Round 18 Trades

[Andrew Birch]

Most of obvious is to trade cogs to sloane. But feel 1 trade will not be enough to cover any potential donuts as the fwd line cover is looking shaky now.
im optimistic Logue and Duursma will be back this week. Hell even garner and Bewley could get another chance going by the team boards (i know means f all but still)

But 2 rookies on field means I will continue to slide in the rankings. I suppose 2 cracks at an ok rookie score in place of cogs aint bad.

I will prob just hold em to cover inevitable donuts.


View attachment 709603

Loopholing an M8 score out of Clarke/Duursma is no worse than having Brayshaw at M8

 

[Aishole]

Go Whitfield.

Don't listen to the pussies. He is a POD.

The best defender in the game is a POD.

And you don't want him?

God damn it Benno. I’d just about made up my mind now im ****ed again.

He isn’t too much of a POD, hes at 20%. He hasn’t gotten any attention from opposition yet, thats 100% going to change with no Kelly and Cogs. If those 2 were there i’d lock him in.

Im yet to see him perform with close attention. Im sure Collingwood will tag him this weekend. Maybe i hold off 1 week and see how he goes again. He will drop in price more also (150 BE)

 

[ubeaut]

Go Whitfield.

Don't listen to the pussies. He is a POD.

The best defender in the game is a POD.

And you don't want him?

I'm torn. You make great points. He is averaging something like 123 without the 2 injury affected scores. That's midfielder super premo numbers.
On the other hand the potential tag without Kelly or Cogs is a huge concern.
He's got Pies (Mayne or Greenwood?)
Swans (Hewett?)
Hawks (Howe?)
Port (Houston?)
Dogs probably no tag
Suns probably no tag

It's enough to put doubt into an otherwise no brainer
It's Whitfield vs Hurn for me

 

[Benno_900]

God damn it Benno. I’d just about made up my mind now im f’ed again.

He isn’t too much of a POD, hes at 20%. He hasn’t gotten any attention from opposition yet, thats 100% going to change with no Kelly and Cogs. If those 2 were there i’d lock him in.

Im yet to see him perform with close attention. Im sure Collingwood will tag him this weekend. Maybe i hold off 1 week and see how he goes again. He will drop in price more also (150 BE)

Only 3 in the top 100 own him.

6% of top 1000

 

[ubeaut]

God damn it Benno. I’d just about made up my mind now im f’ed again.

He isn’t too much of a POD, hes at 20%. He hasn’t gotten any attention from opposition yet, thats 100% going to change with no Kelly and Cogs. If those 2 were there i’d lock him in.

Im yet to see him perform with close attention. Im sure Collingwood will tag him this weekend. Maybe i hold off 1 week and see how he goes again. He will drop in price more also (150 BE)

I already held off a week and it cost me especially with Cogs going down. Had to field Anuuswerth and lost around 50 points. Would have cracked 2500 if I had traded in Whitfield or Hurn.
I'm chasing a top 1k finish I'm 2458 now after dropping 174 places
At this stage points worth more than any price drop. Other's may be in a different situation tho.

 

[BennyGan]

Possibly. Whitfield is a different player to Hurn though. He plays everywhere but the ruck, whereas Hurn stays back. Can Mayne go everywhere with him?

Maybe has done jobs on wingers too, Zac Williams is another player he could go to as well

 

[AFDogs]

I'm bringing in Wines. I've never felt so nervous in my life.

 

[Northernsoul74]

I'm bringing in Wines. I've never felt so nervous in my life.

He’s in doubt for this weekend.

 

[Gigantic]

**** it, gonna bring in Toby Greene

 

[Aishole]

Only 3 in the top 100 own him.

6% of top 1000

Error 504 - Information does not compute.

Please recalibrate information to match Pathetic state of Aishole , top 10k info only

 

[Jiska]

Got 5 left but waiting another week for Whitfield

 

[ubeaut]

Got 5 left but waiting another week for Whitfield

Reasoning behind waiting? Is it worth the 15-20k price drop?
Asking cos I also have 5 left and a defender premo to come in. Already regret waiting a week and losing 50 points playing Anooswerth

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Thoughts on JPK?

Only 4 scores under 100 with 2 being in the 90s and 7/8 tons have been 110+

$550k and looks fit, but with Sydney potentially out of finals, still he get rested end of season?

He won't get rested IMO, he has already missed some games and historically he starts the season a little patchy and finishes off strongly.

I'm considering him too.

 

[exit]

fu** it, gonna bring in Toby Greene

I've had him since he returned. It's a ride for sure.

Don't know whether you're gonna get a 60 or 130, injury or brain fart.

Never a dull moment.

 

[qqaaxx]

Overall % is misleading at this point especially for someone like Whitfield who were in a lot of starting teams. Only about 35k people still actually playing the game at this point. (I’m just estimating)

Trading Whitfield in, so can add one more to the top 100

 

[enobrien]

Only 3 in the top 100 own him.

6% of top 1000

That was before the weekend. 17 traded him in. 20 of the top 100 now, 20% of top 1k

 

[qqaaxx]

That was before the weekend. 17 traded him in. 20 of the top 100 now, 20% of top 1k

Or people who held him moved back up

 

[rocker_oz33]

What about treloar with no pendles?

Could a option.

I've never had Treloar before .Bit of a butcher of balls but gets enough of it.

 

[kane22]

5 trades remaining
I have 520k left for a forward not sure who to bring in
a) Billings due to St. Kilda having a very good run in and has a good ceiling.
b) Punchable, maybe he will get a good go in the midfield and is at a great value and allows me to get Whitfield next week. Billings doesn't.
c) Some other campaigner who undoubtely shit the bed and give me 60's like Cameron

 

[kane22]

I'm bringing in Wines. I've never felt so nervous in my life.

Oh wow thats a ballsy move. Good luck to ya. What average are you hoping for, 105?

 

[Benno_900]

That was before the weekend. 17 traded him in. 20 of the top 100 now, 20% of top 1k

Premos with higher ownership...

Lloyd
Laird
Sicily
Hurn
Williams
Stewart
Ryan
Houli

Still a POD

 

[Ace Cannon]

Just need a hand guys on best way to get Dunkley in . Just going for league glory . Been in this position many times over the last 15 years and screw it up over and over . Thanks .

View attachment 709837

 

[JuddgementDay]

Premos with higher ownership...

Lloyd
Laird
Sicily
Hurn
Williams
Stewart
Ryan
Houli

Still a POD

You are very good at counting

 

[stevebbb]

Speaking of PODs, can we reopen the PODs thread? Would be interesting to see who has PODs and how they're ranked. Would assume most of the top teams have very few PODs.

2019 PODs

Couldn’t see a thread about the PODs in Supercoach 2019. At the moment, without knowing the exact %’s of individual players picked in teams I’d say my PODs would be Luke Ryan, Angus Brayshaw, Tim Taranto and Brandan Parfitt. I also have Matt Crouch but not sure if he’s a POD or not.

www.bigfooty.com

Andrew Birch

 

[vast]

Speaking of PODs, can we reopen the PODs thread? Would be interesting to see who has PODs and how they're ranked. Would assume most of the top teams have very few PODs.

2019 PODs

Couldn’t see a thread about the PODs in Supercoach 2019. At the moment, without knowing the exact %’s of individual players picked in teams I’d say my PODs would be Luke Ryan, Angus Brayshaw, Tim Taranto and Brandan Parfitt. I also have Matt Crouch but not sure if he’s a POD or not.

www.bigfooty.com

Andrew Birch

Open the 2020 thread