Its funny i looked at Gilberts disposal accuracy on the club site and he had one of the highest at the club this year??????
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Review Saints vs Cats review
- Thread starter freebloke
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Yeah, I'm actually a big advocate for Gilbert, he's just a whipping boy.
gringo2011
Premium Platinum
I don't think the issue is that one gun player. Or at least he wouldn't have helped today. The whole team were done by about halfway through the last quarter. One gun player (as much as we need him) wouldn't have made too much of a difference. Of course, we need to go out and get a Dusty or a Fyfe or even a Hopper (seriously throw all the cash we have at this guy) but we can't just brush off today because we're a couple of elite players short.
Questions need to be asked about why we have not been able to run out either the WCE game or this one. At least it was hot in Perth but today? Either we need to have moments in the quarter where we just slow it down for a while or our whole fitness regime needs to be looked at. Perhaps the lack of fitness is also one reason why we're missing so many shots at goal? It's very hard to kick them when you're gassed.
I thought Ross was immense today. I've been a huge backer since day one, so great to see him dominate. I would call myself an awesome pick of talent but I also thought that Siposs and Stanley would be good. Anyway, Ross is a boss
Stuv came back pretty well and the defence was strong again. Ultimately after five rounds, I think it's clear we need to address the depth of our midfield, our fitness, lack of forward ruck, any possible tinkering with the game plan and also the development of the kids. Seems like a long list but we're almost there in all points. Just a 10% improvement across the board and we'd be sitting 5-0 right now. The question is if the club, as a whole, is good enough to find that improvement? It'll be fun watching!
Good news is that we usually back up disappointment with a good performance. So, next week should be great
It's our game plan that is killing us. If you sit on level three you see their work rate it's just a super taxing effort that keep us in games. We are pretty much the same as under Ross Lyon with a game plan that is extremely tight but players of limited ability.
dan0z
Club Legend
Pretty disappointed today, thought we really had a good chance to win.
But just beaten by a better team today. Cats really good without the ball.
Dunston, Weller, and Bruce are really out of form, think dunston needs a rest.
Not sure what to do about rucks, hopefully club gets that sorted.
Ross excellent, backline looking solid. We seem to play our best when Newnes and Billings are up and running, maybe new barometers?
I've been impressed with Steele this season so far, remember he's young and had interrupted pre season. Liking Geary as captain also, I think he has stepped up.
Out: dunston Long
In: Stevens Sincs/Rice maybe give him a debut?
But just beaten by a better team today. Cats really good without the ball.
Dunston, Weller, and Bruce are really out of form, think dunston needs a rest.
Not sure what to do about rucks, hopefully club gets that sorted.
Ross excellent, backline looking solid. We seem to play our best when Newnes and Billings are up and running, maybe new barometers?
I've been impressed with Steele this season so far, remember he's young and had interrupted pre season. Liking Geary as captain also, I think he has stepped up.
Out: dunston Long
In: Stevens Sincs/Rice maybe give him a debut?
Disappointing that we fell away in the midfield in the last, but let's compare the 2 midfields...
St Kilda: Ross (23), Steven (27), Steele (21), Newnes (24), Billings (21), Acres (21), Dunstan (22), Longer (23)
AVERAGE AGE = 22/23ish
Geelong: Selwood (28), Duncan (25), Dangerfield (27), H-Smith (24), Bliclavs (26), Guthrie (24), Smith (27), Parfitt (18)
AVERAGE AGE = 24/25ish
The difference is around around 2 years per player - which is around 40 AFL games.
Geelong will probably make the top 4 this year and we more than matched for 3/4 of that game.
For our stage of development we're tracking pretty well IMO.
St Kilda: Ross (23), Steven (27), Steele (21), Newnes (24), Billings (21), Acres (21), Dunstan (22), Longer (23)
AVERAGE AGE = 22/23ish
Geelong: Selwood (28), Duncan (25), Dangerfield (27), H-Smith (24), Bliclavs (26), Guthrie (24), Smith (27), Parfitt (18)
AVERAGE AGE = 24/25ish
The difference is around around 2 years per player - which is around 40 AFL games.
Geelong will probably make the top 4 this year and we more than matched for 3/4 of that game.
For our stage of development we're tracking pretty well IMO.
St BKD
Club Legend
I'm considering a move. Can't stand been so close to that club.
I watched the replay when I got home with my Cat on my lap... she hates Geelong as much as I do
On SM-G935F using BigFooty.com mobile app
His problem is going in and out of the game for extended periods imo. Goes as hard as any, just needs to fix his goal kicking
Don't know where you got these stats from ??
Plugger35
Umpiring Expert
- Sep 27, 2008
- 139,980
- 162,500
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Chelsea, Black Caps, Sea Eagles, Subiaco
Some people need to learn how to space out their rants, if you post a block of text rant I won't read it no matter how many good points you might make.
Put you rants in easy to read posts separated by a line of space like I just did there and it will make it easier for all of us.
Put you rants in easy to read posts separated by a line of space like I just did there and it will make it easier for all of us.
absolute belter yarn
Not sure what's happening with our forwardline at the moment, but when two 50+ goal kickers are only averaging 1.4 goals a game when the team is kinking 80+ points then something isn't right.
Bruce and ruck should not be in the same sentence ever again. I'd rather play with a mid less and have two genuine rucks than him doing it.
Next week is a crucial game for us, we win and finals are still on the agenda. If we lose its pretty much curtain for this year.
Outs: Dunstan Long
Ins: Hickey Stevens
Bruce and ruck should not be in the same sentence ever again. I'd rather play with a mid less and have two genuine rucks than him doing it.
Next week is a crucial game for us, we win and finals are still on the agenda. If we lose its pretty much curtain for this year.
Outs: Dunstan Long
Ins: Hickey Stevens
dan0z
Club Legend
Does anyone know the average age of both teams today?
Kilroy
Hall of Famer
- Nov 10, 2013
- 32,106
- 87,771
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Also think Longer should stay in the team. Has a lot to improve on around the ground but I would take his tap work in the middle any day over that. Our midfielders actually got first use of the footy and it showed!
Armitage is cooked mate
- Mar 5, 2016
- 794
- 2,459
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
I reckon just dump Gilbert in the ruck instead of Bruce. More or less the same thing in terms of hitouts but at least Bruce gets to stay forward and kick goals.
If he doesn't come back this midfield is cooked bro
saintwazza
Team Captain
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2022
St Kilda - James Frawley Player Sponsor 2021
Saints Pledge Contributor
St Kilda - Doulton Langlands Player Sponsor 2020
St Kilda - Robbie Young Player Sponsor 2019
Reimagine Moorabbin
St Kilda - Nathan Freeman Player Sponsor 2018
St Kilda - Nathan Freeman Player Sponsor 2017
I think Billy longer was pretty good today so I hope he stays in and we bring Hickey back. Josh Bruce in the ruck is a waste of time we just lose the hit outs and clearances whenever he is in there. That also puts our forward line out of whack so it would be a lot more stable if he's in there all the time with skunk
Haven't read the thread, but a few of my thoughts.
Dunstan needs to be dropped in order to regain form in the VFL. He is a liability and our match committee seriously shouldn't be able to look themselves in the mirror if they select him next week.
Additionally, Long isn't ready. Needs to go back and work on things in the VFL.
Sinclair should be in the side ahead of either of the above. Always looked classy at AFL level, and is far too good for VFL.
Stevens also should get some game time, can play mid, can play half forward, and will almost definitely have more impact than either Dunstan or Long.
Longer was good in the first half, but became tired far too quickly. If he's only fit enough to play 76% tog than he can't play when our back up is Bruce. Bruce is a total liability in the ruck, and increased game time there seriously impacts his influence as a key forward. Hickey plays 90% of a game, and has far more impact around the ground than Billy at this stage. In sharing that, I wouldn't mind Billy getting a few games in a row, because it's not too much of a difference.
Also, Carlisle should be given a go as a back up, he couldn't possibly be any worse than Bruce.
Dunstan needs to be dropped in order to regain form in the VFL. He is a liability and our match committee seriously shouldn't be able to look themselves in the mirror if they select him next week.
Additionally, Long isn't ready. Needs to go back and work on things in the VFL.
Sinclair should be in the side ahead of either of the above. Always looked classy at AFL level, and is far too good for VFL.
Stevens also should get some game time, can play mid, can play half forward, and will almost definitely have more impact than either Dunstan or Long.
Longer was good in the first half, but became tired far too quickly. If he's only fit enough to play 76% tog than he can't play when our back up is Bruce. Bruce is a total liability in the ruck, and increased game time there seriously impacts his influence as a key forward. Hickey plays 90% of a game, and has far more impact around the ground than Billy at this stage. In sharing that, I wouldn't mind Billy getting a few games in a row, because it's not too much of a difference.
Also, Carlisle should be given a go as a back up, he couldn't possibly be any worse than Bruce.
Bring forth the rhetoric Rhett
Similar threads
- Locked
