Round 5 Trades

[karaoke]

Bump

Get Krak.

 

[stevebbb]

Bump

Get Krak.

+1
use the ~240k to try make a couple upgrades in the next few weeks

 

[gh172]

Thanks guys.

 

[karaoke]

For those thinking they would have to get rid of at least 1 fwd rookie to get in both Tarrant & Krak, not necessarily.

Hypothetically;

Mid rookie > Krak
Mid rookie > Tarrant (via Swan/Gray/Bont/Goddard etc M/F DPP)

Just because you don't want to move on Salem, Clark, Hogan etc. doesn't limit you from getting Tarrant in.

 

[ManWithNoName]

I'm torn between Lamb -> Tarrant (two forward bench players every week, removes a dead rookie, costs me $40k) or dumping someone like Heeney for Tarrant via Swan (leaves the emergency loophole up forward, gains me $90k).

 

[MrChristo]

Minson was dropped for disciplinary reasons (not agreeing with the gameplan)which seems a bit strange, so who knows.

There's also the fact that he's about the only big man in history to consistently av. more free kicks against than marks taken.

 

[bananatigz]

Richmond have at least 6 list cloggers that played last week (Arnott, Morris, Drummond, McDoughnut, Gordon, Lloyd) that would/should be dropped before McIntosh. Even if he's spudding up right now, he at least has potential to get better, unlike most of those plodders, and should be persevered with.

Big harsh on Drummond and McDonough but the others I agree with, and Kmac should hold his place for a while yet unless his form really drops off

 

[Krujan]

Big harsh on Drummond and McDonough but the others I agree with, and Kmac should hold his place for a while yet unless his form really drops off

Ok I take back Drummond, didn't realise it was only his 1st game. McDonut on the other hand, was my worst SC rookie pick last season. So far I haven't seen any improvement in him this year.

 

[Lums23]

Too late to bring in cripps??

No. He's pretty cheap for a super-premo

 

[Rillo]

Which way should I go?
A saad st kilda > Tarrant
B Harvey > Goldstein via dpp Ryder

Or a saad st kilda> Tarrant
B harvey> hogan and bank over $300k??

Thanks

Bump

 

[fantasyunit]

Bump

Probably the first one. Goldy is a must and Hogan has gained too much to get on now.

 

[Asho81]

Hi guys,
Who would I be best to cull first.... Tex Walker, Dan Rich or Newnes?
I have Goodes in the backline and IMO he is a better trade option than Newnes in the case that Newnes comes good (were all hoping!).....

Thinking of going Tex/Rich --> Tarrant, then Goodes --> McDonald/Hooker.
Are these bad sideways trades, or a decent move to secure Tarrant and add another premium to my terrible backline?

 

[Lums23]

Bump

First one of the two. Harvey will probably turn it around, but if you started with him it might be time to cut your losses. Especially if it's as a part of a trade to Goldstein

 

[bananatigz]

Ok I take back Drummond, didn't realise it was only his 1st game. McDonut on the other hand, was my worst SC rookie pick last season. So far I haven't seen any improvement in him this year.

Played one game as sub

 

[Double the Fist]

I think we need some kind of Griffen Anonymous support group.

Hi my name's The Steadier... and I have a Ryan Griffen problem.

Bloody hell mate, we're going to need a bigger room!

 

[DuckYeah]

Get Krak.

Trade krak for what? 150gs then he goes back to the rookie list? Is a trade worth 150? Im certainly not trading for him

 

[Asho81]

Trade krak for what? 150gs then he goes back to the rookie list? Is a trade worth 150? Im certainly not trading for him

Lol, okay.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Hi im toxic.

#I'llkeepgriffen

Hi my name is OhhhCyril and I have a Ryan Griffen problem. It was a dark Wednesday night before round 1 was due to kick off, and while finalising my team I felt this sudden urge to include him into my side. At the time I knew it was a bad idea in the back of my head but I just couldn't resist.

This is not the first time, last year I did the same thing, and told myself never again. Please help me.. Admitting I have a problem is the first step .

 

[TheOz]

First one of the two. Harvey will probably turn it around, but if you started with him it might be time to cut your losses. Especially if it's as a part of a trade to Goldstein

Problem with Harvey is he's been parked on a back flank and isn't getting too much of the ball.

 

[TheOz]

Hi guys,
Who would I be best to cull first.... Tex Walker, Dan Rich or Newnes?
I have Goodes in the backline and IMO he is a better trade option than Newnes in the case that Newnes comes good (were all hoping!).....

Thinking of going Tex/Rich --> Tarrant, then Goodes --> McDonald/Hooker.
Are these bad sideways trades, or a decent move to secure Tarrant and add another premium to my terrible backline?

Next week I reckon you'll be asking about who to trade McDonald/Hooker for after they score in the 60s. You don't have an unlimited supply of trades to keep doing stupid trades.

 

[Asho81]

Next week I reckon you'll be asking about who to trade McDonald/Hooker for after they score in the 60s.

Perhaps.... or maybe not
Doesn't everyone have issues with Newnes?

 

[TheOz]

Perhaps.... or maybe not
Doesn't everyone have issues with Newnes?

No because I never selected him.

 

[The_Steadier]

Hi my name is OhhhCyril and I have a Ryan Griffen problem. It was a dark Wednesday night before round 1 was due to kick off, and while finalising my team I felt this sudden urge to include him into my side. At the time I knew it was a bad idea in the back of my head but I just couldn't resist.

This is not the first time, last year I did the same thing, and told myself never again. Please help me.. Admitting I have a problem is the first step .

#sobrave

Like all of us in the group, you're likely to experience the seven stages of grief.
I happen to be stuck at Anger.

 

[NinjaSwan]

Perhaps.... or maybe not
Doesn't everyone have issues with Newnes?

Keeping Newnes, only reason his score was so bad on the weekend was because he was tagging due to Weller being injured.

 

[Double the Fist]

No because I never selected him.

..... he meant everyone except you.