Round 8 trades

[Lachy Jamison]

thinking swallow then hibberd then bartel.. you cant go wrong with any of them though

traded mitchell to hibberd

thoughts on trading m thomas to acres then tyson to boyd ? or downgrade jaensch to gardiner and upgrade m thomas to boyd ??

Gardiner will get to 200k max, waste.

 

[elMM]

Mitchell > mcveigh

McDonald > HaRrY TAyLoR because I'm bloody reckless

Talk me out of it bigfooty

 

[toxic]

Need some help here:

Bringing a forward in, bruest or Cyril? Cyril about 30k for expensive but injury prone?

Thoughts?

Dude - really need your whole fwd line for others to offer any real help (if you call it that).

ideally your whole team as more often than not there are multiple options.

In terms of a flat out Cyril v Breust, I'd go breust

 

[JuddsABlue]

Mitchell to Burgoyn anyone?

Is by the far the best price for all similiar avgs

Going Lloyd (richmond) > Ambrose

All about setting up for next week to finally get son of god into my team

 

[toxic]

Mitchell to Burgoyn anyone?

Is by the far the best price for all similiar avgs

Going Lloyd (richmond) > Ambrose

All about setting up for next week to finally get son of god into my team

Lloyd to ambrose is padded cell material

 

[JuddsABlue]

Lloyd to ambrose is padded cell material

really?

gets me a field of 18 this week, Lloyd doesnt apear to have much more cash in him considering his inconsistency he could really tank, and I dont have any other tradable options in the forward line

Has a 3 round avg of 51, whats his JS like?

 

[Blueboys11]

Very strange advice. Can only be explained if you're playing Zane in a cash league this week.

There's plenty of point to a downgrade from Impey to Ambrose. As well as the immediate $60k profit from the trade you get the difference between Impey's projected loss of about $26,000 over the bye period and Ambrose's projected gain of about $107,000 in the same time. All up that alone is a gain of over $190,000 from the trade. Add to that the fact that Ambrose has shown he can score decent points. Anyone who has Impey and doesn't already have Ambrose should jump at that trade.

Well I won't be going anywhere near it. Much bigger fish to fry than making a trade to net me $60k

I assume you don't have JKH anymore?

Same logic. Sub affected scores for Impey and a lot better downgrade options coming through the mids than Ambrose

Can i have the next puff of whatever it is you are smoking, thatz some good sh1t

Impey couldnt score if he was the only bloke at a prom night for nymphomaniacs

I must of missed the 100's Ambrose pumped out before his injury??

Kicks a few lucky goals, scrounges out an 80 and people forget all about the 40 the week before

Lol

 

[toxic]

really?

gets me a field of 18 this week, Lloyd doesnt apear to have much more cash in him considering his inconsistency he could really tank, and I dont have any other tradable options in the forward line

Has a 3 round avg of 51, whats his JS like?

JS excellent

3 round average is not what it seems, he got knocked out in a game and it effected him for 2 weeks.

Will make at least another 150K minimum

 

[toxic]

Well I won't be going anywhere near it. Much bigger fish to fry than making a trade to net me $60k

I assume you don't have JKH anymore?

Same logic. Sub affected scores for Impey and a lot better downgrade options coming through the mids than Ambrose


I must of missed the 100's Ambrose pumped out before his injury??

Kicks a few lucky goals, scrounges out an 80 and people forget all about the 40 the week before

Lol

yep i have JKH, yep I have Lloyd and yep I have Ambrose all 3 will be the best fwd rookies for the year (eg: will make the most cash before being culled)

 

[JuddgementDay]

yep i have JKH, yep I have Lloyd and yep I have Ambrose all 3 will be the best fwd rookies for the year (eg: will make the most cash before being culled)

Wait a minute... didnt u ask why i've traded in Ambrose for crouch whislt i already have JKH & lloyd?
btw i needed ~$50k for the mitchell to mcveigh trade

 

[toxic]

Wait a minute... didnt u ask why i've traded in Ambrose for crouch whislt i already have JKH & lloyd?
btw i needed ~$50k for the mitchell to mcveigh trade

yes but you didnt need a 3rd rookie fwd, you had 6 gun fwds by memory, altho i could be wrong...apologies if i am wrong

 

[Saints_87]

is it worth doing impey to ambrose and jaensch to burgoyne??

 

[GAsnr]

Mitchell > mcveigh

McDonald > HaRrY TAyLoR because I'm bloody reckless

Talk me out of it bigfooty

I actually chuckled at this.

Reckless.

Spot on.

Edit: Mitchell to McVeigh is what I'm doing this week too. Got rid of McDonald last week with DPP for a mid premo

 

[hoddo]

Well I won't be going anywhere near it. Much bigger fish to fry than making a trade to net me $60k

I assume you don't have JKH anymore?

Same logic. Sub affected scores for Impey and a lot better downgrade options coming through the mids than Ambrose


I must of missed the 100's Ambrose pumped out before his injury??

Kicks a few lucky goals, scrounges out an 80 and people forget all about the 40 the week before

Lol

I already explained why Impey>Ambrose means a lot more than the obvious $60k. But if you don't like the trade that's fine. We all have to stick by our own decisions.

 

[GAsnr]

I already explained why Impey>Ambrose means a lot more than the obvious $60k. But if you don't like the trade that's fine. We all have to stick by our own decisions.

You can only do so much

 

[lids2richo]

who do people think have the better job security out of J.Lloyd (Syd) and Hallahan

 

[Blueboys11]

I already explained why Impey>Ambrose means a lot more than the obvious $60k. But if you don't like the trade that's fine. We all have to stick by our own decisions.

Each to there own, I just personally think it's a trade wasted making a virtually direct swap to another rookie who has limited scoring potential himself. Come 6-7 weeks time I expect both these players to have similar salaries

 

[LivDeeVic]

Anyone else thinking hodge will be a better option than burgoyne as a straight swap for mitchell.

Yes. But I ended up spending the extra 30k for Bartel

 

[The_Koach]

Backline issues!

McVeigh, Simpson, Swallow, Burgoyne, Suckling, Langford (McDonald, Ashby)

Thinking of dropping McDonald - who would be the best suited, under $515,700?

M Johnson v L Hodge v G Birchall v B Murphy?

Or any other that i should look out for?

Thanks in advance

 

[Saints_87]

who do people think have the better job security out of J.Lloyd (Syd) and Hallahan

im thinking lloyd for sure..

ended up going:
mitchell to burgoyne
jaensch to m johnson

 

[LivDeeVic]

Backline issues!

McVeigh, Simpson, Swallow, Burgoyne, Suckling, Langford (McDonald, Ashby)

Thinking of dropping McDonald - who would be the best suited, under $515,700?

M Johnson v L Hodge v G Birchall v B Murphy?

Or any other that i should look out for?

Thanks in advance

Hodge for mine

 

[lids2richo]

im thinking lloyd for sure..

I haven't seen Lloyd play. What's your reasoning? Hallahan named as follower and lloyd on the bench. And sydneys emergencys look better

 

[Jars458]

thinking swallow then hibberd then bartel.. you cant go wrong with any of them though

traded mitchell to hibberd

thoughts on trading m thomas to acres then tyson to boyd ? or downgrade jaensch to gardiner and upgrade m thomas to boyd ??

Defintley the second one. Tyson has money to make and Jaensch gone for at least three weeks. Problme is dont know how good Gardiner will bee whereas Acres looks the goods. Hard one.

 

[GAsnr]

who do people think have the better job security out of J.Lloyd (Syd) and Hallahan

I haven't seen Lloyd play. What's your reasoning? Hallahan named as follower and lloyd on the bench. And sydneys emergencys look better

Choice between 2 players with poor JS. That's my opinion anyway. LLoyd probably the better call, but only just.

 

[Saints_87]

I haven't seen Lloyd play. What's your reasoning? Hallahan named as follower and lloyd on the bench. And sydneys emergencys look better

oh oops i thought you mean richmonds lloyd, if its the other lloyd, i would go hallahan then