Rnd 17 Trades

[cat on acid]

What do people think of Sylvia? Thinking of trading him for Horseley for the fwd/mid link.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Makes me feel a little better, im sitting 6th with just the 1 trade left but that may be 1 more than a few im battling with!

Well done! I hope you pull it off.........the Supercoach title that is.

All the best.

My aim is for top 500, currently at 1,600.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

HI All

Hoping for some advice. Currently ranked 336 with 3 trades remaining

View attachment 1677

Considering the following moves this week

McDonald, Horsley out
Goodes/Beams, Baguley in

This will give me MPP access from my DEF to MID and MID to FWD, which i don't have now. I'm not sure whether to bring in Beams or Goodes, as I have a hunch that Goodes could fire now, and that will leave me with around $150k in the bank. Beams is hard to resist though, but Pies have a tough draw.

Plan is to have Cloke on the bench when Franklin gets back, as I'm bound to have injuries with 7 rounds to go.

I'm hoping against hope that I have no injury in my ruck, and if not, the last trade will be used to upgrade Sam Shaw to Heath Shaw (if I bought Goodes), or perhaps bring in Pendles or Swan if any of my mids fail to fire (they haven't yet)

Any thoughts appreciated

Downgrade McDonald to a forward/mid and upgrade Adams to beams.

 

[chewysnake]

My aim is for top 500, currently at 1,600.[/quote]

Well done! I hope you pull it off.........the Supercoach title that is.

All the best.

My aim is for top 500, currently at 1,600.

Bahahahaha,thanks Moony. I usually save trades and come home in a flurry so hopefully you're in that position this year.
Just comes down to those dicey decisions from here.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

My aim is for top 500, currently at 1,600.

Bahahahaha,thanks Moony. I usually save trades and come home in a flurry so hopefully you're in that position this year.
Just comes down to those dicey decisions from here.[/quote]

Not many trades. I was 300 odd before the byes, and they shot me in the foot. I have a side full of Guns now, although now it all comes down to a bit of luck on the injury/suspension front and i may be ok. Not trading Waters has helped.

 

[Tigey]

Really stumped on what to do

6 trades left with 50k in the bank - Sitting 5th in my cash league, playing 9th/16th/8th in the final rounds and team looks like this

Def:Goddard/Birchall/Broughton/Carrazzo/Lake/R.ShawM.Clarke/S.Shaw/Ellis
Mid: Gazza/JPK/Pendles/Bartel/Priddis/Cotchin/Gibson/Trelor
Ruck: Maric/Jacobs/Redden/Campbell
Fwds: Pav/Sidey/Goodes/Danger/Zorko/Martin/Harvey/Porps/Pfeiffer

Really unsure on how many trades I should keep up the sleeve until finals

Options are -
1. No trades - Take a donut this week for my back half - then next week downgrade Pfeiffer/Trelor and upgrade Ellis/Clarke/Broughton to a Deledio/Scotland (6 trades left for next week - safety incase of injuries this week)
2. Straight swap Broughton to Yarran the next week look at downgrade Pfeiffer/Trelor and upgrade Ellis/Clarke/Broughton to a Deledio/Scotland (4trades left next week)
3 Straight swap Broughton to Baugley - Next week upgrade a Def(Clarke/Ellis) to Deledio or Porp to Franklin when he returns

Please help

 

[tubes82]

Mohr or Sam Shaw --> Carazzo?

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Mohr or Sam Shaw --> Carazzo?

Mohr.

 

[Pessimistic]

Finally Ditched Cloke, all the best Travis !

4 trades left so I'll hold my powder now

 

[Spider Eater]

Having a change of heart at the moment and thinking of leaving Giles in for 1 more week (i know he has a high BE)

As i will have a 0 in the forward line this week am now thinking of getting rid of Dickson.
Possible trade in targets are:
Rioli
Roughead
Robinson
O'Keefe
Goodes

Sway me one way or another? Or should i ignore my thoughts and stick with Jacobs

The positive with J Roughead is that in future weeks you can upgrade/downgrade Giles to a forward making Roughlove your second ruck.

 

[TheNextBigThing]

Any advice would be greatly appreciated guys, my team is

Deledio, Hurn, Burchall, Broughton, Carrazzo, Goddard, Spurr (S.Shaw, Wilkes)

Ablett, Swallow, Rockliff, Swan, Pendlebury, Priddis (Crozier, T.Mitchell)

Cox, Giles (Redden, Campbell)

Dangerfield, Beams, Chapman, Goodes, Martin, Zorko, Franklin (Smedts, Sexton)

3 trades left and about 90k

Im thinking of going Smedts to Couch and then upgrading one of Giles or Broughton, obviously this will only leave me with one trade but I really need a couple more wins in 2 of my leagues so pretty much have to go for broke.

Thinking either Broughton to Shaw or Giles to NN/Jacobs/McEvoy/Goldy

 

[thelikelylad]

With Mohr, Clarke and now S Shaw out I'm left with a donut in defense.
With 6 trades left should I hold on or trade say Mohr and be left with 5 trades?

 

[rocker_oz33]

Any advice would be greatly appreciated guys, my team is

Deledio, Hurn, Burchall, Broughton, Carrazzo, Goddard, Spurr (S.Shaw, Wilkes)

Ablett, Swallow, Rockliff, Swan, Pendlebury, Priddis (Crozier, T.Mitchell)

Cox, Giles (Redden, Campbell)

Dangerfield, Beams, Chapman, Goodes, Martin, Zorko, Franklin (Smedts, Sexton)

3 trades left and about 90k

Im thinking of going Smedts to Couch and then upgrading one of Giles or Broughton, obviously this will only leave me with one trade but I really need a couple more wins in 2 of my leagues so pretty much have to go for broke.

I am thinking of doing the same trades quiet hard this one will giles or broughts come back strong and start
scoring.

 

[TheNextBigThing]

I am thinking of doing the same trades quiet hard this one will giles or broughts come back strong and start
scoring.

Yeah its tough, all year I was thinking Giles would be a keeper but he has dropped right away, and you have no idea how Broughton will score because you don't know how Ross Lyon is going to play him.

 

[rocker_oz33]

With Mohr, Clarke and now S Shaw out I'm left with a donut in defense.
With 6 trades left should I hold on or trade say Mohr and be left with 5 trades?

Really depends if you are in a strong spot to win or strong spot on the ladder.The young ess rookie baguey(spelling) is prob your best bet,clarke has high b/e not sure on the other 2.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Yeah its tough, all year I was thinking Giles would be a keeper but he has dropped right away, and you have no idea how Broughton will score because you don't know how Ross Lyon is going to play him.

And to sink the boot in they drop redden after a good showing/scoring last week.I'm thinking either giles to macvoy or broughts to lids(been lids less all year silly move) but macvoy seems a great POD.But broughts scores V's lids scores might be higher than giles V macvoy.Who were you going to trade in?

 

[TheNextBigThing]

And to sink the boot in they drop redden after a good showing/scoring last week.I'm thinking either giles to macvoy or broughts to lids(been lids less all year silly move) but macvoy seems a great POD.But broughts scores V's lids scores might be higher than giles V macvoy.Who were you going to trade in?

Thinking either Broughton to Shaw or Giles to NN/Jacobs/McEvoy/Goldy

 

[Knighta21]

For all those with Broughton, I'd probly be trading him. Just seems Lyon is never going to play him in the right spot.

For me this week however, I just went A black > Couch which allows me to swap him with Zorko in the middle to get cover for Buddy.

Edit: And leaves me sitting pretty with 1 trade left

 

[Judd_Magic]

I have a donut this week due to Broughton, S.Shaw and Darley all being out.

Should I trade this week to avoid a donut and if so who do I trade out?

I have one trade and $196,300 in the kitty.

Thoughts?

 

[vjknight]

Edit: And leaves me sitting pretty scared with 1 trade left

join the club

 

[vjknight]

I have a donut this week due to Broughton, S.Shaw and Darley all being out.

Should I trade this week to avoid a donut and if so who do I trade out?

I also have $196,300 in the kitty.

Thoughts?

"wont anyone think of the finals"

 

[Judd_Magic]

"wont anyone think of the finals"

Ha! Ha! Yeah guess I should wait. Not good at the waiting game am I.

 

[vjknight]

Ha! Ha! Yeah guess I should wait. Not good at the waiting game am I.

wait til round 20 when fyfe is back to $400k

 

[Ed D]

wait til round 20 when fyfe is back to $400k

The only way he'll get that low is if he spuds it up on his return, and if he does that you probably wouldn't want him. The last game he played he scored 98.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I have a donut this week due to Broughton, S.Shaw and Darley all being out.

Should I trade this week to avoid a donut and if so who do I trade out?

I have one trade and $196,300 in the kitty.

Thoughts?

Darely out aswell it just keeps getting better and better Oh now l will wait for spurr to be sub something crazy rossy will do.