Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[ROOINYOU]

Do I trade Dusty and Higgins to (Pre-Trade Rookie Structure: On Field 3-3-2. $61k in bank):

Lloyd and Rozee/Miers (2-4-3, ~$260k in bank).
OR
Neale and Rozee/Miers (3-3-3, ~$260k in bank).
OR
Sloane and Boak/Dahlhaus (3-3-2, $15k/$85k in bank).

Sloane and Boak.

 

[hoddo]

6000 have traded out Heeney.
600 have traded out Cogs, 36 of them to Scott Lycett.
63 people have traded Gawn to Lycett. Deary ******* me!

Can't understand the last two, but the Heeney one seems reasonable. Since last year's bye he's tonned up just twice in 11 matches and scored under 80 in 6 games … one injury affected. He seems to be playing a SC unfriendly role more often than not and I wouldn't want him until there was sound evidence that was going to change.

 

[Red Syrah]

I'm at the point where it sickens me to see Heeney in my team, but the best trade option is Telly, and I already have Danger and Dollhouse.

What to do.

Good news, I'm in the top 500

Heeny has the same bye so it wont affect byes. It could be a form of risk mitigation, if 1 Geel fwd has a bad day hopefully the others step up..

 

[buttox]

just realized i can go
mills to newman
hore via moore to worpel
means i only field 1 rookie in defense.
very tempting. Thoughts?

 

[balmainforever]

just realized i can go
mills to newman
hore via moore to worpel
means i only field 1 rookie in defense.
very tempting. Thoughts?
View attachment 646141View attachment 646142

Structure is almost the same as mine.

 

[AN1611]

IF Greene doesn't get up this week, will look to move him on.

Who would everyone go out of Boak vs Worpedo?

Boak has Wines coming back and Worpedo is a 2nd year player who might fade once the season goes on

 

[ROOINYOU]

So many issues to be dealt with including Dusty, Goldy and Weeney. Basically i'm looking to try and do the following over the next few weeks...

Dusty > Rockpig
Atkins > LDU (I like what i am seeing!)
Goldy > Gawn
Heeney > Kiera
Zac W > Seagull

Thoughts?

if thats all you want to do.. I would go Dusty and Goldy out this week.
Kiera next week if Heendog goes full spud against carlton
hold Zac for now..Lloyd cant get much more expensive.he will get cheaper!
Hold Atkins over LDU...has just as much cash to be made. LDU too expensive for the same risk.

the smart part of me(my balls) is saying that all these premo trades are not worth it...aside from maybe Goldy/Gawn.
we're only dealing with bad scores, not injuries!
dark times are coming my friend...trades will be burnt and lessons learned.
Get growth now...not points.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

What the hell was the go with Mundy on Sunday? Huttabito

Didn't watch the game but saw his TOG was yuck.

Was already planning on dumping Lynch, but at the moment Mundy is more of an issue.

Might go Lynch + Mundy OUT for Worpel + Moore and just bank the cash for a week.

 

[Hava Alle]

Dusty (gtfo of my team) - Rockpig
Heeney - Boak

 

[ROOINYOU]

Is Darcy Moore worth getting? It would either be Andrew McGrath or Callum Mills making way

No!
he's one fugly dude and wont score 90's every week.

 

[Quazza]

Heeney definitely a concern for me. Leaning twards Telly, or maybe Boak who I had at F3 most the pre season but switched to Dunkley late

 

[PowerForGood]

Geez, I'm getting convinced on here that Heeney is this year's Billings.

 

[ROOINYOU]

Am thinking him as well. Looking the goods at CHB and Collingwood appear to be playing a keepings off style of game so lots of seagull kicks around the backline.

dont think the Pies will play like that every week!
wont need to wait as long to attack against lesser teams.
I think he was pretty lucky to get 93

 

[mochacinolatte]

Geez, I'm getting convinced on here that Heeney is this year's Billings.

But Heeney can kick goals though?

 

[Quazza]

Geez, I'm getting convinced on here that Heeney is this year's Billings.

Thrillings is currently averaging more than Heeney too. Let that sink in for just a moment.....

 

[mochacinolatte]

Thrillings is currently averaging more than Heeney too. Let that sink in for just a moment.....

 

[Metapod]

Heeney will play mid eventually, hold. He’s just getting to 100% after his ankle injury. Those trading him; if he drops to ~420k R5-6, then bangs out 2 x 100s will you look to bring him back in? Not worth 2 trades. He will be top 6 come tailend

 

[Asho81]

Not sure this week..... will be getting Rockliff somehow. Don’t ave Constable which probably should be a focus;

A. Heeney + Atkins —> Moore + Rocky + $130k spare

B. Steele + Gibbons —> rocky + Constable + $215k spare

C. Steele + Butters —> Rocky + Sheed


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[SavDog23]

Thrillings is currently averaging more than Heeney too. Let that sink in for just a moment.....

Rozee also for 330k less. Im giving him 3 more rounds to prove himself before he becomes Telly or Lloyd.

 

[LegendLewis]

Heeney will play mid eventually, hold. He’s just getting to 100% after his ankle injury. Those trading him; if he drops to ~420k R5-6, then bangs out 2 x 100s will you look to bring him back in? Not worth 2 trades. He will be top 6 come tailend

Actually not convinced of that at all anymore. 2 tonnes in 11 games. Injury prone. Coach playing him injured. Coach will play him forward if Forward line not functioning and the forward line is not functioning. Who knows what Horse will do??

 

[Pykie]

if thats all you want to do.. I would go Dusty and Goldy out this week.
Kiera next week if Heendog goes full spud against carlton
hold Zac for now..Lloyd cant get much more expensive.he will get cheaper!
Hold Atkins over LDU...has just as much cash to be made. LDU too expensive for the same risk.

the smart part of me(my balls) is saying that all these premo trades are not worth it...aside from maybe Goldy/Gawn.
we're only dealing with bad scores, not injuries!
dark times are coming my friend...trades will be burnt and lessons learned.
Get growth now...not points.

There is no risk with LDU.

His TOG% is low atm, he's still earning the trust of the coaching staff.

After the weekend, I imagine he will become the #2 center bounce midfielder after Cunnington, he barely turns it over, he's a natural SC pig because of his goal assists, score involvements and good disposal.

Get onboard, he's going super saiyan.

100+ average for the year.

 

[enobrien]

Heeney will play mid eventually, hold. He’s just getting to 100% after his ankle injury. Those trading him; if he drops to ~420k R5-6, then bangs out 2 x 100s will you look to bring him back in? Not worth 2 trades. He will be top 6 come tailend

Judd_Magic

 

[Hai_Newman]

Should be considering no trades but

Hanley plus Heeney
To
Newman plus Worpel

is starting at me and my need to trade out of habit is still there.

Someone talk me out of it.

Look like good trades to me.

 

[PowerForGood]

Heeney will play mid eventually, hold. He’s just getting to 100% after his ankle injury. Those trading him; if he drops to ~420k R5-6, then bangs out 2 x 100s will you look to bring him back in? Not worth 2 trades. He will be top 6 come tailend

If the opinion is that a sideways trade to someone "better" than Heeney over remainder of the year is worth it, then won't require a reverse trade.

Also Top 6 come end of year / league finals relevant isn't Top 6 total over year / overall ranking relevant.

I'm not of that opinion yet but if I get there then it has to be this week.

 

[buttox]

Not sure this week..... will be getting Rockliff somehow. Don’t ave Constable which probably should be a focus;

A. Heeney + Atkins —> Moore + Rocky + $130k spare

B. Steele + Gibbons —> rocky + Constable + $215k spare

C. Steele + Butters —> Rocky + Sheed


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

post your team.
those trades seem heinous.
we all know rocky is capable of scoring 20