Round 4 Trades

[Judd_Magic]

Not this week. Maybe next week. I assume you want Menzel's points on the field but he's got so little history recently that I think you need to at least look at him a week longer.

Then again a game against us might just boost his numbers out of proportion. It's risky.

Yeah, really want his points as I think he will ton up against Essendon compared to another 50-60 from Mills.

Menzel still has to play this week before his price changes so wouldn't be the worst idea in the world to wait one more week I guess.

 

[pincrusher]

I did say I might change my mind. But if there is a 15+ppg scoring difference between him and Gray/Parker come seasons end, isn't it worth it? I think both Gray and Parker could stick at 120+, while I'm not sure Shiel will average much more than 105. I'll probably be wrong, but it seems to bare out in the stats. Both Gray and Parker kick more goals and get much more contested footy than Shiel while averaging slightly higher possession numbers.

I've been slightly disappointed with Shiel and Wines so far. I thought they would tear it up this year. However, Shiel is still averaging a ton and we're only 3 games in. No way I'm trading him out at this point in time. Look at all the people that traded out Fyfe after the first week.

 

[pincrusher]

Can't believe Menadue survived the chop. He looked like a 12yo playing among men last week. That to me is an indication of the lack of depth at tigerland right now.

 

[Deliverance]

With Parish you've got all the best rookies starting on field.

Hold on second trade JM.

Haha! That's what I love to hear. Tell JM to hold his trades and he'll burn them quicker than the sun burns an Irishman.

 

[pincrusher]

Not sure whether to hold S Gray or trade. Been very disappointing so far this year after such a hot finish to 2015.

 

[Deliverance]

I did say I might change my mind. But if there is a 15+ppg scoring difference between him and Gray/Parker come seasons end, isn't it worth it? I think both Gray and Parker could stick at 120+, while I'm not sure Shiel will average much more than 105. I'll probably be wrong, but it seems to bare out in the stats. Both Gray and Parker kick more goals and get much more contested footy than Shiel while averaging slightly higher possession numbers.

Why do you think Parker will stick at 120+? Is it because of his first 3 rounds? We're you "sure" that Shiel would average 105+ before round 1?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Haha! That's what I love to hear. Tell JM to hold his trades and he'll burn them quicker than the sun burns an Irishman.

LOL!

Well there is Irish in my family tree.

 

[Deliverance]

LOL!

Well there is Irish in my family tree.

Same, got me a free pass around Europe.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Not sure whether to hold S Gray or trade. Been very disappointing so far this year after such a hot finish to 2015.

I have no idea what to do with S.Gray either.

I have the double wammy up forward in S.Gray and Barlow.

Maybe best to hold till byes if you have both like me and dump the worst one while keeping the best out of the 2 for F6 or as F7/M9 cover for finals.

Man I am making too much sense here when I should really be saying TRADE! TRADE! TRADE!

 

[Judd_Magic]

Same, got me a free pass around Europe.

I would love to just go and drink pints of Guinness in a pub over in Dublin one day with all the mad Irish. LOL!

 

[pincrusher]

I have no idea what to do with S.Gray either.

I have the double wammy up forward in S.Gray and Barlow.

Maybe best to hold till byes if you have both like me and dump the worst one while keeping the best out of the 2 for F6 or as F7/M9 cover for finals.

Man I am making too much sense here when I should really be saying TRADE! TRADE! TRADE!

At the moment I've gone Barlow> Parker and S Gray> Hartley via DPP. Gives me $478k in the bank. Was a toss up between Parker and R Gray. No doubt will reverse several times through the course of the day!!

 

[vicpride]

Should I stick with Pendles? I've also got Lobbe who I thought might average 90 odd but has had an average start.

Sent from my GT-I8730 using Tapatalk

 

[dash555]

Is Hewett to Hartley a good trade this week. I do have bench cover with Davis, Mills? That's the only trade considering at the moment. Advice?

 

[Deliverance]

Gone sideways crazy this week. Pendles & Hoff to Hall and Zorko.
I can so see this blowing up in my face.

Next week, I'm in board the Lyons train.

 

[pincrusher]

Gone sideways crazy this week. Pendles & Hoff to Hall and Zorko.
I can so see this blowing up in my face.

Next week, I'm in board the Lyons train.

Think there's going to be a bit of that this week. (sideways trading I mean). I am trading out S Gray and Barlow. Trying to work out whether or not I can afford to pass up Hartley and just trade to two premo's. I have $243k, so I could afford R Gray and Jelwood for those two, or Zorko instead of Jelwood. It's going to do my head in by the end of the day.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Can't believe Menadue survived the chop. He looked like a 12yo playing among men last week. That to me is an indication of the lack of depth at tigerland right now.

He must give good blowies because he was atrocious, seriously looking at trading him to Parish.

 

[pincrusher]

He must give good blowies because he was atrocious, seriously looking at trading him to Parish.

I wish I had Parish from the start, but I wouldn't be getting him now at that price. First year player. Gonna run out of puff sooner or later. $260k for a first year rookie is massive coin.

 

[KenTucker]

Crouch going down has really left me stuck, not enough cash to upgrade to a keeper and downgrading to somebody like Ruggles or Hartly messes with structure. Even cutting Jesse Lonergan (who has been fine) all the way down to Ruggles left me $5k short or guys like Parker & Ward. I traded Rocky out to Mitchell last week, if I went Parker and had that extra 50K this plan may have worked.

Currently have a whopping 6k to spend

How much is Crouch forcast to drop $$$ wise? I may just have to have hit sit untill I can cut him down to Petracca soon and then use that cash to upgrade someone. I'll have to live with guys like Hewitt, no room to sideways to another rookie. McCarthy dropped this week hurts too.

Any ideas fellas? What to do with Crouchy?????

View attachment 235749

I'm in the same boat and doing nothing this week.

 

[KenTucker]

Sheridan & Brouch out for Dangerman & a Wiggle.

Leaves me fugg all cash though.

I've got Sherro and will give him a couple more weeks.

 

[KenTucker]

Are tom lynch (GCS) scores solid because he's a rarely discussed gun or because GCS are 3-0?

 

[KenTucker]

Being a brissy player, why is Zorko discussed so much?
No love for dahlhous or lynch?

I've got Lynch. My 2 upgrade targets are Dollhouse and the Magnificent one.

 

[SC fish]

Since McCarthy has been dropped/rested I think I just have to go B.Crouch > Parish now

Parish is $260k, have you thought about bringing in the cheaper rookies such as Hartley or Ruggles to save a bit of cash?

 

[karaoke]

Are tom lynch (GCS) scores solid because he's a rarely discussed gun or because GCS are 3-0?

Gun, a KPF worth having in SC.

 

[DraftPunk]

I've been slightly disappointed with Shiel and Wines so far. I thought they would tear it up this year. However, Shiel is still averaging a ton and we're only 3 games in. No way I'm trading him out at this point in time. Look at all the people that traded out Fyfe after the first week.

Shiel had an average first two weeks and still scored 100. Last week was on track for a 120+ until he came off with his back issue. He is not far away for ripping a game apart, a lot will be trading him in soon I reckon.

 

[joeyp]

with Barlow named on an extended bench would anyone think Barlow --> Hall is a waste of a trade?

I missed Hall and dont want to miss the boat completely.