t see the difference between the two, maybe you can explain why Pickitt is the greatest poster in the history of the SFA?

 

[King Tenz]

Quality & quantity are not the same thing.

If you can’t see the difference between the two, maybe you can explain why Pickitt is the greatest poster in the history of the SFA?

Wait, is Pickitt not the greatest poster of all time?

 

[HARPSichord]

Round 7 v OOB

3. Robertio - another excellent performance from our resident Guinness drinker.
2. Braklet - kept the thread chugging along and always caught up even though there are massive time zone differences
1. kenneyswarriors - camel gif king

HM to TJohn, very handy rookie.

Thread 4/5. Always a fun time with the OOB.

 

[King Tenz]

Am I also allowed to vote for Old Boys AnUltimateRessie? I want my bench vice king, kenneyswarriors to have 3 votes.

 

[AnUltimateRessie]

Am I also allowed to vote for Old Boys AnUltimateRessie? I want my bench vice king, kenneyswarriors to have 3 votes.

I don't think Greenery or T2B_ would be too happy with you pretending to be a Wonder

 

[Greenery]

I don't think Greenery or T2B_ would be too happy with you pretending to be a Wonder

I have already PM'd King Tenz to inform him that any posts made in Wonders threads will be deducted from his Dragons match thread post count and he's now at risk of not hitting his posting quota. (I am very angry)

 

[damicky]

I have already PM'd King Tenz to inform him that any posts made in Wonders threads will be deducted from his Dragons match thread post count and he's now at risk of not hitting his posting quota. (I am very angry)

You could have just tagged KT in this Thread

 

[Greenery]

You could have just tagged KT in this Thread

I am sending a message to the Wonders that I take this as a provacation and a personal attack.
My lawyers have already informed me that this kind of behaviour towards opposition rookie players constitutes harrassment and is usually only met with a dire karmic punishment.

Consider how the Wonders were forced to have you captain them for several seasons after Cadsky poached you.