Re: Round 7 Trades
Dont trade cyril just yet, could bite u on the bum like gray has to many sc'ers.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Rounds 7 & 8 - Trades
- Thread starter Pout
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
russea
Club Legend
- Feb 6, 2010
- 1,040
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Fulham, Atlanta falcons, Canucks
Re: Round 7 Trades
Hmm still tossing this one up
Silvagni > Hams/Sheppard/Webberly/Roberton
Then
Hille > Cox
Really not sure what to do, is it worth taking a risk on one of those 4 just to get cox?
Any thoughts
Hmm still tossing this one up
Silvagni > Hams/Sheppard/Webberly/Roberton
Then
Hille > Cox
Really not sure what to do, is it worth taking a risk on one of those 4 just to get cox?
Any thoughts
Re: Round 7 Trades
Keep shuey, his price will still go up, he should be ur 2nd half of season cash cow upgrade.
Re: Round 7 Trades
I wouldn't do either russea...
I reckon save the trades and wait another week on Cox. I've been looking at bringing him in myself for Hille, BUT Hille has actually looked really good the last couple of weeks IMO. Possibly back to his old self.
He's averaged 22 disposals the last 3 weeks with scores of 76, 58 and 97 and I feel his score against Collingwood (58) didn't do him justice (though it is hard to get points in a team that looks horrible and gets smashed)... These games have been big DT scores too so it's just a matter of time before his DT/SC ratio improves, which we saw last week with his 97.
I think we'll continue to see him scoring 90+'s, like he used to pre-knee injury, which has ultimately resulted in me taking my finger off the 'T' button...... for now anyway!
I wouldn't do either russea...
I reckon save the trades and wait another week on Cox. I've been looking at bringing him in myself for Hille, BUT Hille has actually looked really good the last couple of weeks IMO. Possibly back to his old self.
He's averaged 22 disposals the last 3 weeks with scores of 76, 58 and 97 and I feel his score against Collingwood (58) didn't do him justice (though it is hard to get points in a team that looks horrible and gets smashed)... These games have been big DT scores too so it's just a matter of time before his DT/SC ratio improves, which we saw last week with his 97.
I think we'll continue to see him scoring 90+'s, like he used to pre-knee injury, which has ultimately resulted in me taking my finger off the 'T' button...... for now anyway!
Re: Round 7 Trades
Got a bit of a plan:
Kennelly -> Webberly (if he's named) or Roberton
Seaby -> Cox
Then next week:
Ziebell -> J.Brown
Then the week after:
Silvagni -> 100k
Hunt -> 500k
Leaves me with 16 premiums plus i'll keep Waters, Hille, Pods/Hall.
Then hopefully I can sit on my remaining ten trades for a couple of weeks, before upgrading Maguire, Martin and Hall/Pods
Wishful thinking, I doubt it will work in the end.
Got a bit of a plan:
Kennelly -> Webberly (if he's named) or Roberton
Seaby -> Cox
Then next week:
Ziebell -> J.Brown
Then the week after:
Silvagni -> 100k
Hunt -> 500k
Leaves me with 16 premiums plus i'll keep Waters, Hille, Pods/Hall.
Then hopefully I can sit on my remaining ten trades for a couple of weeks, before upgrading Maguire, Martin and Hall/Pods
Wishful thinking, I doubt it will work in the end.
Re: Round 7 Trades
Might regret it but Cyril is gone.
Might regret it but Cyril is gone.
russea
Club Legend
- Feb 6, 2010
- 1,040
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Fulham, Atlanta falcons, Canucks
Re: Round 7 Trades
Hmm Thats a very good point may hold off on hille then mabye
Just another idea
I still think silvagni has peaked B/E of 68, an avg of 67 and an injury concern i think now is a good time to trade him off so heres the idea
I can go
Silvagni > Hams
and then upgrade Hunt who has also just about peaked
So if i do the trade from above i can upgrade him to and player $469,400 or less. Meaning i can get a Gram or Fisher among that lot or go for the under priced Hargrave and still save a little cash
OR
can do Silvagni > Roberton
Which means i have $518500 i can spend for an upgrade, where i can spend a bit more and get a H.Shaw or Drummond or even Newman and save some cash
Is this again another waste of trades or am i on the right track
Hmm Thats a very good point may hold off on hille then mabye
Just another idea
I still think silvagni has peaked B/E of 68, an avg of 67 and an injury concern i think now is a good time to trade him off so heres the idea
I can go
Silvagni > Hams
and then upgrade Hunt who has also just about peaked
So if i do the trade from above i can upgrade him to and player $469,400 or less. Meaning i can get a Gram or Fisher among that lot or go for the under priced Hargrave and still save a little cash
OR
can do Silvagni > Roberton
Which means i have $518500 i can spend for an upgrade, where i can spend a bit more and get a H.Shaw or Drummond or even Newman and save some cash
Is this again another waste of trades or am i on the right track
- Jun 9, 2008
- 12,260
- 12,174
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Re: Round 7 Trades
Whats the synopsis on Hargrave? Is everyone jumping on the bandwagon or giving him one more week to prove that he's back?
I've got one spot left in my backline to fill, tossing up between Drummond or Hargrave (have Gilbee Hodge Goddard Malceski Enright Shaw already). The fact that Drummond has a high b/e and that im still unsure on Hargrave is pushing me towards waiting another week to see how they both go.
The only other trades I need to do in the next month are upgrades on Medhurst (urgently) and Hall (can wait on this as he is scoring decently). Being able to save cash by picking Hargrave over Drumming would help immensely.
All my cows aren't ripe for picking yet so in order to make the most of current upgrading opportunities ill need to use the $250k ive got in the bank wisely
Whats the synopsis on Hargrave? Is everyone jumping on the bandwagon or giving him one more week to prove that he's back?
I've got one spot left in my backline to fill, tossing up between Drummond or Hargrave (have Gilbee Hodge Goddard Malceski Enright Shaw already). The fact that Drummond has a high b/e and that im still unsure on Hargrave is pushing me towards waiting another week to see how they both go.
The only other trades I need to do in the next month are upgrades on Medhurst (urgently) and Hall (can wait on this as he is scoring decently). Being able to save cash by picking Hargrave over Drumming would help immensely.
All my cows aren't ripe for picking yet so in order to make the most of current upgrading opportunities ill need to use the $250k ive got in the bank wisely
Re: Round 7 Trades
Yeah personally I'm waiting a week to see if he's back Krueze... If he does get another 90+ score his price increase should easily be matched by the increase in the player you want to upgrade anyway. For example: for me, Nason should increase a similar amount (if not more) to Hargrave so there's no harm in waiting a week and seeing if he really is 'back'
Whats the synopsis on Hargrave? Is everyone jumping on the bandwagon or giving him one more week to prove that he's back?
I've got one spot left in my backline to fill, tossing up between Drummond or Hargrave (have Gilbee Hodge Goddard Malceski Enright Shaw already). The fact that Drummond has a high b/e and that im still unsure on Hargrave is pushing me towards waiting another week to see how they both go.
The only other trades I need to do in the next month are upgrades on Medhurst (urgently) and Hall (can wait on this as he is scoring decently). Being able to save cash by picking Hargrave over Drumming would help immensely.
All my cows aren't ripe for picking yet so in order to make the most of current upgrading opportunities ill need to use the $250k ive got in the bank wisely
Yeah personally I'm waiting a week to see if he's back Krueze... If he does get another 90+ score his price increase should easily be matched by the increase in the player you want to upgrade anyway. For example: for me, Nason should increase a similar amount (if not more) to Hargrave so there's no harm in waiting a week and seeing if he really is 'back'
JuddgementDay
Brownlow Medallist
Re: Round 7 Trades
I need a cheap rookie midfield.
Who do you guys suggest?
Melksham, Howlett or someone else?
Who would have better job security out of Melksham & Howlett?
I need a cheap rookie midfield.
Who do you guys suggest?
Melksham, Howlett or someone else?
Who would have better job security out of Melksham & Howlett?
YOTC
Brownlow Medallist
Re: Round 7 Trades
Thinking
Jetta -> Rohan/Macdonald -> Newman
or
Silvangi -> Roberton/Macdonald -> Newman
Thinking
Jetta -> Rohan/Macdonald -> Newman
or
Silvangi -> Roberton/Macdonald -> Newman
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
Re: Round 7 Trades
should l pull the pin on roughy ? surly he cant get any lower or can he
should l pull the pin on roughy ? surly he cant get any lower or can he
Re: Round 7 Trades
I'd take the Jetta trade because Rohan's selection has been confirmed.
Help with mine?
1. Peterson to Fyfe
2. Peterson to Pavlich
3. Leave Peterson in side.
I'd take the Jetta trade because Rohan's selection has been confirmed.
Help with mine?
1. Peterson to Fyfe
2. Peterson to Pavlich
3. Leave Peterson in side.
russea
Club Legend
- Feb 6, 2010
- 1,040
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Fulham, Atlanta falcons, Canucks
Re: Round 7 Trades
Okay after a big long think on what i should do iv come up with these options
1. JKT > Howlett and Hunt > Hargrave/Kennelly/Harry O
Then Next week see how roberton goes and a possible
Silvagni > Roberton
and
Hille > Cox
2. Silvagni > Hams and Hille > Cox
3. JKT > Howlett
Stick with both Hille and Hunt and wait until next week to see how diffrent players went.
Atm im thinking 1 or 3 mabye 1 but im not sure who to go for
any thoughts??
Okay after a big long think on what i should do iv come up with these options
1. JKT > Howlett and Hunt > Hargrave/Kennelly/Harry O
Then Next week see how roberton goes and a possible
Silvagni > Roberton
and
Hille > Cox
2. Silvagni > Hams and Hille > Cox
3. JKT > Howlett
Stick with both Hille and Hunt and wait until next week to see how diffrent players went.
Atm im thinking 1 or 3 mabye 1 but im not sure who to go for
any thoughts??
Re: Round 7 Trades
Trengove >>> Howlett
For the extra $30k Trengove MIGHT grow, Howlett will go up $70k. Considering they're both cows, it's the right move.
Rioli >>> Brown
Rioli was always a potential keeper but not a premium. Time to get rid of him before he costs me more (already down $30k and he has a BE of 155). Brown has a BE of 137 which he'll go pretty close to given his form.
The $150k upgrade to Brown still leaves me with $100k in the pocket from both trades. Now that's good super coaching!
Steering clear of Fyfe because his JS is a worry and two good scores against Richmond & WCE don't exactly inspire me.
Trengove >>> Howlett
For the extra $30k Trengove MIGHT grow, Howlett will go up $70k. Considering they're both cows, it's the right move.
Rioli >>> Brown
Rioli was always a potential keeper but not a premium. Time to get rid of him before he costs me more (already down $30k and he has a BE of 155). Brown has a BE of 137 which he'll go pretty close to given his form.
The $150k upgrade to Brown still leaves me with $100k in the pocket from both trades. Now that's good super coaching!
Steering clear of Fyfe because his JS is a worry and two good scores against Richmond & WCE don't exactly inspire me.
russea
Club Legend
- Feb 6, 2010
- 1,040
- 0
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Fulham, Atlanta falcons, Canucks
Re: Round 7 Trades
Peterson > Pav looks very very nice but more than likely (may be wrong) but it will take up most of or all of ur salary cap money. So if u desperatly need upgrades in other posistions leave peterson in the side
but if uv got enough cash and think it is the best spot where you can use ur money go ahead and make the trade
Peterson > Pav looks very very nice but more than likely (may be wrong) but it will take up most of or all of ur salary cap money. So if u desperatly need upgrades in other posistions leave peterson in the side
but if uv got enough cash and think it is the best spot where you can use ur money go ahead and make the trade
Re: Round 7 Trades
Not coninced Rohan is a good pick up. Ggood player but his SC performance might be a question.
I'm holding Hille. I still think there's a lot of upside in him and has shown a little bit over the last few games. besides, the Cox/NicNat combination is costing them both SC points IMO.
Not coninced Rohan is a good pick up. Ggood player but his SC performance might be a question.
I'm holding Hille. I still think there's a lot of upside in him and has shown a little bit over the last few games. besides, the Cox/NicNat combination is costing them both SC points IMO.
LiverpoolRed
Club Legend
Re: Round 7 Trades
Nah mate keep him, for atleast this week, is playing as the solo target this week with no Buddy, this could be make or break, but he is good enough to take full advantage.
Re: Round 7 Trades
Not completely sold that Bastinac is peaking. Has an 88 b/e this week, but then (if he holds his ave) should rise about $30k in next 3 weeks. Not a must-hold, but not an urgent sell either.
Silvagni, as above. Has a 68 b/e this week, but should then continue to rise after that. What's the injury concern though?
As for me, i'm probably going Raines > Roberton, Rioli to FWD premium (probably SuperPav).
Not completely sold that Bastinac is peaking. Has an 88 b/e this week, but then (if he holds his ave) should rise about $30k in next 3 weeks. Not a must-hold, but not an urgent sell either.
Silvagni, as above. Has a 68 b/e this week, but should then continue to rise after that. What's the injury concern though?
As for me, i'm probably going Raines > Roberton, Rioli to FWD premium (probably SuperPav).
rocker_oz33
TheBrownDog
Re: Round 7 Trades
cheers mate l should/could keep him but my forward line is pretty bad with roughy jbrown balla pods lecra proplza hall (Duncan pdavis) l want to add a pav or a rok even goodes or someone l thought these players would do alright l was wrong
cheers mate l should/could keep him but my forward line is pretty bad with roughy jbrown balla pods lecra proplza hall (Duncan pdavis) l want to add a pav or a rok even goodes or someone l thought these players would do alright l was wrong
nicolbolas
Team Captain
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer Sponsor 2016
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer Sponsor 2014
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2012 Player Sponsor
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2011 Player Sponsor
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2010 Player Sponsor
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2009 Player Sponsor
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2008 Player Sponsor
Re: Round 7 Trades
went Gumbleton to Fyfe, then Nason to Hodge. Still have 50K+
went Gumbleton to Fyfe, then Nason to Hodge. Still have 50K+
DemonJim
I feel the need, the need for speed!
- Mar 25, 2008
- 24,506
- 18,704
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Atlanta Braves - Indianapolis Colts
Re: Round 7 Trades
Reimers -> Fyfe
Medhurst -> Pavlich
Reimers -> Fyfe
Medhurst -> Pavlich
Re: Round 7 Trades
Duude.... That's a horrible trade. I don't know what the rest of your fwd line is but that's just horrible.
Why??
Gumby will get picked every week.
Gumby has a BE of 10 so is completley undervalued.
Gumby is getting a regular 50+ score. Very handy for F7 or bench cover.
Fyfe has scored well but against Rich & WCE.
Will Fyfe play next week?
Duude.... That's a horrible trade. I don't know what the rest of your fwd line is but that's just horrible.Why??
Gumby will get picked every week.
Gumby has a BE of 10 so is completley undervalued.
Gumby is getting a regular 50+ score. Very handy for F7 or bench cover.
Fyfe has scored well but against Rich & WCE.
Will Fyfe play next week?
Re: Round 7 Trades
Have never before considered Chappy for SC due to his durability concerns, but I find myself wavering a bit today. I have $708k to spend on Rioli's replacement, was all set to bring in Pavlich, but now am wondering if Chappy might be worth the risk. Would love some feedback on the potential replacements...
FWD: J Brown, ROK, Franklin, Higgins, Hall, Rioli, Pods (Duncan & Roberts)
Chappy $646k, 129.8 ave
Pav $566k, 111.8
Didak $511k, 96.3
Harvey $507k, 92.8
*All the above replacement options have the dual-positioning option.
Have never before considered Chappy for SC due to his durability concerns, but I find myself wavering a bit today. I have $708k to spend on Rioli's replacement, was all set to bring in Pavlich, but now am wondering if Chappy might be worth the risk. Would love some feedback on the potential replacements...
FWD: J Brown, ROK, Franklin, Higgins, Hall, Rioli, Pods (Duncan & Roberts)
Chappy $646k, 129.8 ave
Pav $566k, 111.8
Didak $511k, 96.3
Harvey $507k, 92.8
*All the above replacement options have the dual-positioning option.
- Status
