- Nov 26, 2013
- 13,085
- 23,232
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Man U, Chicago Bulls, Anaheim Ducks
Any other player gets dropped for the shit cotch put out last week
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 17
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round 16 Winner: The Jet From Poowong
Preview Round 6 v Melbourne MCG Monday April 24th 7.25pm - ANZAC Eve
- Thread starter _RT_
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
play a full game in the ones then. he'll have more impact than cotch has been having.
sonz is probably the right call for sub with hugo dropping out. (cotch should make way)
What’s your point? He’s a Brownlow medalist and three-time premiership captain. If he puts out the same performance he probably will get managed but absolutely no point dropping him now when no one else is setting the world on fire.
It’s a slippery slope gifting games to players.
Sonsie hasn’t been good enough so far and is still building his tank.
Ralphsmith has been shit.
Ross has been slow and is no spring chicken. He offers little to the team. Essendon beat Melbourne with fast ball movement, Ross is the last player for that.
Dow shit, Banks not setting the world on fire yet, Bauer learning a new position.
Rioli has probably be brought in to help our forward line pressure which was off against Sydney. With Samson dropping everything we need a mosquito fleet hanging around.
Different intensity to seniors, not match fit enough. I do think Ross gets the short end of the stick at the selection table but on this occasion, i believe the right call was made.
Last edited:
- Nov 26, 2013
- 13,085
- 23,232
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Man U, Chicago Bulls, Anaheim Ducks
Unfortunately with the folks in charge, there’s no way in hell that’ll happen
Club has a way too friendly sort of vibe about itself
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Puzzling the Sonsie omission we're making our young players scapegoats for our experience lads who are letting us down bigtime weekly that's the real problem.
Cotch is a premiership captain we love him , but he should be sub or not play at all simple as that remember no one is bigger then the club.
Cotch is a premiership captain we love him , but he should be sub or not play at all simple as that remember no one is bigger then the club.
lost it at selection but we will win
Cotch late out…will be replaced by Sons
- Jan 18, 2016
- 1,656
- 7,880
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Being its Grimes's last game this week, hope he plays well and we send him off in style for the champion he was.
I knew this would happen to Cotch this year. Did anyone else just know he was going to miss that shot from 30m directly in front last week. I guess the goal is to get him to 300 as we did with Shedda. A young team but would prefer him to at least be playing in the guts in spurts if that's all his got. Just let him play the only position he can until it's time to hang em up.
If Cotchin has no impact, based on being a bit past it, match committee needs to cop some heat.
He's getting picked on sentiment and on name.
He's getting picked on sentiment and on name.
Dees mids strong bods, Oliver, petracca and viney. Cotchin can match them in the clinches, the only reason I can find over Sonsie.
If cotchin doesn't perform then no doubt Sonz (think he'll be the sub) will replace him sometime in the 2nd half
- May 15, 2017
- 22,891
- 87,649
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Dusty
came for the prodigy melts when I saw the news
disappointed there wasnt more to it but satisfied with the message
- May 15, 2017
- 22,891
- 87,649
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Dusty
I understand playing Cotch as he's a legend but I think Sonsie in that midfield position would maybe offer a bit more and be better for team balance as well. Meatball Taranto Hooper plus Bolton and Sonsie chipping in
Hope Cotchy plays a blinder so we don't have to read people tear into him after the game
Hope Cotchy plays a blinder so we don't have to read people tear into him after the game
he looks dehydrated. it gets like that on the billies, you forget to eat and drink water, just billies n beers will dehyge the f outta ya damos drink some water cuh
Not the moves I would have gone with personally but probably the most structurally balanced team we have fielded this year on the assumption that we see Cumberland continue his forward pressure (three pressure forwards now) and Short does indeed play HBF (another good ball user and runner and an upgrade of Ralphsmith).
Will await to see whom is the sub (will hope for Sonsie but expect it to be Ralphsmith). Sonsie will be fine, I don’t mind him getting a few games as a rotating half forward then going back to the VFL every now and then to play pure inside mid (his best position at the next level).
I wonder if this is a bit of going back to what we know works and we see Cotch more in the midfield; Dusty more as a forward flank (as opposed to almost pure forward) with more midfield stints.
Will await to see whom is the sub (will hope for Sonsie but expect it to be Ralphsmith). Sonsie will be fine, I don’t mind him getting a few games as a rotating half forward then going back to the VFL every now and then to play pure inside mid (his best position at the next level).
I wonder if this is a bit of going back to what we know works and we see Cotch more in the midfield; Dusty more as a forward flank (as opposed to almost pure forward) with more midfield stints.
- Status
Similar threads
