Game Day Round 2 2025: Fremantle Dockers Vs. Sydney Swans

Remove this Banner Ad

Brodie would of been better option over Erasmus.

Brodie is the type that goes up a level when playing in the big time. Erasmus goes to water. Just my opinion.

Agreed. Tougher around the contest. Experience playing a big part.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

More like Freo can't hurt me if I expect nothing!

Watch later games from 2022. Teams worked out Brodie's spots and started intercepting his hand balls. Brodie - effective handball to the outside of a contest = not a good player. And he hasn't seemed to work very hard at peel to improve anything so... Enjoy being the king of Mandurah I guess
Nah all good mate. I misread it.

I like where your heads at, rather be wrong and get the win than be right and get beaten by 20 goals.

Unless of course you are right and we get done by 20 goals....

Then J Lo should be sacked.
 
Also I wonder how many more chances Mr Amiss has? O mac starting Fwd for Peel this weekend..

I would imagine they’ll give him the derby to find form too even if he fails V Swans. Was out of sorts Pre season too and lacklustre last year.
 
I reckon Ras has four or five howlers, a goal, 6 tackles and 4 goal assists.

He needs a consistent run at it. As we all know we have to be careful with these developing players, develop them too long without giving them a decent crack. Nek minute.
 
Erasmus is a general fwd for mine. Good set shot and played juniors as a fwd I believe?

Would be better than Sturt & Banners in the fwd line. As a mid he struggles with executing handballs and freezes under pressure.
 
Also I wonder how many more chances Mr Amiss has? O mac starting Fwd for Peel this weekend..

I would imagine they’ll give him the derby to find form too even if he fails V Swans. Was out of sorts Pre season too and lacklustre last year.

He was actually pretty good last year but was inaccurate. Average about three scores a game (same as Treacy) but Treacy was more accurate. Can’t see O Mac playing forward for what would have to be almost the first time in his professional career overtaking Jye anytime soon.

So to answer your question of how many chances Amiss has.

A lot I reckon. He’s twenty one. Don’t understand the push to drop him at all
 
Also I wonder how many more chances Mr Amiss has? O mac starting Fwd for Peel this weekend..

I would imagine they’ll give him the derby to find form too even if he fails V Swans. Was out of sorts Pre season too and lacklustre last year.

Amiss is due to have a blinder. Just you watch.
 
Also I wonder how many more chances Mr Amiss has? O mac starting Fwd for Peel this weekend..

I would imagine they’ll give him the derby to find form too even if he fails V Swans. Was out of sorts Pre season too and lacklustre last year.
About 50.

He had about 60 shots on goal last year. There are only about 5 players on our list capable of that. 2 are already in the team, 1 is 34 and the other has a dodgy knee.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Also I wonder how many more chances Mr Amiss has? O mac starting Fwd for Peel this weekend..

I would imagine they’ll give him the derby to find form too even if he fails V Swans. Was out of sorts Pre season too and lacklustre last year.
Lacklustre last year? He was our 2nd highest goal scorer. He was fine.

The guy is a jet, you need to just play them for the future as it certainly isn't O Mac playing as a forward.
 
Got that last year, failed.

Huh? Erasmus played in Rd 1 (sub), Rd 5 (sub), Rd 6 (sub), Rd 21 (subbed off). Didn't play a single full game all season.

He played 14 games in 2023 and sub or subbed in 8 of them. The only stretch he had in the starting side was Rd 17-21, and he performed OK. One game against Collingwood with 26 and 10 tackles, and 16-18 touches in the others.

I have no issue with people not rating him. The jury is clearly out. But don't pretend he has had a proper go at establishing himself in the senior side.
 
Nah all good mate. I misread it.

I like where your heads at, rather be wrong and get the win than be right and get beaten by 20 goals.

Unless of course you are right and we get done by 20 goals....

Then J Lo should be sacked.
I'd rather a smashing that can't be ignored than a 3-4 goal loss that can, if we have to lose
 
Erasmus is a general fwd for mine. Good set shot and played juniors as a fwd I believe?

Would be better than Sturt & Banners in the fwd line. As a mid he struggles with executing handballs and freezes under pressure.
In what world would Ras be better than Sturt in the fwd line?
 
Brodie should not play AFL again unless we're desperate and reaching into the bottom of our depth, he doesn't have it anymore.

When he can't be bothered to try at WAFL level he doesn't get that chance at AFL level.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Game Day Round 2 2025: Fremantle Dockers Vs. Sydney Swans


Write your reply...

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top