Round 16 Trades

[Abstract]

Thoughts on Darcy as a R3 without a DPP link? Setup would be Gawn, Witts, Darcy with Nank at F6 and D Cameron at F8.

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

Problem: 3 trades left. $21,500. Have NRoo stinking up my FWD line. Have Ryder in R2. Want Gawn. Want Witherden to provide a link to Lloyd (SS)/Hibberd (NM) both currently sitting in DEF.

Solution: Trade Mountford to Witherden, NRoo to Gawn via Ryder.

Outcome: 1 trade left. Profit.

Question: Would you do it?

 

[Glorin]

Thoughts on Darcy as a R3 without a DPP link? Setup would be Gawn, Witts, Darcy with Nank at F6 and D Cameron at F8.

Unless you have a heap of trades, not sure its worth it. Just makes you less flexible. I would be trying to get another fwd and getting Nank to f7.

 

[SC fish]

So I'm down to one trade left and I need to get rid of Beams.

I've got $529,200 to spend

I've sorted players by their 3 round average and here's who I'm considering.

Callan Ward - $512,200. 3 Rd Avg - 120.0
Lachie Whitfield - $524,900. 3 Rd Avg - 119.3
Jarryd Lyons - $519,600. 3 Rd Avg - 115.0
Andrew Gaff - $514,900. 3 Rd Avg - 114.3
Luke Parker - $510,400. 3 Rd Avg - 112.3
Jack Billings - $525,600. 3 Rd Avg - 109.3
Brandon Ellis - $524,100. 3 Rd Avg - 108.3

After that there's Robbie Gray, Brad Hill, Jobe Watson, Dom Sheed, Steele Sidebottom and Mark Blicavs who all have a 3 Rd Avg of 100 or more and are within my price range.

I'm leaning mostly towards Ward, Lyons and Parker. Although Whitfield has the highest overall average which is 104.7 while everyone else's overall average is 96.1 or less.

Any advice would be much appreciated!

Insert "Paaarker" pic here

 

[CaptainHowdy87]

So I'm down to one trade left and I need to get rid of Beams.

I've got $529,200 to spend

I've sorted players by their 3 round average and here's who I'm considering.

Callan Ward - $512,200. 3 Rd Avg - 120.0
Lachie Whitfield - $524,900. 3 Rd Avg - 119.3
Jarryd Lyons - $519,600. 3 Rd Avg - 115.0
Andrew Gaff - $514,900. 3 Rd Avg - 114.3
Luke Parker - $510,400. 3 Rd Avg - 112.3
Jack Billings - $525,600. 3 Rd Avg - 109.3
Brandon Ellis - $524,100. 3 Rd Avg - 108.3

After that there's Robbie Gray, Brad Hill, Jobe Watson, Dom Sheed, Steele Sidebottom and Mark Blicavs who all have a 3 Rd Avg of 100 or more and are within my price range.

I'm leaning mostly towards Ward, Lyons and Parker. Although Whitfield has the highest overall average which is 104.7 while everyone else's overall average is 96.1 or less.

Any advice would be much appreciated!

2 votes for Parker so far.

Someone else just suggested to me I hold my trades for this week and wait for Selwood to drop in price. Will Selwood drop to less than $529,200 by next week or the week after?

 

[Goody1971]

2 votes for Parker so far.

Someone else just suggested to me I hold my trades for this week and wait for Selwood to drop in price. Will Selwood drop to less than $529,200 by next week or the week after?

I think Selwood is on track for sub $500k over the next week or 2

 

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

Bring in either Yeo or Gawn?

 

[qarocks]

is anyone else worried selwood will be affected the by the head knock for a few more weeks, even if he plays?
i am slightly worried, and his output drops, his price will drop so much he is untradable.

 

[hawkermitch]

I'm bringing in Darcy - Freo. Have Ryder in forwards right now as well as Nank & Witts as R1 & R2 - getting rid of Pruess on bench for Darcy.

Not sure who goes out but am bringing in Witherden as he's going up over 80k and has D/M as a good bench cover with js.

 

[The_Steadier]

Bring in either Yeo or Gawn?

Yeo fo shizzle, he's a must have fwd.

Gawn is value but not "must have"

 

[dash555]

10 Trades 50K
DEF: Doch, Shaw, Adams, Tuohy, Newmann, Hibberd (Melb) (Ryan, Hibberd - Nth)
MID: Danger, Pendles, Neale, Fyfe, JPK, Merrett, Bont, Pepper (S Selwood, Cousins, Berry)
RUCK: Sandi, Martin (Strnadica)
FWD: Dahl, Nank, Macrae, Lynch, Buddy, Greenwood (Parsons, Eddy)
Thoughts for this week?

 

[GAsnr]

10 Trades 50K
DEF: Doch, Shaw, Adams, Tuohy, Newmann, Hibberd (Melb) (Ryan, Hibberd - Nth)
MID: Danger, Pendles, Neale, Fyfe, JPK, Merrett, Bont, Pepper (S Selwood, Cousins, Berry)
RUCK: Sandi, Martin (Strnadica)
FWD: Dahl, Nank, Macrae, Lynch, Buddy, Greenwood (Parsons, Eddy)
Thoughts for this week?

Berry and SPP to best mid and rookie

 

[SC fish]

First trade Stewart to Witherden.

Second trade Roughead to Gawn. I might reconsider if Greene and/or Witts is OUT

 

[dash555]

Berry and SPP to best mid and rookie

Should I think about Sandi replacement or go for the mids.

 

[Judd_Magic]

First trade Stewart to Witherden.

Second trade Roughead to Gawn. I might reconsider if Greene and/or Witts is OUT

I'm getting nervous with all this Witts shoulder/being out innuendo.

 

[GAsnr]

Should I think about Sandi replacement or go for the mids.

Oops my bad, missed Sandi. Go for Sandi replacement, berry to witherton

 

[Suns of Anarchy]

Problem: 3 trades left. $21,500. Have NRoo stinking up my FWD line. Have Ryder in R2. Want Gawn. Want Witherden to provide a link to Lloyd (SS)/Hibberd (NM) both currently sitting in DEF.

Solution: Trade Mountford to Witherden, NRoo to Gawn via Ryder.

Outcome: 1 trade left. Profit.

Question: Would you do it?

Who is your R3?

 

[The Lemon]

Insert "Paaarker" pic here

 

[Huttabito]

I'm getting nervous with all this Witts shoulder/being out innuendo.

I think as long as you have 3 trades left you should be right

 

[big_bazza]

have got 2 options this week, both involve bringing in a ruckman the question is which one.
I have 6 trades left and 294k in the bank

Option A: 2 trades, D.Cameron > Hodor and then J.Stewart > fwd premo.

Option B: 1 trade, J.Stewart > ruck premo probably Gawn Via nank, leaving Nank as my ruck cover in the forward line

Option C: no trades, give my new potential ruckmen another week to show me who looks good.

Im thinking option B atm mainly due to the lack of Premo forwards and because it will leave me with 1 extra trade.

 

[toxic]

Yeo fo shizzle, he's a must have fwd.

Gawn is value but not "must have"

Fwiw i see the exact opposite

Gawn at his best is 15 points superior to any ruck

 

[big_bazza]

Fwiw i see the exact opposite

Gawn at his best is 15 points superior to any ruck

I guess this is the problem some have with bringing big Maxy in, how much of his best will we see this year?

 

[toxic]

I guess this is the problem some have with bringing big Maxy in, how much of his best will we see this year?

Removing his injury game isnt he averaging 113+ or something?

 

[big_bazza]

Removing his injury game isnt he averaging 113+ or something?

Yeah i mean after his time off with injuries though and the fact that their main couple of mids are out i can see why some people are sceptical. I do agree with you that at his best hes a 15+ player than any other ruck but it might take him a few weeks to do so.

 

[gutsroy]

Think I'll skip Witherden after all.
Gawn good scoring off fairly conservative TOG = upside.
Gawn draw and midfield injuries = waters muddied.