Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[SC fish]

Anyone gonna hold Hore?
See a lot of people trading, I'm liking him a loophole option

Good for Clark/Scrimshaw or other this week.
Plus he should be back soon.

True, but I've got a decent loophole in Bines, so need to move Hore on to someone who is going to make $$

 

[shaunfern]

Is Hore to Parker (via Darcy Moore) worth it? Given I would have to sacrifice Moore’s link up with Burgess?

Forward line would be thiinnnn.

Danger, Heeney, Billings, Parker, Setterfield, Drew....Bench: Balta & Petrucelle

 

[Mongoose528]

Current team:

Backs: Crisp / Williams / Smith / Scrimshaw / Clark / Duursma // Wilkie / Burgess

Mids: Macrae / Cripps / Oliver / M. Crouch / Dusty / B. Crouch / Walsh / Constable // Scott / Butters / Gibbons

Rucks: Gawn / Grundy // Bines

Forwards: Dangerfield / Heeney / Greene / Moore / Setterfield / Drew // Parker / Balta

Trades:

Option 1: Dusty -> LDU + Greene -> Boak/Worpel/Kelly (If so, which forward? - Currently thinking Kelly.)

Option 2: Dusty -> Lloyd via Duursma.

Currently leaning towards option 1, LDU looks like a great in currently, so does Kelly. Thoughts?

 

[Axly]

True, but I've got a decent loophole in Bines, so need to move Hore on to someone who is going to make $$

Yeah the money side of things is true and prices change this week.
With loophole I more meant as a loophole for rookie scores than captaincy. Its handy

 

[Benno_900]

Heeney - > Whitfield via DPP
Hore - > Rozee

 

[Young Gun #6]

Is the following trade stupid? Note I have Moore and 3 rookies on field in defense atm. I can use Hore as a loop between Clark and Collins.

Goldy -> Mumford
Hore -> B.Smith

Goldy looked awful with Campbell in the side and he stayed in this week along with possibly Wood as well.

I really want him gone but don’t want to make another trade that generates 155k to try get Grundy in (ie B.Crouch to LDU).


Is the top trade stupid with Mumford coming in with no form line?

 

[balmainforever]

Ridley --> clark
need the cash gen

 

[SC fish]

Yeah the money side of things is true and prices change this week.
With loophole I more meant as a loophole for rookie scores than captaincy. Its handy

As it happens I've left Hore on field and put the E on Clark tonight. If Clark scores well I might decide to keep Hore after all!

 

[JT_the_Man]

Is the following trade stupid? Note I have Moore and 3 rookies on field in defense atm. I can use Hore as a loop between Clark and Collins.

Goldy -> Mumford
Hore -> B.Smith

Goldy looked awful with Campbell in the side and he stayed in this week along with possibly Wood as well.

I really want him gone but don’t want to make another trade that generates 155k to try get Grundy in (ie B.Crouch to LDU).


Is the top trade stupid with Mumford coming in with no form line?

Damnit now you’ve given me something else to think about...

 

[Edmund hunt]

Should i replace Hore with Smith or Moore?

 

[Mongoose528]

Should i replace Hore with Smith or Moore?

Moore imo.

 

[SC fish]

Just realised I have enough $$ to go Mills to Lloyd!

 

[Scythe94]

Keeping Hore for tonight at least - let’s me loophole Clark. If Clark spuds it up, then might make the trade. If Clark goes well, I’ll keep Hore for a week and reassess next round.

 

[Edmund hunt]

Moore imo.

Why would it be moore?

 

[JT_the_Man]

I forgot how stressful this trading shit is!

Greene > Telly, McGrath > Moore
Or
Greene > Moore, Hore > Rozee/Scrimshaw

 

[Metapod]

Who’s the better in: Gibbons or Rozee

 

[King_Steele]

I forgot how stressful this trading shit is!

Greene > Telly, McGrath > Moore
Or
Greene > Moore, Hore > Rozee/Scrimshaw

1st option

 

[King_Steele]

Who’s the better in: Gibbons or Rozee

Gibbons

 

[stevebbb]

Trades doooone!!! No reveeeerse

Valente to LDU
Mills to Worpel (via Moore to Def)

Hore and Mr Donut P Bines my only non playing players, unless Scrimshaw gets dropped (which I really can't see happening)

 

[JT_the_Man]

1st option

Screw it, trigger pulled!

 

[JT_the_Man]

Screw it, trigger pulled!

Actually Worpel or Telly

I hate this game

 

[King_Steele]

Trades doooone!!! No reveeeerse

Valente to LDU
Mills to Worpel (via Moore to Def)

Hore and Mr Donut P Bines my only non playing players, unless Scrimshaw gets dropped (which I really can't see happening)

Nice trades brother

 

[King_Steele]

Actually Worpel or Telly

I hate this game

Telly easily

 

[ubeaut]

Current team:

Backs: Crisp / Williams / Smith / Scrimshaw / Clark / Duursma // Wilkie / Burgess

Mids: Macrae / Cripps / Oliver / M. Crouch / Dusty / B. Crouch / Walsh / Constable // Scott / Butters / Gibbons

Rucks: Gawn / Grundy // Bines

Forwards: Dangerfield / Heeney / Greene / Moore / Setterfield / Drew // Parker / Balta

Trades:

Option 1: Dusty -> LDU + Greene -> Boak/Worpel/Kelly (If so, which forward? - Currently thinking Kelly.)

Option 2: Dusty -> Lloyd via Duursma.

Currently leaning towards option 1, LDU looks like a great in currently, so does Kelly. Thoughts?

Option 1 for sure mate. Your midfield is deep enough to afford that switch. LDU will make great coin. Make sure u get T. Kelly.

 

[Mongoose528]

Why would it be moore?

Moore is playing in a Supercoach friendly role with the way Collingwood are set up, and should continue to score well, whereas I don't think Smith will reach the heights of Moore.