Prediction Round 22 Changes vs. Geelong
- Thread starter YelloMit
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Erasmus > Fyfe
Emmett > Simpson
Emmett > Simpson
- Thread starter
- #5
Freddy doesn't need a lot of the ball, and at least he kicked a goal and assisted Amiss.
I'm harsh on Chapman because he always stinks it up and never gets dropped.
- Mar 25, 2020
- 2,291
- 6,062
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Nothing wrong with Chappie, he had a bad game, it happens. Remember guys, as annoyed as you may be, there's 3 games left, destiny is in our hands. Players, friends etc probably read some of this so let's get a bit of perspective eh?
DRAGONS FFC - Moderator
- #8
Willsy82
Debutant
Can we swap Darcy for Meek 
- May 3, 2013
- 2,194
- 2,771
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Out Emmett In Fyfe
Raz deserves another game
Raz deserves another game
Chapman wasn't great today. Still think he capable of being best 18 in a premiership side.
Don't forget he hasn't played much football in the last few years, a full preseason and he will improve immensely
Think it could be
Emmett > Fyfe
Erasmus > Johnson
Leaves us a little tall in the forwards though.
Emmett > Fyfe
Erasmus > Johnson
Leaves us a little tall in the forwards though.
And Aish out for Cooper.
Chappy on notice
Chapman really should be on notice.
He isn’t winning any defensive efforts. Let’s his man go out the back.
No one can argue Hughes isn’t a heart of a lion. Goes in hard every time.
He isn’t winning any defensive efforts. Let’s his man go out the back.
No one can argue Hughes isn’t a heart of a lion. Goes in hard every time.
CaseySibosadoHOF
All Australian
- Sep 17, 2022
- 847
- 2,081
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
I'm a big fan of Raz and have defended him profusely, and to be clear he was far from our worst out there. Was starting to get into the flow at stoppage right before we subbed him off (before then he seemed to take the "role player" tag too literally and was pretty passive at stoppage without doing enough defensively to make up for it). Subbed him off too soon, and maybe even subbed off the wrong bloke entirely.
But with Fyfe and Johnson coming back you can't start Raz, and even if he didn't have an iffy history as sub (he does) I'd rather just let him cook for Peel than have him sub.
Johnno and Fyfe for Raz and Emmett, and honestly make anyone but Aish sub.
Works for me.
- Moderator
- #21
Yeah, the way he's going, Drapes can play the Chapman role when Pearce is back.
Play Simpson the rest of the year. By finals he'll have some continuity in the side and could be a real difference maker coming on as sub or even starting on a HFF. Emmett, love your effort and story but you are not our guy.
I'd bring in Hughes for Chapman too.
I'd bring in Hughes for Chapman too.
Chapman has been horrid for the last month and more. He won't get dropped, but he needs to be.
Emmett will be out whether its omitted or suspended doesn't really matter.
Erasmus out too.
Bring Fyfe and Johnson in and move some magnets. It's not like we have anyone ready to take Emmett's spot. Simpson goes invisible in the WAFL let alone AFL.
Emmett will be out whether its omitted or suspended doesn't really matter.
Erasmus out too.
Bring Fyfe and Johnson in and move some magnets. It's not like we have anyone ready to take Emmett's spot. Simpson goes invisible in the WAFL let alone AFL.
- Moderator
- #24
NOD in.
Simpson in for Emmett.
Johnson can be sub to manage that foot.
Aish can take the chappy role.
Simpson in for Emmett.
Johnson can be sub to manage that foot.
Aish can take the chappy role.
Purple Jesus
not jess
Rather Hughes. Aish has been bog average.
