Game Day Round 4, 2024: Richmond v St.Kilda - Norwood Oval, Sunday 7th April, 3:20PM AEST *GATHER ROUND*

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Stassi Schroeder GIF by Stassi

nuclear holocaust vibes

I’m tipping a draw, but a brave one.
Yeah it's gonna be a nervous day.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Should win this. No Liam Baker, no Tom Lynch, no Noah Balta, no Dylan Grimes, no Jacob Hopper, no Dion Prestia. Their backline looking pretty lean and we've got King back off a suspension as well as Membrey and Caminiti who should stretch their backline, a few of their good mids out and their star key forward out. If we can't get this one done there's some worries.
 
as well as Membrey and Caminiti who should stretch their backline

People keep saying things like "stretch their backline" but if that was a thing then wouldn't sides just pick 6 tall forwards every week? Personally I don't remember many occasions where a notably tall forward line took a lot of marks and kicked a lot of goals. Usually they concede just as many intercepts and the ball runs out easily because they can't chase.
 
People keep saying things like "stretch their backline" but if that was a thing then wouldn't sides just pick 6 tall forwards every week? Personally I don't remember many occasions where a notably tall forward line took a lot of marks and kicked a lot of goals. Usually they concede just as many intercepts and the ball runs out easily because they can't chase.
It only works if you get good clean ball use and deep entries.

A key forward 1 on 1 with the above and it’s generally money
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Hastie sub again
Understand why Hastie is the sub, but just seems strange having Sharman, Caminiti, King, and Membrey in the same 22. Would've got Sharman or Caminiti as sub. Haven't had those 4 in the same lineup before so will be interesting to see the dynamic of the talls, as well as whether Sharman even spends the majority of the time up forward.
 
Understand why Hastie is the sub, but just seems strange having Sharman, Caminiti, King, and Membrey in the same 22. Would've got Sharman or Caminiti as sub. Haven't had those 4 in the same lineup before so will be interesting to see the dynamic of the talls, as well as whether Sharman even spends the majority of the time up forward.
12 months ago. When Sharman was struggling and out of the side.

He wasn’t seen by our coaching group as a “tall”.

I’d imagine that’s still the case.
 
Understand why Hastie is the sub, but just seems strange having Sharman, Caminiti, King, and Membrey in the same 22. Would've got Sharman or Caminiti as sub. Haven't had those 4 in the same lineup before so will be interesting to see the dynamic of the talls, as well as whether Sharman even spends the majority of the time up forward.
Yep will be interesting especially when you add Philliou (190cm) and Owens (191 cm) to the fwd mix.
 
Understand why Hastie is the sub, but just seems strange having Sharman, Caminiti, King, and Membrey in the same 22. Would've got Sharman or Caminiti as sub. Haven't had those 4 in the same lineup before so will be interesting to see the dynamic of the talls, as well as whether Sharman even spends the majority of the time up forward.

IMO Sharman has to play not forward, and Caminiti has to play second ruck
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top