Round 3 Trades

[stevebbb]

Hibberd to boner
Cameron to fisher.
I'm thinking.

I like Fisher, could easily average 90 and be a F6 keeper. Plays a main role for the Blues

 

[SavDog23]

Trouble is, he'll go berserk against Wet Coast

And then has St Kilda the week after. So the 130 game will only be in his 3 round average for 1 week, because he didn't play round 1. He could very easily go 160+ against the Eagles and Saints and have a 150 3 round average and go UP in price.
Would have been 145+ today if the match didn't pass the 3300 score limit with 2 minutes left.

 

[fantasyunit]

First thoughts are Hibberd>Bonner and Venables>Taranto.

Seems a bit mad to go premium/rookie to two mid-pricers. If Bonner can match Hibberd for another month, then I can use the 300K to shore up my forward line so that I only have to play one of Ryan/Fritsch/ZGL each week.

Could also use it to get Danger, but it'd be for Cogs, Cripps or Fyfe, none of which I'm willing to ditch. Committed to getting Danger cheaper later on.

 

[Asho81]

Got all the right rookies.
150k spare, sitting about 6000, and only 1 Trade necessary.......

Crouch —> Dangerfield.

 

[JDavey]

That has to be the dumbest argument I have ever seen. Does that even show disposal efficiency? Clangers? What they do with the ball?
Like how you also completely avoided the 19 kicks and 6 handballs v 13 kicks and 23 handballs. What you do with the possessions matters and 1 Dusty 50m spear kick is better than 10 Danger 1 2 handballs. Theres a reason Tom Mitchell doesnt get 200+ points every week.

What even game is that from Danger? Not this year.
On top of that scores are scaled and weighted depending what happened in that game. Comparing scores from 2 different games is dumb as ****. Dangers couldve been in one with lots of touches and scoring so its worth less. Dusts game at least, there was not much scoring going on from other Richmond players.

• Yes it literally shows those things in the same thing you're quoting. Thanks for beating me out on 'DUMBEST ARGUMENT I HAVE EVER SEEN' on your opening sentences.
• 6 extra kicks do not make up for 17 handballs, CP, clearances, etc.
• Obviously it's not from this year, Dangers first game was today and if you were watching he didn't kick 4.
• Scaling and weighting doesn't account for the difference in DT to SC, try again.
• No its not, thats the whole premises of SC is to compare players you dumb campaigner (not to mention before you make this dumbass statement you spent a paragraph comparing stats and then players, nuffy and a hypocrite HAHAHHA)
• Danger got 3 brownlow votes for that game, Dusty unlikely to match (3 Jenkins, 2 Laird). I'm sure those touches were 'worth less though'

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Bontempelli to anyone.

I have him too, he looks terrible and spending too much time up forward.

I'm trading him for Danger.

 

[Vineyy]

Salem > Liam Ryan (via DPP)
Matt Crouch > Dangerfield

370k leftover to strengthen my forward line over the next week or two.

 

[buttox]

I like Fisher, could easily average 90 and be a F6 keeper. Plays a main role for the Blues

Yup and for 260k he is super cheap.
I want my forward rookies on the bench.
Fisher goes to f5. English to r3 for ruck cover.
Better balance and I've now got my danger cash.

 

[vast]

Naughton to Bonner only one on the cards at this stage.

 

[Spacedog]

And then has St Kilda the week after. So the 130 game will only be in his 3 round average for 1 week, because he didn't play round 1. He could very easily go 160+ against the Eagles and Saints and have a 150 3 round average and go UP in price.
Would have been 145+ today if the match didn't pass the 3300 score limit with 2 minutes left.

I don't think he will go 160+, he was actually spending lots of time forward and jelwood + ablett were stealing his points. Duncan back will only mean less midfield time

 

[jc12]

first of all... **** YOU CAMERON ****ING RAYNER, NUMBER 1 DRAFT PICK MY ARSE, if i had ryan on the field instead of him i would of got 2400 but no, had to spud it up, ****ing shit team brisbane

anyway should i trade him and bank an extra 80-90 k?

 

[Wildrig]

No Trades

Defs : Laird,Lloyd,Sicily,Doedee,Finlayson,Murray (Naughton,Murphy)

Mids : Dusty,Merrett,Parker,Coniglio,Cripps,Fyfe,Kelly,Holman (Brayshaw,Banfield,Barry)

Rucks : Gawn, Nankervis (Cameron)

Fwds : Greene,Billings,Walters,Smith,Petracca,Ryan (Fritsch,Giles-Langdon)

Am I missing anything ? I feel weird not trading but I have no room to play with getting Naughton out. 30 trades left just doesn’t seem right !

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Hibberd to Simpson

Naughton to Murphy

228k in the war chest leaves me with this side.

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

Have you got a specific plan for the warchest?

Otherwise Mihocek - Murray is a better trade. At least Naughton is getting a game.

 

[enobrien]

I like Fisher, could easily average 90 and be a F6 keeper. Plays a main role for the Blues

Do we know how hes scoring so well? His DT:SC ratio has quite the discrepancy in both games

Noticed his DE% is good

 

[enobrien]

No Trades

Defs : Laird,Lloyd,Sicily,Doedee,Finlayson,Murray (Naughton,Murphy)

Mids : Dusty,Merrett,Parker,Coniglio,Cripps,Fyfe,Kelly,Holman (Brayshaw,Banfield,Barry)

Rucks : Gawn, Nankervis (Cameron)

Fwds : Greene,Billings,Walters,Smith,Petracca,Ryan (Fritsch,Giles-Langdon)

Am I missing anything ? I feel weird not trading but I have no room to play with getting Naughton out. 30 trades left just doesn’t seem right !

Nailed the rookies, no underperforming premos, hold!

Just watch this space on Sicily/Greene over suspension and injury concerns

 

[Plugger Mcnally]

Depending on Fyfe

Trade 1: get 10K

Trade 2: Fyfe to Dusty

Risky. Fyfe looking like he has an upside, Dusty dominating. Get em both and Sloane.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Hey guys, I took the gamble on starting with Cam Rayner - whats the best thing to do with him? bench cover (assuming he has good JS)?

 

[buttox]

Do we know how hes scoring so well? His DT:SC ratio has quite the discrepancy in both games

Noticed his DE% is good

He's a little gun is why.
Blues have a superstar in the making IMO.

 

[srobbo]

Thoughts on Geary as a D5? Average 114 for 362k. Noticed his average for the past two years has been 65. Tonned up the past two rounds, before that the last time was Rd.1 2015

Don’t do it.

Yes he’s shown over the years he can ton with a reasonably high ceiling, but his lows are just as bad & more frequent. His role changes too much w2w from free wheeling to lockdown.

Guarantee you’ll be trading him out by R8

 

[srobbo]

Lambert >> Taranto the only one for me at this stage.

 

[Phoenix_9]

Dahlhaus —> R. Gray
Hibberd —> Simpson

Dahlhaus in a shit team, playing a shit role. My biggest blunder. Gray, proven gun, with the recruitment of Watts and Rockliff, should play more midfield minutes and average over 100.

Hibberd, looks to be getting less cheap possessions from kick outs (or kick outs to himself), with Vince and Lewis taking them more frequently. Simpson, old yes, but so bloody durable. Looks to have taken some of Dochertys points off half back, and the ball will be in defense plenty. Lock him in for 100 average as well.

Luxury trades, but I usually use 4 over the first couple weeks, and I’ve used none and I don’t have any midpricers or rookies to correct.

Pending teams, they’re done deals.

 

[vanders]

I dont have Dusty or Danger, I have enough in the bank to get either of them. Obviously Danger is a massive POD but will he score more than Dusty? I could pay 100k extra for Danger and be 10-30 worse off each week if I take Danger instead of Dusty.

 

[OB11]

A Brayshaw > J Higgins
Crouch > TMitch

 

[Didstar]

Bonner a must have?
Want to go Naughton to Bonner, but will need a secondary trade of Brayshaw to a basement rookie.

 

[Leftyitis]

And so it begins. One corrective trade being Dow > Taranto.

Dow was just chillin on mid bench with LDU and Barry. This trade allows me to swap Taranto with Garlett who was on field in the fwd line.

Leaves me with 300K in the (Danger) kitty, that may change to the Oliver kitty over the next 3-6 weeks.