Round 4 Trades

[KardiniaPark]

go sloane - i've done it this round.
locked in & no regrets

I just like the idea of cash and being able to make a decent upgrade next week instead of all my eggs in the Sloane basket.

 

[shotgun_blues]

B: Simpson, Newnes, Ibbotson, Oxley, Saad, McIntosh (Goodes, Brown)
M: Sloane, Pendlebury, Selwood, Cotchin, Ward, Wines, Cripps, Vandenberg (Heeney, Nelson, Anderson)
R: Naitanui, Minson (Cox)
F: Dahlhaus, Zorko, D.Smith, Wingard, Clark, Hogan (Saad, Lamb)

Ummed and arghed the following trades all week:

Wines>CEY
Goodes>B.Smith

Or...

Wines>CEY
Lamb>Bontempelli

Then Minson was dropped:

Wines>Krakouer
Lamb>Ryder

Eventually settled on this last night:

Wines>CEY
Saad>Ryder
(For about 6 or so reasons it made sense - ruck coverage for the season and Ryder the obvious choice, Port has an easy run soon enough, CEY will make quick cash and score better than Saad, Krak can wait until next week, loopholes this week etc)

Leaves just enough cash next week to go:

Anderson/Nelson>Krakouer
Lamb>Tarrant

First upgrade hopefully will be Goodes & McIntosh to Hibberd/Malceski & downgrade ASAP as D6 looks a problem already after McIntoshs insipid performance last night. With 5 premium forwards I can concentrate on upgrading the defence ASAP. Surprised Minson was dropped after scoring 95 last week but want to keep him and hopefully it's the kick up the arse he needs for the remainder of the season and damned if I'm doing a ruck trade or copping a donut every time one misses a game.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Ok here we go ;

I have 303k. I want to get rid of NVB early because I only have 4 prem mids.

This is $573k to spend. So in order to get Sloane I would have to also downgrade Goodes to a 50/50 rookie such asGeelong Jazny or old mate from Bris.

I also have the option to keep Goodes, only make the one trade and go straight to Dangerfield with the money in my bank which I quite like.

Danger would leave me with 28 trades and no cash. Don't mind it though.

 

[Dirtywhirl]

Decided to stick fat with Goddard and Griffen, no trades this week. Will catch you in the vent thread after Bont pulls out another 130 tomorrow

 

[toxic]

Went Bartel to goddard
and
anderson to krakhoare

No idea why goddard but figured no thinking was a new better style

 

[The_Steadier]

Ok here we go ;

I have 303k. I want to get rid of NVB early because I only have 4 prem mids.

This is $573k to spend. So in order to get Sloane I would have to also downgrade Goodes to a 50/50 rookie such asGeelong Jazny or old mate from Bris.

I also have the option to keep Goodes, only make the one trade and go straight to Dangerfield with the money in my bank which I quite like.

Danger would leave me with 28 trades and no cash. Don't mind it though.

If I were you I'd downgrade to Hugh Goddard and get Sloane.
He will definitely get a good run at it at some stage this year- been playing well in the VFL, and he and McCartin are our future backbone.

Won't be a huge scorer, but once he's in the side I reckon his JS will be very good.

 

[toxic]

Ok here we go ;

I have 303k. I want to get rid of NVB early because I only have 4 prem mids.

This is $573k to spend. So in order to get Sloane I would have to also downgrade Goodes to a 50/50 rookie such asGeelong Jazny or old mate from Bris.

I also have the option to keep Goodes, only make the one trade and go straight to Dangerfield with the money in my bank which I quite like.

Danger would leave me with 28 trades and no cash. Don't mind it though.

Its hannaberry time

Its jack steven time...hmmm gutsy

Its coniglio time $$$$

 

[KardiniaPark]

If I were you I'd downgrade to Hugh Goddard and get Sloane.
He will definitely get a good run at it at some stage this year- been playing well in the VFL, and he and McCartin are our future backbone.

Won't be a huge scorer, but once he's in the side I reckon his JS will be very good.

I can't put him in sight unseen. 1-2 injuries down back and I'm in trouble. Its too risky, I was stuck with Fuller for all of last year I don't want to do that again.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Its hannaberry time

Its jack steven time...hmmm gutsy

Its coniglio time $$$$

No,no, was a maybe now it's a no. Surely you have danger ahead of them?

 

[toxic]

No,no, was a maybe now it's a no. Surely you have danger ahead of them?

Nope..

Contract = poor SC

I rate hanners massively when fit

Lachie neale is interesting and sam.mitchell is ultra reliable

 

[Gene Simmons]

I'm gambling on late-in, with Blitz as my go-to if Minson doesn't get back in. With his midfield work lately, he could be well worth swinging in there since pure rucks in general have taken a nosedive.

Does Blicavs have good job security? Is McIntosh or West due back anytime soon... ?

The other similar priced option is Grundy.. So I guess it's a question of BLICAVS v GRUNDY? Either option will free me up some cash for an upgrade next week..

 

[The_Steadier]

Nope..

Contract = poor SC

Not to mention Walsh seems to have a boner for playing Danger up fwd for large periods.

 

[toxic]

Not to mention Walsh seems to have a boner for playing Danger up fwd for large periods.

He has sloane and a cast of 6 or 7 others who play thru the mids..a fit and firing tex and eddie taking dangers goals

More even team possession distribution
KardiniaPark

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

Need some help with one of my trades,
option A) Anderson to Gregson
option B) Anderson to Tarrant (via Krakour dpp)
option C) Hold Anderson and wait for cheaper rookie to debut

 

[toxic]

Need some help with one of my trades,
option A) Anderson to Gregson
option B) Anderson to Tarrant (via Krakour dpp)
option C) Hold Anderson and wait for cheaper rookie to debut

anderson traveled with the hawks, mite yet play.. apparently hodge, sam mitchell, ruffy, breust, birchall, gibson, dunstall, buckenarra, lake, hill, mcevoy all in doubt...

well according to paige they are anyway

 

[Benson FC]

What are Minson owners doing?
I'm thinking about just taking Lonies score and using Bellchambers, but that's a decision I will have to make before Ess v Coll lock out.
Reason I'm holding out trading is, I can't afford Goldstein without a double trade, and I need Anderson to loophole Vandenbergs score.
What's the word on Minson? I didn't think his form had been too bad

 

[toxic]

View attachment 127582 What are Minson owners doing?
I'm thinking about just taking Lonies score and using Bellchambers, but that's a decision I will have to make before Ess v Coll lock out.
Reason I'm holding out trading is, I can't afford Goldstein without a double trade, and I need Anderson to loophole Vandenbergs score.
What's the word on Minson? I didn't think his form had been too bad

and if anderson plays?

 

[Benson FC]

and if anderson plays?

Hadn't heard that we was was a chance to? Who's in doubt?
If that's the case... Then I'm probably leaning towards just putting Heeney on the field and missing Vanberbergs score.
Just wondering what people with minson are doing. 2 trades are tempting though given goldsteins 83 break even.. But there's other areas id like to improve before a ruck trade
Unless anyone has information about why minson was dropped and how long for

 

[toxic]

Hadn't heard that we was was a chance to? Who's in doubt?
If that's the case... Then I'm probably leaning towards just putting Heeney on the field and missing Vanberbergs score.
Just wondering what people with minson are doing. 2 trades are tempting though given goldsteins 83 break even.. But there's other areas id like to improve before a ruck trade
Unless anyone has information about why minson was dropped and how long for

i have no knowdlege of anyone being in doubt but he did travel with the team, possibly as just insurance...

 

[smidla]

Any thoughts on what I should do with Malcheski? Trade to smith?

 

[SnappyHappy]

I need to downgrade Goodes but I don't like the JS of Kelly or Andrews.

Think I'll take a punt on Matt Dick who has been playing well in VFL and a chance for more games at Carlton.

Carlton fans? Is he a chance for more games? Gingy ? TheOz ?

 

[Mattrox]

Goodes to kelly for me. Would love to wait a week, but need cash to use for my ollie wines trade. Worst case Kelly can be a loophole candidate when he gets dropped

10 tackles usually gets lots of ticks in the coaches eyes. Here's hoping!!

Crows Kelly could well lose his spot next week if Cheney gets up.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Ok here we go ;

I have 303k. I want to get rid of NVB early because I only have 4 prem mids.

This is $573k to spend. So in order to get Sloane I would have to also downgrade Goodes to a 50/50 rookie such asGeelong Jazny or old mate from Bris.

I also have the option to keep Goodes, only make the one trade and go straight to Dangerfield with the money in my bank which I quite like.

Danger would leave me with 28 trades and no cash. Don't mind it though.

I also have a simular problem, some very ordinary mids. I need Slone ASAP! I have NVB as well and 50k to spend, I will have to downgrade another rookie also, I would also like to get Lamb > Tarrant this week as well. HHMMMmmm, big decisions coming up this week. I will be watching what you do this week KP.

 

[Benson FC]

i have no knowdlege of anyone being in doubt but he did travel with the team, possibly as just insurance...

Mm.. In that case, Anderson to Krak, Gray to the mids to get Vandenbergs score, Krak to start over Lonie, Mclaren on the field to loophole Hogans score.. Haha
Only thing is, doubt we will know if Andrerson is in before Lonie locks out.. Going to trade Anderson to Krak next week so maybe I should just do it now..

 

[KardiniaPark]

I also have a simular problem, some very ordinary mids. I need Slone ASAP! I have NVB as well and 50k to spend, I will have to downgrade another rookie also, I would also like to get Lamb > Tarrant this week as well. HHMMMmmm, big decisions coming up this week. I will be watching what you do this week KP.

I'm holding for now. Will decide on Sloane v Danger tomorrow.