Rate the Player Above You

[ZabsBlues]

Iam not surkin but Jared Rivers 7.5/10

Marc Murphy

 

[Surkin]

Rivers is a 4. Injury plagued and not that great.
Murphy is an 8. Consistent top flight performer.

Liam Picken?

 

[West123]

Liam Picken?

6/10.

Not top level by any means but with the potential to be a quality pesky tagger for the decade to come he is worth a rank.

Aaron Joseph?

 

[StonesThrow]

6/10.

Not top level by any means but with the potential to be a quality pesky tagger for the decade to come he is worth a rank.

Aaron Joseph?

5/10 I think he will prove to be a good tagger and with his speed could possibly develop into a decent mid. Too young atm to say much though.

Shannon Hurn

 

[The Kipster]

5/10 I think he will prove to be a good tagger and with his speed could possibly develop into a decent mid. Too young atm to say much though.

Shannon Hurn

6/10 a good runner with a booming kick, slightly lacking in peripheral vision

Will Minson?

 

[Lions1024]

6/10 a good runner with a booming kick, slightly lacking in peripheral vision

Will Minson?

4/10 was tempted to give him a 3.

Joel Patfull

 

[dread and might]

6. Potentially, 7.5-8

Kieren Jack

 

[Rack Watts]

6. Potentially, 7.5-8

Kieren Jack

7/10

-----

Tayte Pears

 

[BACCS]

7/10

-----

Tayte Pears

8/10 on what I've seen.

Rutten?

 

[AG]

Rutten?

8/10. One of the best FB's this decade and is still performing well.

Shaun Burgoyne?

 

[stugots]

8/10 on what I've seen.

Rutten?

7.5 with an upside

bellchambers..

 

[brjafi]

7.5 with an upside

bellchambers..

5.8

jake king

 

[Axel.]

7.5 with an upside

bellchambers..

2/10 atm

Albert Proud?

 

[Puddy]

2/10 atm

Albert Proud?

6.5/10 -decent player

Danyle Pearce

 

[anti_]

pearce 6/10 - he could be so much better
jake king 4/10 - just not really upto AFL

adam selwood

 

[Axel.]

6.5/10 -decent player

Danyle Pearce

Very hard one imo.

At his best 7.5-8/10
At his worst 4/10

adam selwood

Adam Selwood 7/10

Mitch Clark?

 

[raskolnikov]

7/10 - potential to be more

Robin Nahas

 

[Copulator]

7/10 - potential to be more

Robin Nahas

4/10

Will raise to 8/10 if he grows a Jordan Mcmahon porno mo

Winston Abraham?

 

[WWWombat]

8/10 for potential

3/10 for application

So . . .

5.5/10 overall

Alby Smedts

 

[Greening Magic]

8/10 for potential

3/10 for application

So . . .

5.5/10 overall

Alby Smedts

1.5 (this is based on playing on Alby when he was old and playing country footy, age had taken it's toll)

Luke Ball

 

[Juddbemetron]

1.5 (this is based on playing on Alby when he was old and playing country footy, age had taken it's toll)

Luke Ball

5/10-if he gets his body right could be 7 or even 8

Jarrad Waite

 

[SirJimi05]

Currently 3/10. Very much done and Dustined.

Over his career I'd say 7.5/10.

Dayne Beams.

ROFL!

So i presume Harry O is a 1/10?

Fletcher was awesome this year.

Finished 2nd in Essendon's B&F.

Would have comfortably won the B&F had he not missed 5-6 games through injury.

Made the initial AA squad.

Obviously you didn't watch any Essendon games this season and just automatically assume he is past it because he is old.

 

[conodie05]

ROFL!

So i presume Harry O is a 1/10?

Fletcher was awesome this year.

Finished 2nd in Essendon's B&F.

Would have comfortably won the B&F had he not missed 5-6 games through injury.

Made the initial AA squad.

Obviously you didn't watch any Essendon games this season and just automatically assume he is past it because he is old.

You're right. I didn't. Sue me.

 

[SirJimi05]

You're right. I didn't. Sue me.

Why post then? Save your posts for players you actually know something about.

 

[ringo200]

5/10-if he gets his body right could be 7 or even 8

Jarrad Waite

7/10 as a backman if he recovers properly from his injury, which he should.

I haven't seen enough of him him as a forward but I think his run out of the backline is too important to move him up there permanently.

Jesse Smith