The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
- Moderator
- #1
Give me an F ... give me a U ... give me C ... give me a .... ah you get the point.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 7 - Pride Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Autopsy Rd 21 Carlton v Geelong Post Match Discussion
- Thread starter The Old Dark Navy's
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I'll cop the Christensen free when they give us the Menzel free and four points from earlier in the year.
I don't feel as shocked as I should be. Probably because I am used to seeing us getting reamed by the umpires vs Geelong.
Umpires yeah but no one stepped up when we needed them Murphyseriously doesn't cut it with me
I seldom cheer for you guys, but I was hoping for a win after more deplorable umpiring for the protected species. Commiserations.
The Blue Baggers
Premiership Player
- Apr 7, 2013
- 3,919
- 3,280
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Worse thing is you just expect the blues to lose close ones , thanks umps ! Woeful decision !!
Feeling very cheated and deflated! I guess the worm will turn for the Blues at some point soon. The boys fought it out and were cruelled by having only 19 players and a lousy and unprofessional umpiring decision.
Mangus Onfries
Club Legend
- Aug 5, 2013
- 1,292
- 2,785
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Loved the way your boys played. So sick of Geelong getting a leg up from the umpires. See you next Friday.
- Jul 14, 2012
- 8,858
- 14,470
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Positive.
I am confident in this playing group.
Two things cost us that game.
1. 23rd Geelong player in yellow.
2. Inexperience and lack of composure.
One will sort itself out in time. The other one will continue running around with a whistle.
Grrrr
I am confident in this playing group.
Two things cost us that game.
1. 23rd Geelong player in yellow.
2. Inexperience and lack of composure.
One will sort itself out in time. The other one will continue running around with a whistle.
Grrrr
I dont see an afl player in graham anymore. I had high hopes but really isnt getting near it.
Something needs to massively change for him to become a best 22 player
(Yes its early, but not a lot of elite attributes at this level)
Something needs to massively change for him to become a best 22 player
(Yes its early, but not a lot of elite attributes at this level)
I blame the umpires less than our capacity to capitalise on our opportunities. Once again, we shouldn't have been in the situation where one decision decided the match.
JuddsABlue
Norm Smith Medallist
Not good enough
We 'love' that we have guys that try and we protect them for critisizm, but I'm sure theres a more suitable sport out there where trying is the be all and end all. In AFL its not, and if we ever want to get serious, 'trying' isnt good enough, we need skill and so many of our players dont have it
I thought we lacked intensity in some spots, I was player watching a lot of our players on the fringe of the contest and some just didnt go hard enough, and were peeled off to easily when they cut us up in the middle
Much better 2nd half of the year and something to build on, I hope these types of losses dont effect their minds too much
We 'love' that we have guys that try and we protect them for critisizm, but I'm sure theres a more suitable sport out there where trying is the be all and end all. In AFL its not, and if we ever want to get serious, 'trying' isnt good enough, we need skill and so many of our players dont have it
I thought we lacked intensity in some spots, I was player watching a lot of our players on the fringe of the contest and some just didnt go hard enough, and were peeled off to easily when they cut us up in the middle
Much better 2nd half of the year and something to build on, I hope these types of losses dont effect their minds too much
Positive.
I am confident in this playing group.
Two things cost us that game.
1. 23rd Geelong player in yellow.
2. Inexperience and lack of composure.
One will sort itself out in time. The other one will continue running around with a whistle.
Grrrr
Big statement
Can't wait to hear Umpire rep explain that decision.
- Jul 14, 2012
- 8,858
- 14,470
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Nup. Not pwaying anymore.
If graham not careful he will end up back in the vfl
Jabba73
Hall of Famer
Makes me want to vomit watching the Cats players celebrating like they deserved the win, should be ****ing embarrassed they needed that much help to win given our injuries.
Positive.
I am confident in this playing group.
Two things cost us that game.
1. 23rd Geelong player in yellow.
2. Inexperience and lack of composure.
One will sort itself out in time. The other one will continue running around with a whistle.
Grrrr
Playing with no rotations, plus missing a fair few. Did allright.
