Preview Richmond Vs Melbourne, MCG, Sunday 3:40 pm.... This is SRS BZNSS

[tigs2010]

I'm guessing Orren is two years older than Edwards but they play different positions. Exposing a young ruckman too early can hinder there development.

It's not even 2 years. One is currently 29 the other 30. Edwards would be playing if he had a good pre-season and Luke didn't. Then we'd be having the reverse discussion.

 

[Greggy]

Arnot in for Tucky, obviously Cotch and Vapor rub.

 

[Kapital city TIGER]

Why didn't you just argue his post rather than have a go at the poster like 99.9% of people on here do?

Did u mean, "argue his post...like 99% of people on here do? " ? or that 99% of people have a go at the poster, and why didn't he do that?

 

[Equus]

Cool it gents

 

[tigs2010]

Did u mean, "argue his post...like 99% of people on here do? " ? or that 99% of people have a go at the poster, and why didn't he do that?

First one. Lol may have exaggerated the % but usually majority attack the post not the poster.

 

[jesterx]

First one. Lol may have exaggerated the % but usually majority attack the post not the poster.

Hey shut up guy!

 

[Groupie_]

 

[tigs2010]

Hey shut up guy!

Hey go **** yourself.

 

[sante]

AARON EDWARDS WILL NOT PLAY UNLESS JACK OR MCGUN GO DOWN INJURED!!!!


Hopefully we see Arnot debut this weekend.

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

I'd like to see one of Dea or Arnott given we're going up against a pretty inexperienced side. For what it's worth the average age of our side last week was the third oldest in the AFL. Last year we were the third youngest just about every week. We've now got plenty of experience and solid bodies in the line up. We can afford to play a few kids, especially a 90kg kid in Arnott.

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

I'd like to see one of Dea or Arnott given we're going up against a pretty inexperienced side. For what it's worth the average age of our side last week was the third oldest in the AFL. Last year we were the third youngest just about every week. We've now got plenty of experience and solid bodies in the line up. We can afford to play a few kids, especially a 90kg kid in Arnott.

 

[rfctiger90]

Well.. that escalated quickly.

Happy with the changes. Hopefully Arnott comes in for a run. Probably deserves one. Although Dea does too. We'll see what happens I guess!

 

[Capitano_Cotch]

Really want to see Matt Dea on the park this weekend.
Think he has deserved his spot in the side and was pretty good for us last season when called upon.
Thinking Arnot may play though as a direct replacement for Tuck.

 

[Capitano_Cotch]

We really need to smash the Dees this weekend.
I won't be happy with a mediocre performance from us.

 

[Handsuper47]

As long as we can get the 4 points and no injuries, I really don't care how much we win by.

 

[Jozzy]

Would have given Cotch another week but knowing him there's no way he's missing a game more than he has to, really hoping Arnott plays.

 

[Tigers_fan24]

Would have given Cotch another week but knowing him there's no way he's missing a game more than he has to, really hoping Arnott plays.

Needs to get a game b4 the next couple of weeks bigger ones imo. If he's healthy put him in so he can get a feel of the footy.

 

[Tigers_fan24]

I hope dea or arnott come up, just for something new. I think white has just about had his fair share of goes

 

[exceptional design]

Regardless of the opinions of others, I would really like to see Arnott or Edwards play, but not both.
Good to reward performance, good to keep the pressure on others.
Very good that at least one more player won't be thinking anything other than quarter by quarter of good footy.
That combines with Big O, Vlastuin, Nahas (if he plays), Ellis also putting in big efforts to try to cement their place, should see us with a big effort and hopefully big win.

 

[exceptional design]

And of course Cotchin back hungry after a week off.

 

[exceptional design]

And of course Foley's 2nd week - all make for a no complacency!

 

[tigs2010]

Regardless of the opinions of others, I would really like to see Arnott or Edwards play, but not both.
Good to reward performance, good to keep the pressure on others.
Very good that at least one more player won't be thinking anything other than quarter by quarter of good footy.
That combines with Big O, Vlastuin, Nahas (if he plays), Ellis also putting in big efforts to try to cement their place, should see us with a big effort and hopefully big win.

Despite what I said about Arnot I'd be happy to see him get a crack. I do expect that he'll push the boundaries of suspension which tbh won't affect us at this stage of his career but he will need to learn to reign himself in because I do believe he can be a very good footballer for us. But he'll be no use on the sidelines if he gets rubbed out all the time.

 

[Morro]

Hero?

You had your opinion on Edwards, so I had mine on you.

What makes you the Aaron Edwards expert? You've watched the majority of his career closely I take it

I suggest you keep your opinion on posters to yourself. Going the poster isn't acceptable.

Thank you.

 

[SteveRFC]

I suggest keeping you keep your opinion on posters to yourself. Going the poster isn't acceptable.

Thank you.

Your welcome

 

[Morro]

Your welcome

No, YOU'RE welcome.

Now play nice with others my man.