JuddgementDay
Brownlow Medallist
Dont get that flog. I've kept him for too long before i've traded him. Total waste & he will find a reason to disappoint you
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Round 18 trades
- Thread starter big bootaaaaah
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Jun 7, 2011
- 5,167
- 13,520
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Don't do it man.
stevebbb
Brownlow Medallist
- May 21, 2013
- 23,659
- 60,861
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Fluminense; Blue Jays
I didn't start with him so he hasn't burnt me at all
thoughts he'd pump out some 80/90s playing mid, but I just had a look and he's a huge spud, even playing pure mid lol
thanks lads
Is Rory Sloane worth the risk?
No response
So done some further analysis myself...Removed the following from my shortlist:
- Jelwood (can't afford and likely to not be able to afford next week either)
- Coniglio (too many GWS players in my team: Shaw & Ward)
- Priddis (injury cloud and under performing)
That leaves..
- Rocky... has Essendon, Port Adel, Adelaide, Carlton, Geelong for the run home. Has averaged 116sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
- Gray... has GWS, Brisbane, Syd, Mel, Adel for the run home. Has averaged 117sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
Leaning towards Gray. He has three top 8 teams in his next 5 games, but has performed well against Sydney (126avg last 3 games) and loves the Adel showdown (128 avg last 3 games). With Port contending for finals, I don't see him slowing down. Plus, Rockys injuries have burned me many times in the past.
Definitely overthinking this, just need to make myself feel better about not getting Jelwood
tl;dr - Robbie Gray or Rockliff as final mid premo? Thinking Gray.
Last edited:
No response
Removed the following from my shortlist:
- Jelwood (can't afford and likely to not be able to afford next week either)
- Coniglio (too many GWS players in my team: Shaw & Ward)
- Priddis (injury cloud and under performing)
That leaves..
- Rocky... has Essendon, Port Adel, Adelaide, Carlton, Geelong for the run home. Has averaged 116sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
- Gray... has GWS, Brisbane, Syd, Mel, Adel for the run home. Has averaged 117sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
Leaning towards Gray. He has three top 8 teams in his next 5 games, but has performed well against Sydney (126avg last 3 games) and loves the Adel showdown (128 avg last 3 games). With Port contending for finals, I don't see him slowing down. Plus, Rockys injuries have burned me many times in the past.
Definitely overthinking this, just need to make myself feel better about not getting Jelwood
tl;dr - Robbie Gray or Rockliff as final mid premo? Thinking Gray.
Both good picks but Rocky has the higher ceiling which could win you a final.
No response
Removed the following from my shortlist:
- Jelwood (can't afford and likely to not be able to afford next week either)
- Coniglio (too many GWS players in my team: Shaw & Ward)
- Priddis (injury cloud and under performing)
That leaves..
- Rocky... has Essendon, Port Adel, Adelaide, Carlton, Geelong for the run home. Has averaged 116sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
- Gray... has GWS, Brisbane, Syd, Mel, Adel for the run home. Has averaged 117sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
Leaning towards Gray. He has three top 8 teams in his next 5 games, but has performed well against Sydney (126avg last 3 games) and loves the Adel showdown (128 avg last 3 games). With Port contending for finals, I don't see him slowing down. Plus, Rockys injuries have burned me many times in the past.
Definitely overthinking this, just need to make myself feel better about not getting Jelwood
tl;dr - Robbie Gray or Rockliff as final mid premo? Thinking Gray.
Priddis underperforming???
Tonned up 8/9 including 110, 122, 126 last 3 weeks & barring the one mare where Mitch Robbo towelled him (and he's not on his pat there) he's been rock solid!
Very true, now we're back at square one
Ah very true, rushed analysis there/bad statement. Had a slow start to the year (after the Brisbane game). Main concern was the corky he got on the weekend. Probably should chuck him back in the mix.
All good picks I guess, minor difference in the end.
gutsroy
Brownlow Medallist
Got to think some more about what's retro, struggled a bit for inspiration tonight...
Monya Meow Meow
Club Legend
- Apr 24, 2013
- 1,557
- 873
- AFL Club
- Carlton
No response
Removed the following from my shortlist:
- Jelwood (can't afford and likely to not be able to afford next week either)
- Coniglio (too many GWS players in my team: Shaw & Ward)
- Priddis (injury cloud and under performing)
That leaves..
- Rocky... has Essendon, Port Adel, Adelaide, Carlton, Geelong for the run home. Has averaged 116sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
- Gray... has GWS, Brisbane, Syd, Mel, Adel for the run home. Has averaged 117sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
Leaning towards Gray. He has three top 8 teams in his next 5 games, but has performed well against Sydney (126avg last 3 games) and loves the Adel showdown (128 avg last 3 games). With Port contending for finals, I don't see him slowing down. Plus, Rockys injuries have burned me many times in the past.
Definitely overthinking this, just need to make myself feel better about not getting Jelwood
tl;dr - Robbie Gray or Rockliff as final mid premo? Thinking Gray.
If you think Rocky's body can hold up until season's end, grab him due to his higher ceiling
6 trades, 63k left with these bunch of faults:
Clearly my biggest issue is Deledio who I highly doubt will play this week. His injury smells suspiciously like a one week which turns into a few. I'm going for overall so can't really afford to play a gimp on the field even if it is SP Menafault. Looking at burning 2 trades which isn't exactly ideal:
Collins to Ubergang
SP Menfault to Howe
Leaves me with 100k and DPP cover for DEF/FWD. Howe covers Deledio until he's back and then Yeobot becomes a D7 loophole option. Other open is just turfing Deledio to Buddy and sitting at 5 trades.
Clearly my biggest issue is Deledio who I highly doubt will play this week. His injury smells suspiciously like a one week which turns into a few. I'm going for overall so can't really afford to play a gimp on the field even if it is SP Menafault. Looking at burning 2 trades which isn't exactly ideal:
Collins to Ubergang
SP Menfault to Howe
Leaves me with 100k and DPP cover for DEF/FWD. Howe covers Deledio until he's back and then Yeobot becomes a D7 loophole option. Other open is just turfing Deledio to Buddy and sitting at 5 trades.
- Feb 11, 2016
- 1,030
- 2,404
- AFL Club
- Richmond
I think you're right about Lids.6 trades, 63k left with these bunch of faults:
Clearly my biggest issue is Deledio who I highly doubt will play this week. His injury smells suspiciously like a one week which turns into a few. I'm going for overall so can't really afford to play a gimp on the field even if it is SP Menafault. Looking at burning 2 trades which isn't exactly ideal:
Collins to Ubergang
SP Menfault to Howe
Leaves me with 100k and DPP cover for DEF/FWD. Howe covers Deledio until he's back and then Yeobot becomes a D7 loophole option. Other open is just turfing Deledio to Buddy and sitting at 5 trades.
The trades make sense provided Howe retains his form. Would give you decent cover DEF and FWD.
- Thread starter
- #240
Rocky. I believe the disturbance in the force over at Brissy is on the mend, so should start to knuckle down with good scores.No response
Removed the following from my shortlist:
- Jelwood (can't afford and likely to not be able to afford next week either)
- Coniglio (too many GWS players in my team: Shaw & Ward)
- Priddis (injury cloud and under performing)
That leaves..
- Rocky... has Essendon, Port Adel, Adelaide, Carlton, Geelong for the run home. Has averaged 116sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
- Gray... has GWS, Brisbane, Syd, Mel, Adel for the run home. Has averaged 117sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
Leaning towards Gray. He has three top 8 teams in his next 5 games, but has performed well against Sydney (126avg last 3 games) and loves the Adel showdown (128 avg last 3 games). With Port contending for finals, I don't see him slowing down. Plus, Rockys injuries have burned me many times in the past.
Definitely overthinking this, just need to make myself feel better about not getting Jelwood
tl;dr - Robbie Gray or Rockliff as final mid premo? Thinking Gray.
vanders
Brownlow Medallist
I have Barlow and 3 trades left. If I upgrade him to a MID I have no DPP and an iffy bench. I don't have enough cash to get Pendles though, so I'm using 2 trades to sure up by team a bit.
Kade Stewart to Naismith via Phillips gives me a DPP on my MID bench and a little extra cash. It also gives me DPP from FWD/Ruck in case Gawn or Goldy miss.
Then went Barlow to Pendles. This is my team now:
Kade Stewart to Naismith via Phillips gives me a DPP on my MID bench and a little extra cash. It also gives me DPP from FWD/Ruck in case Gawn or Goldy miss.
Then went Barlow to Pendles. This is my team now:
Shit, based on what lol? Brisbane are cooked
- Thread starter
- #243
There was a lot of media hype about rocky leaving and not getting along with players and Leppitsch etc
OUT: Zahacancer, Collins
IN: S.Mitchell, Broad.
I'm probably getting caught up in all the Mitchell love in the media this week but jeez he seems back to his best.
The trades do cull me of a playing bench spot, unless Broad gets back in? What are the chances?
Leaves me with 2 trades and a bench of:
DEF: Broad, Lee
MID: Stewart, Trengove, Phillips
RUC: Grimley
FWD: Cox, Silvagni
Silvagni the only one getting games atm! How did it come to this?
IN: S.Mitchell, Broad.
I'm probably getting caught up in all the Mitchell love in the media this week but jeez he seems back to his best.
The trades do cull me of a playing bench spot, unless Broad gets back in? What are the chances?
Leaves me with 2 trades and a bench of:
DEF: Broad, Lee
MID: Stewart, Trengove, Phillips
RUC: Grimley
FWD: Cox, Silvagni
Silvagni the only one getting games atm! How did it come to this?
toxic
Hall of Famer
No response
Removed the following from my shortlist:
- Jelwood (can't afford and likely to not be able to afford next week either)
- Coniglio (too many GWS players in my team: Shaw & Ward)
- Priddis (injury cloud and under performing)
That leaves..
- Rocky... has Essendon, Port Adel, Adelaide, Carlton, Geelong for the run home. Has averaged 116sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
- Gray... has GWS, Brisbane, Syd, Mel, Adel for the run home. Has averaged 117sc against these 5 teams in their past 3 encounters.
Leaning towards Gray. He has three top 8 teams in his next 5 games, but has performed well against Sydney (126avg last 3 games) and loves the Adel showdown (128 avg last 3 games). With Port contending for finals, I don't see him slowing down. Plus, Rockys injuries have burned me many times in the past.
Definitely overthinking this, just need to make myself feel better about not getting Jelwood
tl;dr - Robbie Gray or Rockliff as final mid premo? Thinking Gray.
Gray
- Thread starter
- #246
Leaves me with 2 trades and a bench of:
Silvagni the only one getting games atm! How did it come to this?
Pocket Aces
Club Legend
OUT: Zahacancer, Collins
IN: S.Mitchell, Broad.
I'm probably getting caught up in all the Mitchell love in the media this week but jeez he seems back to his best.
The trades do cull me of a playing bench spot, unless Broad gets back in? What are the chances?
Leaves me with 2 trades and a bench of:
DEF: Broad, Lee
MID: Stewart, Trengove, Phillips
RUC: Grimley
FWD: Cox, Silvagni
Silvagni the only one getting games atm! How did it come to this?
Do Cox > Naismith and SMitchell in if you cant afford him there are plenty of options in the 500-540k range.
Gives you a playing bench of Collins, Naismith & Silvagni.
HEYTRUEROO
Team Captain
- Jun 16, 2016
- 449
- 640
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
First Trade: Barlow to Premo (Most likely Bontempelli).
Second Trade Option (a): Cox to Naismith - Keeps dpp cover FWD/RUC in case Goldy is rested. Frees up some extra cash.
Second Trade Option (b): Jansen to Hammelmann via Phillips dpp - keeps dpp link between MID/FWD. Opens dpp link between DEF/FWD w/ Adams.
Not sure which of the two second trade options to go with. Desperately need Lids to get up this week otherwise will be playing Phillips/Cox/Naismith/Hammelmann on the field...
Any advice fellas?
Second Trade Option (a): Cox to Naismith - Keeps dpp cover FWD/RUC in case Goldy is rested. Frees up some extra cash.
Second Trade Option (b): Jansen to Hammelmann via Phillips dpp - keeps dpp link between MID/FWD. Opens dpp link between DEF/FWD w/ Adams.
Not sure which of the two second trade options to go with. Desperately need Lids to get up this week otherwise will be playing Phillips/Cox/Naismith/Hammelmann on the field...
Any advice fellas?
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...z/news-story/ea7075710d91308efd16dcbb1bda99cb
Even my non-playing rookies can't catch a break this year #burnthetrades
Even my non-playing rookies can't catch a break this year #burnthetrades
- Status
Similar threads
