Preview Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oct 12, 2008
18,713
22,503
AFL Club
Carlton
AFL Premiership Round 1

[FONT=&quot]CARLTON BLUES VS. RICHMOND TIGERS[/FONT]

[FONT=&quot]
carlton-football-club-logo.gif
VS.
images
[/FONT]

LADDER

(Nothing to see here yet, but left here for future templating purposes)

FORM

(NAB Cup)
Carlton: W L W W L
Richmond: L L W L L

Richmond's final hit out against the Crows at Visy Park once again showed their deficiencies in ball movement and skills and capped off a forgetful pre season competition campaign.

The NAB Cup and Challenge matches saw the Tigers struggle to get the ball out of their defensive 50 against sides who employed the forward line press. However on occasions where they were able to create space they looked dangerous on the attack when less thinking is required and they kick it long and run for each other. Their trades add to depth, not sure about their quality. Draft pick ups like Conca look more likely though, doubt they’ll have an effect against us.

Carlton’s Pre Season has been promising and we’ve seen new players like Duigan, Laidler and Collins all justify their selections and push for best 22 status. Others like Watson, Twomey and Curnow are very close too. Positional changes wise, Chris Yarran to the HB line has been a revelation and the Tigers would be crazy to not put a defensive tag on this guy. Andrew Walker to the forward line allowed Mitch Robinson to work not only on his endurance but to focus on solely being a midfielder and so far, he has added a welcome dose of grunt :thumbsu:

A fade out in the last minutes of the Cats game can be attributed to the heat, but it’s nonetheless worrying and hopefully the two week break will allow for the boys to rest up and the likes of Murphy, Hampson, White, Carrazzo, McLean to rest up before the big game.

LAST TIME WE MET

Considering it’s a new season and last season is sort of irrelevant (as was the NAB Cup with plenty of new kids)...this should give a good indication of how it went..
[youtube]jME7qiCDrKk[/youtube]
[youtube]Xciay_QX-sA[/youtube]
[youtube]ZwUF5k7I0Us[/youtube]

POSSIBLE TEAMS (My opinion)
Carlton
FB: Russell, Watson/White/Thornton/Austin, Laidler
HB: Yarran, Bower, Duigan
C: Simpson, Gibbs, Scotland
HF: Walker, Waite, Collins
FF: Garlett, Henderson, Betts
R: Warnock, Judd, Murphy**
IC: Hampson, Robinson, Armfield/Carrazzo**, Lucas/McLean/Curnow/Joseph(SUB)
** = Under an injury cloud or limited game time
Bolded = Spot up for grabs

Richmond
FB: Newman, McGuane, Rance
HB: Deledio, Astbury, Connors
C: Morton, Cotchin, Grigg
HF: Houli, Riewoldt, Conca
FF: Nahas, Vickery, Edwards
R: Graham, Martin, Tuck
IC: Foley, Jackson, Batchelor/White, Derrickx(sp?[SUB])
(not all too sure about this line up, so won’t bold and asterickx [pun intended] players)

KEY PLAYERS & MATCH UPS
- Jack Riewoldt: Where will he play? At Full Forward or further up the ground with Vickery at FF? This is could be a game changer with Jamison being out and having an undersized Bower, inexperienced White/Watson/Austin or less than favourable Thornton playing on him. We’ll need to double team him whenever possible, Duigan and Laidler will play an important part in this, Gibbs may float back too.

- Rucks: Warnock and Hampson look ominous and could inflict a world of pain if the Tigers’ rucks don’t step up. Will Angus Graham be accompanied by Tom Derickx (sp?) who has impressed or the unproven Tyrone Vickery who will rest forward? All 3 could be played though so keep your eyes on that battle.

- Mitch Morton: Usually kicks a few goals on us and is dangerous around the goals, looks set to play midfield which I believe is the wrong move with Houli and Grigg who are now available to rotate there. IMO he’ll be much less effectual in the midfield.

- Jeffrey Garlett: How will Richmond contain this guy while also trying to keep Eddie quiet?

- Bryce Gibbs: Has a point to prove, he’ll be aware he’s had an iffy pre season and let’s hope he comes out guns blazing.

PREDICTION

Richmond will not be confident of a win here but would absolutely LOVE to ruin our party. Watch for Shaun Grigg to have a big game against his old side and try to stick it up Ratts, in the end though they have not progressed enough to make ground on us and we’re getting closer and closer to pushing for top 6 and becoming a side that can shake up the Top 4 in next couple of years. Riewoldt in and Jamison out would make for an interesting match if it wasn’t for the impending complete shutting down of Richmond’s attack out of their D50. If there was another decent big forward we may well have been challenged, but Tyrone Vickery should not prove much for a Simon White or Bret Thornton type.

Watch for us to use our superior ball use and experienced bodies to overrun the Tigs. It doesn’t help them that we’ve also had this guy helping us at the club..
vladimir-putin-the-whale-hunter.jpg



BLUES BY 44
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:10PM, 25th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

Thanks Sin, didn't want to write too much considering it's already mostly been covered in 4000 other posts :p

Hopefully the template etc is good enough for others to base theirs on
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:10PM, 25th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

Thanks for the preview, good sensible posting which has been sorely missing in countless other threads, agree with your result also, im predicting going down by 40-50 points
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

They just have too many passengers on their list ..and when a team recruits Brad Miller you know they are in deep shit .

Carlton should do the usual 12 goal flogging ..anything less will be underperforming.
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

This thread won't get to 1000 posts before round one.

Lift!

Just wait for all the ferals to start posting in the thread.

Top job Zee! :thumbsu:
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

FFS Yeah, the result means zilch but it bodes well for another 10+ goal spanking against Carlton. I don't know If I can handle that again.


Hehehe.
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

I watched the Crows V Richmond practice match, and it was very clear that the Jack to CHF experiment was an epic Fail. He doesn't have the tank, kicking range, or athleticism to play the leadup CHF role. I have no idea why Hardwick would contemplate such a move. He was only dangerous when he was moved back to the goalsquare. I'd be amazed if Hardwick tries that again round 1. Jack needs to kick 6+ goals if the Tiges are to have any chance, and he'll only do that playing deep forward.

:)
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

I agree with everything in the OP except for the omission of Army.

Probably instead of Duigan but at the very least Joseph...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

Not sure as to where Deledio is going to play yet, like Gibbs hasn't done a hell of a lot in the praccy matches, if he went into the midfield would you expect to tag him?? Thoughts?
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

Not sure as to where Deledio is going to play yet, like Gibbs hasn't done a hell of a lot in the praccy matches, if he went into the midfield would you expect to tag him?? Thoughts?
I don't think we need to waste too many midfield spots on negative roles. Carrazzo if he plays or Armfield should be the only tagger in the midfield.
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

Really good preview Zee, thanks comrade !!

I really hope we really really smash them as in previous years, can;t wait for the first bounce.

Now for the feral invasion..
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

Not sure as to where Deledio is going to play yet, like Gibbs hasn't done a hell of a lot in the praccy matches, if he went into the midfield would you expect to tag him?? Thoughts?
See Round 14, 2008.
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

Well, I'd say yes.

He lead a less experienced team without their captain, to a victory over a highly experienced team that would ultimately vie for the finals.

Gibbs' team won by 30 points. Gibbs kicked two more goals from the midfield whilst playing on a player 2 years his senior and with 2 seasons more experience.

Both players payed each other little respect in terms of defensive application, Carlton profited the most.
 
Re: Rd 1 - Carlton vs. Richmond, 7:40PM, 24th March @ MCG - Preview, Gameday & Review Thread

Really looking forward to the possible rookie elevations. For Carlton with Mclean injured, Ellard suspended, I reckon Curnow is a cert. I'm not too fussed that we're going into this game way under full-strength. It's a great opportunity for our younger players to get a taste, and maybe even hold onto a spot.

:)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top