Prediction Round 12, 2024: Changes vs St Kilda

[stallon]

Want Yeo/Reid/Ginbey/Kelly in CBAs
Trew as far as I know sucks at anything other than CBAs, and hes not ahead of those other 4. Dont see how he would be an upgrade to anybody off a HFF or wing where he would inevitably end up for 60% of the game.
Even Sheed is a better HFF than Trew.
Just because we re-rookied someone doesnt mean they have to get a game, the club obviously knows a lot about Trew by having him on the list for the last few years so youd expect theyd know more than some random punters on the internet. If hes not getting a game its for a reason.

More than likely they only re-rookied him as emergency back up incase injuries were a disaster again

 

[mat11]

Want Yeo/Reid/Ginbey/Kelly in CBAs
Trew as far as I know sucks at anything other than CBAs, and hes not ahead of those other 4. Dont see how he would be an upgrade to anybody off a HFF or wing where he would inevitably end up for 60% of the game.
Even Sheed is a better HFF than Trew.
Just because we re-rookied someone doesnt mean they have to get a game, the club obviously knows a lot about Trew by having him on the list for the last few years so youd expect theyd know more than some random punters on the internet. If hes not getting a game its for a reason.

More than likely they only re-rookied him as emergency back up incase injuries were a disaster again

After that big loss surely sheed for trew or culley is being discussed tho. Trew was saved by the bell because we didn't land dev

 

[stallon]

After that big loss surely sheed for trew or culley is being discussed tho. Trew was saved by the bell because we didn't land dev

Youre not taking out Yeo/Reid/Ginbey/Kelly after that. We literally beat the Melbourne midfield just the week before, the midfield cant be that bad that we have to resort to playing guys who are 99% delisted at the end of the year.
Sheed out surely, but thats not really Trews role. More than likely Petch comes in as a straight swap for Sheed anyway

 

[mat11]

Youre not taking out Yeo/Reid/Ginbey/Kelly after that. We literally beat the Melbourne midfield just the week before, the midfield cant be that bad that we have to resort to playing guys who are 99% delisted at the end of the year.
Sheed out surely, but thats not really Trews role. More than likely Petch comes in as a straight swap for Sheed anyway

Wouldn't touch yeo/reid/ginbey/kelly was more thinking JJ take witherdens spot because he done a calf and culley take that fwd flank and then swap trew for sheed for negating role I'd assume he'd attend a few cba's

 

[stallon]

Wouldn't touch yeo/reid/ginbey/kelly was more thinking JJ take witherdens spot because he done a calf and culley take that fwd flank and then swap trew for sheed for negating role I'd assume he'd attend a few cba's

I really dislike the idea people have of taking out speed and putting in slow players. JJ was brought in to cover for Petch while injured. Thats still Petchs spot so he will come in if fit(sounds like he probably is fit).

Cant just stack the team with inside mids because theyre playing well in the WAFL, need to retain some sort of structure.
One of them for Sheed sounds ok, feels better to put a more outside leaning player in that role though, its basically Long/Brockmans role.
Give it to Dewar imo and get a different sub

In my mind Culley is waiting for one of our 4 main onballers to cop an injury or he has to fight for a spot as a 4th tall forward with Darling or Maric

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

I have a single seat available for the Saints game. Section 148 row 19

PM me if interested. Not charging if an Eagle fan

You will have the chance to listen to Keys game day live commentary

 

[Biggie]

 

[Alesana]

Happy to see how BWilliams goes as a forward for a game or two if Flynn is in. But if he's not having an impact I'd rather see JWilliams play the backup ruck role which doesn't really leave a spot in the team for BWilliams and then I don't know what they do with him moving forward.

 

[southcoast]

BOM MetEye now suggesting rain will be delayed until after the game.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[DanWCE]

BOM MetEye now suggesting rain will be delayed until after the game.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

Gotta get off to a good start then, because it looks like an almighty downpour is arriving when the game is wrapping up

 

[kaiserchief13]

Happy to see how BWilliams goes as a forward for a game or two if Flynn is in. But if he's not having an impact I'd rather see JWilliams play the backup ruck role which doesn't really leave a spot in the team for BWilliams and then I don't know what they do with him moving forward.

Trade for Baker

 

[DickDunn]

Wet weather footy, Gaff time!

 

[Quinz]

Just here for the melts. Gaff and Sheed and no Culley Trew or Hall make fans something something.

 

[SumaGodCoach]

Dewar omitted for Gaff. Its melting time.

 

[Boohemian]

Gaff is so slow that it looks like he's wading through mud, but that doesn't make him a wet weather specialist.

Melting like an icecream left out on the kitchen benchtop.

 

[KBLT]

Maybe Gaffy is our strongest swimmer?

 

[Eaglemaniac]

Those changes make no sense for dry weather Footy, let alone wet weather Footy. Our selection Integrity does not exist.

 

[random260]

34 possesion is nothing to scoff at though for gaff

 

[Spod]

Gaff in over Trew or Culley while Sheed is still in the team is an interesting call. On WAFL form he probably has earnt a recall but so have the others.

Trew and Culley both emergencies.

 

[mitchzz]

Wtf

Wet weather game. I guess Gaff is a good tackler

 

[Shuestar13]

Oh dear…

 

[Biggie]

 

[squashface]

Jesus.

Gaff and Sheed.
No Culley or Trew
Dewar and Jilliams dropped.

Might skip this one tbh

 

[Bender_]

 

[Spod]

Also bench of Gaff, Sheed, Petch, Maric and Witho - Petch seems like the only reasonable sub option there.