Round 9 Trades

[Socrates2]

People said the same thing about Lockhart after his first 2 games.

True enough but Stocker provides me with very little confidence.

 

[pincrusher]

I'm playing you this week , good luck ,I'm on absolute fire and just brought on Merrett and Dunkley.

Who did you trade out? Assuming Clarke was one?

 

[tommyv49]

Walsh to Dunkley this week. Could backfire spectacularly if dunkley goes back down for the forward line but gotta risk it for the biscuit eyy

 

[Papa Caz]

rowbottom or stocker?

 

[JDavey]

Mate, Stocker is a spud, dud and can't score. Stocker is a shocker. Hately the only viable option this week if picked

He managed 16 touches / 57 points against the side that is most difficult to score against this year despite 6 clangers. To me that says there is tonnes of potential for him to score well/average 55-60 the only question in JS IMO.

 

[Papa Caz]

Rowbottom

rowbottom over both?

 

[Socrates2]

Who did you trade out? Assuming Clarke was one?

No Walsh and Petrucelle, had money in bank from last week.

 

[Suma Magic]

If all three of Stocker, drew and Hately miss I’m screwed. Ideally just Stocker is named. I’ll probably double downgrade if hateley and Stocker are named, even though it will cost points in the short term.

 

[Papa Caz]

He managed 16 touches / 57 points against the side that is most difficult to score against this year despite 6 clangers. To me that says there is tonnes of potential for him to score well/average 55-60 the only question in JS IMO.

4 frees against also, i dont think he is that bad just think he had first game nerves

 

[vast]

When is simpson back? Id feel a lot more comfortable picking shocker alongside him though i still have the feeling he will continue to play.

My best bet is not to trade him or hately but i really dont wanna lose value on heeney and walsh but also really want Jelly. No idea wtf to do.

 

[stevebbb]

He managed 16 touches / 57 points against the side that is most difficult to score against this year despite 6 clangers. To me that says there is tonnes of potential for him to score well/average 55-60 the only question in JS IMO.

Agree. He had a good game against the Pies. Would have scored 65-70 if not for the 4 frees against. JS the only concern

That's why I'm waiting a week! BE of -3, will only go up to $150k-$170k even with a good score. Few players back next week, hopefully Simmo as well, so we'll see his JS. Maybe they'll throw him around and give him midfield minutes

 

[pincrusher]

No Walsh and Petrucelle, had money in bank from last week.

Yeah Walsh goes for me this week too. Just not sure who to yet. Gotta work out which one best fits my bye setup. Will be one of Telly, Jelly or Macrae. Probably Telly.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

When do the Sunday teams get finalized? Just need to see if Hatley gets picked or not so I can stop second guessing my trades every 10 minutes.

 

[pincrusher]

When do the Sunday teams get finalized? Just need to see if Hatley gets picked or not so I can stop second guessing my trades every 10 minutes.

5pm

 

[Edmund hunt]

Cogs with his hand injury may be out a couple of games. If that's the case is he worth upgrading?

 

[Unknown Identity]

Rowbottom's 2 games in the NEAFL since getting dropped.

54 disposals (30 kicks - 24 handballs)
16 tackles
18 Inside 50's

Pretty solid 2 weeks and Swans have brought him straight back, hopefully gets played a bit further up the ground.

 

[JDavey]

Agree. He had a good game against the Pies. Would have scored 65-70 if not for the 4 frees against. JS the only concern

That's why I'm waiting a week! BE of -3, will only go up to $150k-$170k even with a good score. Few players back next week, hopefully Simmo as well, so we'll see his JS. Maybe they'll throw him around and give him midfield minutes

He's a player that will cap out in the $250-300k range, I think you risk a lot by waiting and missing the first 30-50k price rise. Especially as you may not know his JS in one weeks time if one or both of Williamson/Simpson don't play.

 

[GAsnr]

Rowbottom's 2 games in the NEAFL since getting dropped.

54 disposals (30 kicks - 24 handballs)
16 tackles
18 Inside 50's

Pretty solid 2 weeks and Swans have brought him straight back, hopefully gets played a bit further up the ground.

They've got Pies, Cats, Eagles after North this week. Tough few weeks ahead.

 

[vast]

Dont know what to do with atkins should he play? Breakeven isnt that high even though the 12 stuffs abit him for 2 weeks
But with menegola out now i can see him still getting midfield time that he was getting.

Also I wonder if Collins is a max price now? His last game at AO was bad and they have a harder draw coming up where he will have to take a key forward.

I cant see him getting too loose against Ryder/hoff/lycett/, then he will have hawkins to worry about and then against Jezza.

So i guess the question is to trade out collins or atkins? Atkins has really good js which I really need in my midfield at the moment and the byes but to trade out collins both Answerth and Duursma will be in my backline. Though duursma could be getting the chop soon anyway. What to do?

 

[Edmund hunt]

Thoughts on Walsh trade options? I have 67k on top of Walsh. Also wondering if there is any positives as to bring in Jeremy cameron?

 

[pincrusher]

Matt Crouch officially out for tomorrow.

 

[Poetic Justice]

Whattayathink?

 

[stevebbb]

He's a player that will cap out in the $250-300k range, I think you risk a lot by waiting and missing the first 30-50k price rise. Especially as you may not know his JS in one weeks time if one or both of Williamson/Simpson don't play.

Fair enough. End of the day I'm taking Hately or Corbett this week, so can't bring him in. If he's the only option next week coming off a decent performance, I'll happily take him at a higher price. End of the day, if it gets the upgrade I want and the rookie plays over the byes I'm happy

 

[ROOINYOU]

Is it worth trading out cogs if i can bring in a player like Oliver or around the 530k+ mark? Or would brad couch being traded out be a better option?

send Cogs packing!
Oliver a great in and Brad still coring well enough.

 

[Papa Caz]

half my players either could be a late out or are already comfirmed out.

Wondering what i should do with this train wreak this week.

whitfield, smith, atkins, drew could all miss and im already covering crouch and cogs. HELP!