-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Mega Thread Richmond Vs. GCS - Matchday Discussion
- Thread starter tunksy
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS
Out: Hislop and Post
In: White and Browne
Out: Hislop and Post
In: White and Browne
_RT_
Community Leader
- Sep 17, 2006
- 47,034
- 91,406
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Furies Premiers 2010
- Moderator
- #79
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS
Full Team:
B: Newman Rance McGuane
HB: Deledio Thursfield Houli
C: Cotchin Martin Edwards
HF: Nahas Griffiths Helbig
F: King Riewoldt Vickery
R: Browne Conca Foley
INT: Jackson White Grigg Batchelor
EMG: Tuck Morton Farmer
Full Team:
B: Newman Rance McGuane
HB: Deledio Thursfield Houli
C: Cotchin Martin Edwards
HF: Nahas Griffiths Helbig
F: King Riewoldt Vickery
R: Browne Conca Foley
INT: Jackson White Grigg Batchelor
EMG: Tuck Morton Farmer
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
Not all that happy that Post had to be left out, but no doubt he is a victim of circumstances... playing in the heat and humidity, etc.
Wow! Tuck is an emergency, did anyone see that coming?
Not all that happy that Post had to be left out, but no doubt he is a victim of circumstances... playing in the heat and humidity, etc.
Wow! Tuck is an emergency, did anyone see that coming?
lynchy4610
Cancelled
- Mar 10, 2009
- 434
- 1
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #83
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
Happy with Browne in Post out, think we may be top heavy though, wouldn't surprise me to see Browne and White both late withdrawals and Tuck and Morton in.
I don't think White will play, has been injured and hasn't returned to coburg yet? Surely Tuck or Morton will come in at the very least
Happy with Browne in Post out, think we may be top heavy though, wouldn't surprise me to see Browne and White both late withdrawals and Tuck and Morton in.
I don't think White will play, has been injured and hasn't returned to coburg yet? Surely Tuck or Morton will come in at the very least
Tiger Titus
Team Captain
- May 11, 2011
- 576
- 764
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
Very disappointed to see Browne straight back in. He was very ordinary before his week off. Expect Smith to have a field day in the middle.
I don't understand why big Gus is being overlooked now, Browne has not proved he is better quality.
Would have like to see Vickery & Post given another run this week.
Very disappointed to see Browne straight back in. He was very ordinary before his week off. Expect Smith to have a field day in the middle.
I don't understand why big Gus is being overlooked now, Browne has not proved he is better quality.
Would have like to see Vickery & Post given another run this week.
YellowAndBlack83
Senior List
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS
.
Obviously we haven't learned anything over the past few weeks. We drop Post who was played out of position for a chunk of last week and when played forward showed a few nice signs for the Big Browne Log (thats kind of harsh on logs at least they are useful sometimes and move faster too), FFS why not Graham? he had a good game for Coburg last week I am seriously starting to think that he must have taken a shit in Hardwicks lunchbox or something. And no Tuck yet again even though we are struggling in the middle
.
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS
are whitey and browne automatic selections nowadays? both injured and come straight back in...while others languish at coburg. random
are whitey and browne automatic selections nowadays? both injured and come straight back in...while others languish at coburg. random
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS
He's a forward if you ask me. I reckon it was foolish to have him do the bulk of the rucking last week. I'm very happy we're playing a ruckman this week.
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS
Chin up little boy. Just keep getting angrier and angrier as Hardwick puts short term victories to the side with a longer term view of sustained success. Go barrack for Collingwood if you want to support a team that is winning. If Hardwick was taking the "shortcuts" Wallace did you'd be up in arms! Go into the kitchen and get a nice glass of reality!!!!
Chin up little boy. Just keep getting angrier and angrier as Hardwick puts short term victories to the side with a longer term view of sustained success. Go barrack for Collingwood if you want to support a team that is winning. If Hardwick was taking the "shortcuts" Wallace did you'd be up in arms! Go into the kitchen and get a nice glass of reality!!!!
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS
Agree with this.
Vickery is a great second string ruck but his true value is across half forward as a viable option to Jack.
The less time he HAS tospend on the ball the better off we are.
Regardless of whether it is is Browne or Gus we need a player that can at least compete as a number 1 ruck and Post will nevr be that sort of player.... He is not big enough!
Agree with this.
Vickery is a great second string ruck but his true value is across half forward as a viable option to Jack.
The less time he HAS tospend on the ball the better off we are.
Regardless of whether it is is Browne or Gus we need a player that can at least compete as a number 1 ruck and Post will nevr be that sort of player.... He is not big enough!
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
Happy with Browne over Gus, Gus should be made to dominate Coburg like Browne did before he can get in. Not happy with Post out, though.
White and Hislop I'm okay with, though I'd rather see Morton or Tuck in (possibly for Grigg).
Happy with Browne over Gus, Gus should be made to dominate Coburg like Browne did before he can get in. Not happy with Post out, though.
White and Hislop I'm okay with, though I'd rather see Morton or Tuck in (possibly for Grigg).
tugga
Hall of Famer
- May 9, 2006
- 35,851
- 71,688
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Tottenham,NY Rangers,Red Sox, SA Spurs
Gak Attack
Brownlow Medallist
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
Pffft Browne... what's the point? clearly doesn't have it to make it in the league.. just too slow, probably better smarts than Graham but at least I could put up with Graham as a 3rd choice ruck for the next couple of years. Getting smashed in clearances week after week and still no Tuck.. I give up.
Pffft Browne... what's the point? clearly doesn't have it to make it in the league.. just too slow, probably better smarts than Graham but at least I could put up with Graham as a 3rd choice ruck for the next couple of years. Getting smashed in clearances week after week and still no Tuck.. I give up.
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
Yeah I'm looking fwd to Morton coming back. Tuck is one of my favourite players and would have him ahead of Edwards and Grigg but seeing as pumping games into the younger blokes is the name of the game I understand why they're getting a game ahead of him.
Yeah I'm looking fwd to Morton coming back. Tuck is one of my favourite players and would have him ahead of Edwards and Grigg but seeing as pumping games into the younger blokes is the name of the game I understand why they're getting a game ahead of him.
pebblestone
Former Child
Richmond Tigers - 2017 Player Sponsor
Richmond Tigers - 2016 Player Sponsor
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
We were getting smashed in the clearances with Graham too. I reckon Browne deserves a run at it - we've got nothing to lose by testing the young bloke. Graham (and Browne for that matter) may well have been coached into oblivion IMO. Lade has a lot to answer for.
We were getting smashed in the clearances with Graham too. I reckon Browne deserves a run at it - we've got nothing to lose by testing the young bloke. Graham (and Browne for that matter) may well have been coached into oblivion IMO. Lade has a lot to answer for.
pebblestone
Former Child
Richmond Tigers - 2017 Player Sponsor
Richmond Tigers - 2016 Player Sponsor
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
Agree with all of what you have said. Feel for Tucky but with a bit of luck he'll get an offer from someone else next year. Hate to see him finish up like this after what he has done for the team.
Agree with all of what you have said. Feel for Tucky but with a bit of luck he'll get an offer from someone else next year. Hate to see him finish up like this after what he has done for the team.
rfctigerarmy
🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
Zac Smith is going to show us how it's done this week. I'm seriously nervous, I reckon GC might get up.
Zac Smith is going to show us how it's done this week. I'm seriously nervous, I reckon GC might get up.
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
FFS why do we continue to pick the worst player of all time?
Gus>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Browne
FFS why do we continue to pick the worst player of all time?
Gus>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Browne
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
If it wasn't for the compromised draft this year, we would be accused of tanking. Tuck, Morton and Gus have made an impact at Coburg, and deserved to be considered. I really like the way Matt White plays his heart out, but I didn't think he was an automatic selection these days. Ditto Browne.
Selection table descisions have me baffled. Post should have been left in the side for another two weeks at least - give the kid a decent opportunity to grow into a role. One week in, then the next out - can't be good for his confidence.
All eyes on Grigg this week. I can't see how he has kept his spot for the last month. At least Edwards showed something last week, but not Grigg.
We cannot lose this game. It just cannot happen. But the team selection has me scratching my head (again).
If it wasn't for the compromised draft this year, we would be accused of tanking. Tuck, Morton and Gus have made an impact at Coburg, and deserved to be considered. I really like the way Matt White plays his heart out, but I didn't think he was an automatic selection these days. Ditto Browne.
Selection table descisions have me baffled. Post should have been left in the side for another two weeks at least - give the kid a decent opportunity to grow into a role. One week in, then the next out - can't be good for his confidence.
All eyes on Grigg this week. I can't see how he has kept his spot for the last month. At least Edwards showed something last week, but not Grigg.
We cannot lose this game. It just cannot happen. But the team selection has me scratching my head (again).
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS
He is a ruckman/forward who hasn't had the developed body to ruck full time at AFL level yet. He's still a ruckman though and will be a bloody good one.
He is a ruckman/forward who hasn't had the developed body to ruck full time at AFL level yet. He's still a ruckman though and will be a bloody good one.
thetwooth
Senior List
Re: Richmond Vs. GCS - Team Discussion
finally white is back, has been part of the missing linkS....don't come back hislop hack and thank god post has gone with him. two hacks that need to be delisted/traded
finally white is back, has been part of the missing linkS....don't come back hislop hack and thank god post has gone with him. two hacks that need to be delisted/traded
Similar threads
- Locked
