Rate the Player Above You

[SirJimi05]

7/10 as a backman if he recovers properly from his injury, which he should.

I haven't seen enough of him him as a forward but I think his run out of the backline is too important to move him up there permanently.

Jesse Smith

3/10 only due to the amount of football he has missed due to injury.

8.5/10 on potential alone.

 

[conodie05]

Why post then? Save your posts for players you actually know something about.

Like you did with Jessie Smith?

 

[SirJimi05]

Like you did with Jessie Smith?

I know nothing about Jessie Smith. Is he any good?

But i have probably watched Jesse Smith play about 15 times.

Very talented player. Had a good season a few years back and really stood out in a game against my team. I remember thinking that day that he could be a great player in the future.

His old man was a very good player and slightly under-rated imo.

But the facts are his entire career has been cruelled by injury so it is pretty hard to give him much more than a 3 on output alone.

On potential he is an 8 no problems there.

What parts make you think that i haven't seen him play?

Atleast i know the guys name ffs.

 

[swans16]

Jesse White

 

[carmi99]

lmao Jimi is owning the Collingwood clown.

 

[Lord_Travis]

Jesse White

Currently 5/10
Potential 7.5/10

Jamie Bennell

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Currently 5/10
Potential 7.5/10

Jamie Bennell

5/10 - on performance

7.5/10 on potential

Really liked what I saw from him in about 10 or so games, wouldn't be surprised if he improved a lot and became a great winger. Seemed pretty creative just forward of centre.



Courtney Dempsey

 

[AG]

Courtney Dempsey

6.5/10. Finally got over his injury problems and started the season well. Trailed off towards the end imo but that was probably expected after his first proper season. His composure and pressuring skills are very good and he always looks like he is just cruising around the park. Has a good chance to really step up next year after having a break out year, so hopefully he stays injury free over the pre season.

Jarrod Harbrow

 

[craaaig]

6.5/10. Finally got over his injury problems and started the season well. Trailed off towards the end imo but that was probably expected after his first proper season. His composure and pressuring skills are very good and he always looks like he is just cruising around the park. Has a good chance to really step up next year after having a break out year, so hopefully he stays injury free over the pre season.

Jarrod Harbrow

7.5/10

David Zaharakis

 

[CarnCrows]

7.5/10

David Zaharakis

6/10 - Great goal against the pies, lots of promise, but too early to rate any higher.

Brent Reilly

 

[rainman06]

6.5/10

I appreciate that he does some of his work behind-the-scenes so to speak, but I dont think he really does enough. Jack of all trades, master of none.

Angus Monfries

 

[Football God]

6.5/10

I appreciate that he does some of his work behind-the-scenes so to speak, but I dont think he really does enough. Jack of all trades, master of none.

Angus Monfries

still only young and already a leader at the club he will only get better
atm 7.5/10

darren jolly

 

[Dangas]

still only young and already a leader at the club he will only get better
atm 7.5/10

darren jolly

10/10 - The guy is a champ, sad to see him leave

Rhyce Shaw

 

[AG]

10/10 - The guy is a champ, sad to see him leave

10/10? Ablett is the only player close to a 10/10 overall imo. Jolly is probably about an 8/10. One of the top 4 or 5 ruckmen in the league.

Rhyce Shaw

7.5/10. Had a very good season but needs to back it up to be rated amongst the best HB flankers in the comp.

Jason Akermanis

 

[Claude Balls]

10/10? Ablett is the only player close to a 10/10 overall imo. Jolly is probably about an 8/10. One of the top 4 or 5 ruckmen in the league.


7.5/10. Had a very good season but needs to back it up to be rated amongst the best HB flankers in the comp.

Jason Akermanis

Now, 6.5/10. At his best 9/10

Brett Deledio

 

[Blues_Man]

Now, 6.5/10. At his best 9/10

Brett Deledio

6.5/7 out of 10 Shown promise but is To inconsistent at the moment.

Shane O'Bree

 

[anti_]

6.5/10 for o'bree - he's under-rated, collingwood have gotten a lot out of him. not a skilled player, but gives it his all. good clearance player.

Scott McMahon

 

[daffo]

Scott McMahon

5.5/10

Can see him becoming a 200 game player. Showed a lot in 2009 and has showed glimpes of being a very good decision maker with the pill in the future.

Nathan Lovett-Murray.

 

[Swans120]

5/10. Good utility value and will do his job but can be a bit undisciplined at times from what i can see. Not a star and probs wont ever be, but good value in a team to have though.

Heath Grundy

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

5/10. Good utility value and will do his job but can be a bit undisciplined at times from what i can see. Not a star and probs wont ever be, but good value in a team to have though.

Heath Grundy

6/10 and I'm giving him one for being played out of position in the back line. Has the POTENTIAL to be a 8 or a 9 but so do plenty of others.

Adam Schneider

 

[swans16]

6/10 and I'm giving him one for being played out of position in the back line. Has the POTENTIAL to be a 8 or a 9 but so do plenty of others.

Adam Schneider

6.5/10

Patrick Veszpremi

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

lmao Jimi is owning the Collingwood clown.

You think???

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

6.5/10

Patrick Veszpremi

4/10 only a fringe player ATM. Will be huge if he plays week in, week out.

Daniel Giansiracusa

 

[BACCS]

4/10 only a fringe player ATM. Will be huge if he plays week in, week out.

Daniel Giansiracusa

7/10 but just hasnt been as effective in the last couple of years IMO.

Vince

 

[Dooky]

7/10 but just hasnt been as effective in the last couple of years IMO.

Vince

Star...8/10. This bloke would have much bigger wraps on him if he played in Victoria.

Paul Bower